1. Home
  2. Crypto City Guides

Crypto City Guides

5050 Bitcoin for $5 in 2009: Helsinki’s claim to crypto fame

Helsinki played host to the first Bitcoin for fiat transaction in 2009 — 5050 Bitcoin for $5 — 6 months before Pizza Day. Crypto City Guide.

This Crypto City guide looks at Finlands crypto culture: The most notable projects and people, its financial infrastructure, which retailers accept crypto, and where you can find blockchain education courses.

City: Helsinki
Country: Finland
Population: 1.55 million 
Established: 1550
Languages: Finnish and Swedish, with English widely spoken

Jump to: Crypto Culture, Where to spend crypto in Helsinki, Crypto projects and companies, Local crypto controversies, Crypto education and community, Notable crypto figures from Helsinki

Situated on the Gulf of Finland, Helsinki is the capital of Finland and is arguably the world’s most northern metropolis, with 1.5 million people 30% of the countrys population calling the metro area home. Its inhabitants spend winter in a cold, still darkness but enjoy 11 pm sunsets in summertime.

Helsinki Cathedral at sunrise, after a night of partying
Helsinki Cathedral at sunrise, after a night of partying. (Elias Ahonen)

Major population centers are nearby, with both Tampere and Turku reachable in two hours via road or rail. There are regular ferry services across the Baltic including to Estonias capital of Tallinn, which can be reached in two hours by sea, and there are also plans to link the cities via an undersea tunnel. The nearby Helsinki-Vantaa airport is the countrys main international gateway and serves as a transfer hub for Asia.

Finland has been ranked the happiest country in the world for six consecutive years by the World Happiness Report. Its income tax rate tops out at 56% one of the highest in the world and the tax data of every resident is public. Helsinki played host to the 1952 Summer Olympics. The country joined the European Union in 1995 and adopted the euro as its currency in 1999. In 2023, Finland became a member of NATO.

As the capital, Helsinkis crypto events draw participants from across the country, making it the natural meeting place for the industry. For that reason, projects and companies from nearby cities like Tampere and Turku are also included here.

The area was first settled around 5,000 BC as the ice age retreated. Vikings raided the established settlements, as did Swedish crusaders in the 10th and 13th centuries. The city was formally established in 1550 as a Swedish trading post, defended by Suomenlinna (Finland’s fortress), the largest sea fort in Europe. Later, under Russian control as the Grand Duchy of Finland, the emperor moved the capital from Turku to Helsinki, which was closer to St. Petersburg. Finland became independent in 1917, after which it resisted Soviet occupation in the 1940 Winter War.

The Finnish Parliament
The Finnish Parliament. (Elias Ahonen)

Crypto Culture

Helsinkis claim to crypto fame rests with Martti Malmi, a software developer who in 2009 sold 5,050 Bitcoin (BTC) for a $5.02 PayPal transfer, marking the first time that Bitcoin was exchanged for fiat currency. It occurred before the much better-known May 22, 2010, “Pizza Day,” when Bitcoin was first used to purchase a physical good. Eventually, Malmi used most of his Bitcoins to purchase a studio in the metro area. If he’d hung on to them, they’d be worth $171 million today. The Bitcoin was used to seed an exchange called New Liberty Standard, which established the first BTC price of 1,309.03 Bitcoin for $1.

Malmi was in some ways a product of his environment, with Helsinki recognized as a bed of technical innovation since Nokia began to dominate the cellphone market. In 1991, Linus Torvalds began working on what became Linux at the University of Helsinki. It is also home to many video game companies, with local firm Rovios Angry Birds achieving global fame in 2009. Helsinki is also the home of Aave founder Stani Kulechov, though he has moved abroad with the company.

In 2019, a then-staunchly Bitcoin maximalist group called Konsensus organized the translation of Saifedean Ammous 2018 book The Bitcoin Standard into Finnish, and later also translated The Little Bitcoin Book by The Bitcoin Collective. According to one member, the organization has since become more accepting of other cryptocurrencies and blockchain use cases.

The crypto community in Helsinki and Finland is somewhat disorganized and divided, with many enthusiasts being interested in one facet be it Bitcoin, NFTs, or Web3 without embracing the whole, and thus having few common threads. Still, a certain grassroots energy is evident.

Founding meeting of The Finnish Bitcoin Association in Helsinki on May 6, 2023
Founding meeting of The Finnish Bitcoin Association in Helsinki on May 6, 2023. (Elias Ahonen)

Where can I spend crypto in Helsinki?

