1. Home
  2. Kim Grauer

Kim Grauer

Crypto scams are down 77% — but this exploit is making a huge comeback

Attackers of this kind are supposedly "big game hunting” large-scale organizations with deep pockets to extract ”the most money possible” out of these firms.

Cryptocurrency scams have fallen a massive 77% from $3.3 billion to $1.1 billion over the first six months of 2023, according to a recent report by blockchain intelligence firm Chainalysis.

The catch, though, is that ransom attacks are back in trend, with perpetrators pocketing 62.4% more revenue than the first six months of 2022.

On July 12, Chainalysis released its Mid Year Crypto Crime report, noting it’s the second consecutive year that scam revenue has trended downwards.

The firm observed that historically, scam revenue increases in bull markets — but that hasn’t been the case so far in 2023:

“Usually, positive price movements translate to higher scam revenue, likely because increased market exuberance and FOMO make victims more susceptible to scammers’ pitches. But 2023’s drastic scam decline bucks that long-standing trend.”

Inflows into known illicit entities fell 65% over the first six months of 2023 compared to the same timeframe last year, while inflows to risky entities — such as cryptocurrency mixers and high-risk exchanges — fell 42%.

While Chainalysis partially attributed the drop to decreasing transaction volumes, it explained that illicit inflows have fallen at a faster rate:

“Transaction volumes are down across the board, but declines are much less severe for legitimate services, which have seen just a 28% drop in inflows.”
Cumulative flows for legitimate, risky and illicit services from January 1 to June 30 for 2020-2023. Source: Chainalysis.

Kim Grauer, director of research at Chainalysis told Cointelegraph that past scam victims may also be becoming more “scrupulous” with their investment decisions and, as a result, may no longer be falling for the bait thrown out by scammers. This may also be contributing to the fall in scam revenue.

“It’s entirely possible that scam victims have learned to be more scrupulous,” the firm said. “It’s also likely that government and industry awareness campaigns, as well as media reporting, has helped educate people on the risks of scamming.”

Chainalysis warned that artificial intelligence tools may increasingly be used to promote scams through the use of deepfakes, among other things.

“Given the growing prominence of romance and pig butchering scams, one thing to look out for is the use of AI to increase effectiveness and scale, since those scams are largely text-based.”

Hacks also fell by $1.1 billion from the first six months of 2022, according to Chainalysis.

Ransom perpetrators are ‘big game hunting’ deep pocketed firms

Not everything has improved across the board, however. Ransomware revenue increased 62.4% to $449.1 million in the first half of 2023. through June.

The reason, according to Chainalysis, is that attackers are now “big game hunting” large-scale organizations with deep pockets to extract ”the most money possible” out of firms willing to pay up.

“Why the reversal in fortunes? For one thing, big game hunting — that is, the targeting of large, deep-pocketed organizations by ransomware attackers — seems to have bounced back after a lull in 2022.”

These attackers are on track for their second-biggest year ever, trailing 2021’s full year figure of $940 million by 4.6%.

Cumulative flows for ransomware revenue from January 1 to June 30 for 2022 and 2022. Source: Chainalysis

Chainalysis quoted Risk Officer Andrew J. Davis of cybercrime consulting firm Kivu said the decrease in 2022 could be attributed to stronger cybersecurity practices and new laws that impose stricter sanctions against paying ransoms.

As a result, ransom attackers are now likely trying to ”squeeze the most money possible” out of firms willing to pay ransoms, Davis added.

Chainalysis added payment sizes extracted by the largest perpetrators have increased substantially.

Related: Pink, Pussy, Venom, Inferno — Drainers coming for a crypto wallet near you

The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime unit found in October 2021 that ransoms take place every 11 seconds around the world, which resulted in a total damage cost of $20 billion in 2021 alone.

Cybersecurity Ventures predicted in June that ransomware will cost its victims $265 billion annually by 2031.

Chainalysis noted that all figures are a “lower bound estimate” and that illicit and risky transaction volume will likely increase over time as new illicit activity is found.

In addition, the data doesn’t include crime where cryptocurrency is used as a mode of payment.

Collect this article as an NFT to preserve this moment in history and show your support for independent journalism in the crypto space.

Magazine: $3.4B of Bitcoin in a popcorn tin — The Silk Road hacker’s story

MicroStrategy completes $3 billion convertible notes offering to buy more Bitcoin

Crypto crime’s overall impact set to fall even further in 2022: Chainalysis

“Cash is still king when it comes to illicit finance, and that is not likely to change,” says Chainalysis researcher Kim Grauer.

The coming year is likely to see crypto related crime reduce to an ever smaller share of the overall industry as law enforcement takes greater advantage of the transparency provided by blockchain technology, says Kim Grauer, Director of Research at Chainalysis. 

According to a January 6 report from Chainalysis, the growth of legitimate cryptocurrency usage is “far outpacing the growth of criminal usage.” The share of cryptocurrency transaction volume associated with illicit activity has never been lower, representing just 0.15% of transaction volume in 2021.

She told Cointelegraph that barring any “outlier criminal events,” she expected that the growth of legitimate crypto usage over illegitimate usage would continue to accelerate through 2022.

She said that things are looking hopeful in the space as “the illicit share of transaction volume continues to fall” and “the narrative that crypto is primarily a means for criminals to transact is finally being put to bed.”

“Law enforcement wins continue to demonstrate to bad actors that cryptocurrency’s inherent transparency makes it an undesirable means for transferring illicit funds. Cash is still king when it comes to illicit finance, and that is not likely to change.”

During 2021, rug pulls became crypto-criminals' scam of choice. Scamming revenue rose 82% in 2021 to $7.8 billion, with over $2.8 billion of this total coming from rug pulls alone.

However, Grauer said that this doesn’t necessarily indicate rug pulls will remain the most prevalent scam during 2022. Rather, criminals are likely to “abuse newer technologies” like DeFi, NFTs and DAOs as the space moves towards web3.

“We saw this [in 2021] especially with DeFi, where criminals not only targeted DeFi platforms for attacks such as through hacks or rug pulls, but started increasingly using DeFi platforms to launder money.”

Additionally, Grauer suggested that while she didn't expect a potential crypto bear market would affect the rate, or type, of crypto crime, a major financial recession or depression could.

“When you consider overall economic markets — not just crypto — recessions and depressions can drive an increase in criminal activity,” she said.

Related: Retail buyers made up more than 80% of NFT transactions in 2021: Chainalysis

During 2021, law enforcement agencies around the world had many notable successes. In Nov. 2021, the IRS Criminal Investigations announced that it had seized over $3.5 billion worth of cryptocurrency in 2021 from non-tax investigations.

While the proportion was lower, cryptocurrency-based crime actually hit a new all-time high in 2021, with illicit addresses receiving $14 billion over the course of the year, up from $7.8 billion in 2020 according to Chainalysis.

MicroStrategy completes $3 billion convertible notes offering to buy more Bitcoin