Paying with Bitcoin is not common in Finland, where card and app payments dominate. One notable exception is the restaurant Faro, at which a few people are likely to buy a burger and beers with sats at the monthly Bitcoin meetup.

On the bar side, Taudo Baari and Time Bar also accept crypto. There is also the Osuva shooting range.

Samuel Harjunp, CEO and co-founder of hardware startup Xellox and regular at the Faro Bitcoin meetup, comments to Magazine on the state of Bitcoin acceptance:

A few restaurants and bars have already been orange-pilled’ the biggest obstacles are the payment infrastructure and bookkeeping.

Crypto projects and companies in Helsinki

Today, Helsinki has a vibrant tech and startup scene with many coworking spaces. The city is also host to the annual Slush startup conference, which draws 25,000 participants.

Web3 Helsinki is a student-run organization that organized its first event on April 20, 2020, with about 150 people in attendance, making it perhaps the largest single crypto event of the year.

This year’s events have included the Web3 Bash in late April, followed by the Aurora Nordic Web3 Conference in June. On June 6, the BRIDG3 Blockchain summit was held at Tamperes Nokia Arena, focusing on Web3, the metaverse and decentralized autonomous organizations.

The Aurora Nordic Web3 Conference, held in Helsinki on June 6, 2023
The Aurora Nordic Web3 Conference, held in Helsinki on June 6, 2023. (Elias Ahonen)

The Finnish Bitcoin Association was established on May 6, in an event attended by Magazine, with membership fees paid primarily with Bitcoin via the Lightning Network. Upon the conclusion of formalities, the saunas of the hosting coworking space were fired up.

For those interested in nonfungible tokens (NFTs), Fungi is a platform advertising a no-code solution that lets organizations build NFT-based communities. One of these was a metaverse island called cornerstone.land for VR studio ZOAN, where 100 plots could be purchased as NFTs.

HABBO NFT, operated by the local creators of the 23-year-old online chat room game HABBO Hotel, has dropped an 11,600-piece avatar collection on Opensea and is currently developing an NFT-based game. A group called The Future of Art has also dedicated itself to promoting digital art and runs an NFT gallery.

The Finnish Web3 Landscape, according to Tampere-based The Good Cartel, which exists to support Finnish Web3 startups
The Finnish Web3 Landscape, according to Tampere-based The Good Cartel, which exists to support Finnish Web3 startups. (The Good Cartel)

An aspiring LinkedIn competitor, Kleoverse, is a proof-of-talent Web3 platform for recruiters and jobseekers that displays skills such as knowledge in programming languages through badges instead of text on a resume.

Phaver is building a Web3 social media app powered by Lens Protocol, which bills itself as the social layer of Web3. Phaver is one of many local projects that have worked with tech design studio STRGL, which specializes in protocol-level Web3 solutions. STRGLs managing director, Kasper Karimaa, sees Helsinki as a haven for developers:

Finland’s role in blockchain innovation through its agile engineering community make Helsinki the perfect place to assemble a skilled team in research, design and development.

One of the most widely known crypto companies in the country was P2P exchange LocalBitcoins, which employed about 50 people before closing its doors in February 2023. CEO Nikolaus Kangas told Cointelegraph that this was due to a failure to turn our trade volumes and declining market share back to growth.

Bittiraha, which translates to bit money in Finnish, is another old local crypto company. It was founded circa 2012 and installed the countrys first Bitcoin ATM at the Helsinki railway station in December 2013.

The company was also a distributor of Casascius physical Bitcoins and eventually made its own line of Denarium wallets. The parent company Coinmotion, based a few hours north in Jyvskyl, now operates a cryptocurrency exchange. 

Another major Finnish exchange called Northcrypto can be found in Turku.

A euro stablecoin has also been developed in the city. Membrane Finances EUROe was launched in February 2023 and is designed to be an EU-regulated full-reserve stablecoin that is compliant with recent legislation. While this is notable considering the relatively few operational euro stablecoins, volume remains low at approximately $20,000 per day.

Helsinki native Anita “Krypto Granny” Kalergis spends most of her time in Dubai, where she organizes blockchain conferences. She feels that Finnish entrepreneurs and decision-makers lack bravery, preferring to wait for someone else to take the lead and for regulatory certainty both from the national and EU levels. Most activity is not advertised, with especially older business people afraid to rock the boat or make major moves, she observes.

Companies here will build something to 95% completion before opening their mouth, whereas projects in other countries will raise money and build partnerships based on a whitepaper while testing in production.”

Helsinki is surrounded by sea and leaves room for nature
Helsinki is surrounded by sea and leaves room for nature. (Elias Ahonen)

Helsinkis crypto controversies

In 2018, the Finnish customs service planned to auction 1,666 BTC that it had seized in a drug case, but decided not to proceed due to concerns that the virtual money would return to the hands of criminals, displaying a rather negative official view of cryptocurrency. In July 2022, the state eventually auctioned nearly 2,000 BTC for $47 million, with proceeds being donated to Ukraine. 

In December 2021, local media reported a trend of investment scams involving the faces of prominent people, including industrialist Heikki Herlin and then-Prime Minister Sanna Marin. 

Earlier in 2018, the police also made warnings regarding a trend of Bitcoin blackmail relating to bogus claims that hackers had webcam material of users visiting pornographic websites. In 2022, a Helsinki watch dealer fell victim to a common crypto scam, handing over Rolex watches worth $400,000 after mistakenly believing that he had received a Bitcoin transaction.

Cryptocurrency, often adjacent to scams in the news, has come to be viewed with a relatively high degree of suspicion across most of society. Commenting on the decision to halt the 2018 customs seizure sale, Pekka Pylkknen, head of finance at the Finnish Customs Service, highlighted concerns about money laundering, telling national broadcaster YLE that “the buyers of cyber currency rarely use them for normal endeavors.

National media regularly interview outspoken cryptocurrency critic Aleksi Grym, head of fintech for the Finnish Central Bank, as an authoritative expert without seeking alternative pro-cryptocurrency views, though coverage has been improving.

As one may notice from this article, the term Web3 is preferred, presumably due to its distancing from the negative stereotypes of cryptocurrency.

Neither the countrys political establishment nor any major party or other large grouping of the population could be described outright as being pro-crypto.

One reason for this could be Finland’s stable, highly functional, and high-trust society, in which most people do not see the need to disrupt or fix something with cryptocurrency. Bank transfers are free and near-instantaneous across the EU, with cash use increasingly rare. Virtually nobody is un-banked, and the most trusted institution is the police, with 95% public support. Harjunp, whose startup is working on solutions to protect private keys, explains the disconnect:

Many people dont understand Bitcoin and think its something between criminal money and a pyramid scheme.

It is also notable that the moon mentality and dreams of quick wealth found in many cryptocurrency investors is generally seen in a particularly negative light, with Malmi noting that he never set out to make money with Bitcoin perhaps owing to Finnish culture and his idealistic mentality. 

In the same vein, cryptocurrencies are seen by some as drivers of inequality in a country in which large differences in wealth are often considered taboo.

Read also
Features

Satoshi Nakamoto saves the world in an NFT-enabled comic book series

Features

All rise for the robot judge: AI and blockchain could transform the courtroom

Crypto education and community

The Finnish Innovation Fund, or Sitra, has stated it as a priority to accelerate the local development of Web3 services, saying that its in Finlands interest to play an active role in ensuring that the metaverse is created in line with European values.

The fund has also worked with the Finnish National Gallery to create The Finnish Metagallery, an art gallery in the Decentraland metaverse whose building is modeled from the Finnish Pavilion as it appeared at the 1900 Paris World Fair.

Johanna Eiramo from the Finnish National Gallery presenting The Finnish Metagallery in Helsinki at Web3 Bash on April 27
Johanna Eiramo from the Finnish National Gallery presenting The Finnish Metagallery in Helsinki at Web3 Bash on April 27. (Elias Ahonen)

In the old capital of Turku, The University of Turku hosts the Critical Inquiry Into DAOs (CIDS) research group, of which the author is part. 

Notable crypto figures from Helsinki

Martti Malmi, the first person to sell Bitcoin for fiat; Henri Brade, board member of Coinmotion; Aleksi Lytynoja, CEO & co-founder of Kleoverse; Niko Laamanen, founder of Konsensus.

Martin Wichmann, chairman of Konsensus; Antti Innanen, founder of Fungi; Sointu Karjalainen, founder of The Good Cartel; Juha Viitala, CEO and co-founder of Membrane Finance; Mika Timonen, founder of Habbo NFT; Olli Tianinen, CEO of Equilibrium Labs; Kasper Karimaa, managing director at STRGL; Jarmo Suoranta, CEO of TX – Tomorrow Explored.

Keir Finlow-Bates, CEO of Chainfrog; Ville Runola, CEO and founder of Northcrypto; Samuel Harjunp, CEO and co-founder of Xellox; Joonatan Lintala, CEO and co-founder of Phaver.

Cointelegraph team members often found in Helsinki: Elias Ahonen.

If you have any suggestions for additions to this guide, please contact eliasahonen@cointelegraph.com.

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC Sees Subdued Trading Amid Bearish Signals

Crypto City guide to Sydney: More than just a ‘token’ bridge

A “full-on” crypto scene and “heaps” of Web3 projects in Australia’s largest city show Sydney has more to offer than beaches and a bridge.

This Crypto City guide looks at Sydneys crypto culture, the citys most notable projects and people, its financial infrastructure, what retailers accept crypto and where you can find blockchain education courses along with a history of its crypto controversies.

Jump to: Crypto culture, Projects and companies, Financial infrastructure, Where can I spend crypto? Controversies and collapses, Education, Notable figures.

Fast facts

City: Sydney
Country: Australia
Population: 5.2 million
Established: 1788

Sydney is Australias first, oldest and second-most populous city (just), world-famous for its harbor views and iconic landmarks, such as the Opera House and Harbor Bridge affectionately nicknamed The Coathanger by locals. The Harbor Citys second-most notable feature is 100 beaches across the metropolitan area with Bondi Beach the best known.

Sydney has one of the world's largest natural harbors
Sydney has one of the worlds largest natural harbors. (Pexels)

Located on Australias east coast, Sydney was established as a penal colony for the British Empire, which needed somewhere to transport criminals after losing control of its colonies in the American Revolution. Its probably no surprise then it earned the moniker Sin City in the second half of the 20th century due to rampant organized crime that corrupted judges, the top brass of the police and, maybe less surprisingly, politicians.

On a global scale, Sydney is fairly young and architecturally contemporary, which saw it play backdrop to The Matrix, as a major location in Mission Impossible 2 and a starring role in the plot of Finding Nemo (no, 42 Wallaby Way, Sydney doesnt exist). Sydney is Australias financial hub, has the third largest immigrant population globally, and boasts the second most unaffordable housing in the world behind Hong Kong.

Sydney’s crypto culture

Sydney saw an early interest in cryptocurrencies that still carries on today. Blockchain Sydney has been consistently getting together since 2013, and it currently meets twice a month at various pubs around the city. Blockchain Professionals, formed in 2014, also still meets up about once a month.

The Australian DeFi Association, while only launching in early 2022, has become a highly attended and consistent monthly hangout for local crypto industry players and enthusiasts.

Co-founder Mark Monfort originally created it for online discussions but says it soon morphed into an IRL meetup held between the larger one-off blockchain events, such as those by Blockchain Australia.

We wanted to be the gap filler between other meetups because what we saw was that there wasnt really a place for direct conversation apart from Crypto Twitter.

Sydney has over 30 public transit ferries serving 38 wharves making it one of the largest networks in the world
Sydney has over 30 public transit ferries serving 38 wharves making it one of the largest networks in the world. (Wikimedia)

Monfort maintains a calendar of Web3 events and meetups going on around Sydney and Australia. Other popular meetups include Bitcoin Sydney, Hyperledger Sydney and Sydney AI Web3 (which added artificial intelligence in line with the recent AI boom), while NFT Sydney and Metaverse Sydney typically dont meet as often.

As the countrys financial hub, Sydney boasts a thriving startup culture. Many crypto-related events are held in the various co-working offices around the city that also serve as a base for numerous crypto and fintech startups. One provider, Stone & Chalk, runs a Web3 Innovation Centre within the government-supported Sydney Startup Hub, and local exchange Independent Reserve has run a blockchain business accelerator since 2018.

Blockchain Week, the flagship event of Blockchain Australia, invariably holds at least one day of the program in Sydney, typically at the Exchange Centre the home of the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX).

Read also
Features

What its actually like to use Bitcoin in El Salvador

Features

Why Virtual Reality Needs Blockchain: Economics, Permanence and Scarcity

Sydney’s crypto projects and companies 

Sydneys crypto players are diverse, and theres likely a company involved in every niche of the market. Theres a lot of innovation thats coming out of this town much more than you see on a global stage, says Monfort, who also is a co-founder of the Web3 advisory firm NotCentralised.

NFT horse racing and betting game Zed Run was created here by Virtually Human Studios (before it moved to Melbourne) and so was Find Satoshi Labs move-to-earn app StepN. Fellow NFT gaming companies Illuvium and Immutable are also in Sydney (as much as a decentralized organization can be). Sigma Prime, is behind Lighthouse, the widely adopted Ethereum client.

Compared to Melbourne, there arent as many exchanges or trading platforms based in the city. Sydney plays host to significant parts of the Ethereum-based token trading platform Synthetix, the DeFi-backed fintech Block Earner is based here along with the centralized exchanges Independent Reserve and CryptoSpend.

The Redbelly Network operates the blockchain of the same name, which was originally birthed at Sydney University alongside government researchers. Smart Token Labs, creator of the open-source wallet AlphaWallet and crypto wallet creator Verida, both have their HQs in Sydney.

The city also hosts Block8, which helps develop blockchain products, Soulbound token development and advisory business Soulbis, Filecoin-powered data storage provider Holon, along with the Tide Foundation, which offers a cybersecurity solution thats based on blockchain.

Comparison site Finder operates a crypto exchange, and its founder, Fred Schebesta, dabbles with his blockchain investment fund Hive Empire, also Finders holding company. Schebesta owns the Crypto Castle in Coogee, which he bought for $11.5 million (17 million AUD) in May 2021 its rented out for photoshoots and events and listed on Airbnb for an exorbitant nightly price.

Crypto Castle
Crypto Castle highlights that money and taste are two very different things. (Airbnb)

Exchange-traded fund manager Global X ETFs AU has a local entity providing funds investing in Bitcoin and Ether and has another one for publicly traded crypto and fintech companies. Bitcoin mining firms Iris Energy and Arkon Energy are Sydney-based, although they have no local operations with their mines in Canada, Texas and Norway.

Haymarket HQ and BlockathonDAO have created incubator pathways in Sydney for crypto start ups, often running events and meet ups. The former also helps accelerate crypto companies into Australia.

Venture firm Airtree VC has partnered with its share of Web3 firms and is based in the inner-city suburb of Surry Hills, while the Web3 recruitment business CryptoRecruit is out in Bondi. Web3 data platform Itheum made a home in Sydney. Stirling & Rose and Piper Alderman both have specialist crypto lawyers.

Sydney’s financial infrastructure

Sydney was home to Australias first-ever Bitcoin ATM, which went live inside a mall in the city center on April 15, 2014. The ATM was purchased from RoboCoin, the firm responsible for setting up the worlds first Bitcoin ATM in Canada around six months earlier. Sydneys ATM was the 11th from RoboCoin to launch worldwide.

Today, over 100 Bitcoin ATMs, nearly a fourth of the roughly 500 in Australia, are dotted around the central business district and outer suburbs of Sydney according to Coin ATM Radar and are operated by a handful of companies. Users can only sell crypto at 14 of them, however, and those are predominantly based in the city center.

Sydneysiders, like all Australians, have access to multiple local exchanges as well as international ones with local entities in the country. A handful namely CoinJar, Crypto.com, CoinSpot, Wirex and CryptoSpend provide debit cards, offering crypto cashback or allowing crypto to be spent directly.

Crypto isnt widely used for payments or sending funds. Sending smaller monetary amounts through TradFi rails in Australia is typically instant and free, operates 24/7, and only needs a phone number or email thanks to the New Payments Platform, which everyone just calls PayID. The Australian central bank governor Philip Lowe has even said in the past hes skeptical on the need to issue a retail central bank digital currency: How could we offer digital tokens which would be better than that?

The relationship between crypto companies and banking or payment providers is still tenuous. In May 2023, Binance Australias payments provider Zepto was forced to offboard the exchange by its payments enablement partner Cuscal.

Westpac, one of the countrys Big Four banks, also began blocking payments to crypto exchanges on the same day Binance was debanked. Shortly after, the Sydney-based Commonwealth Bank (Australias largest bank) said it would begin declining or temporarily holding payments to crypto exchanges and impose a $10,000 monthly cap on the amount of money its customers could send to exchanges.

The banks vaguely cited issues with scams when asked to explain their respective actions.

CBA liked crypto a lot better, somewhat coincidentally, around the All Time High
CBA liked crypto a lot better, somewhat coincidentally, around the all-time high. (CBA)

Where can I spend crypto?

There are only a handful of places in Sydney left where you can spend crypto. Coinmap claims there are roughly 25 venues that take digital currency payments near the city, which get even more sparse when traveling to the outer suburbs (in total there are about 40).

The majority of venues appearing on Coinmap have shut down, and of those still standing, many no longer take crypto payments. A lack of uptake by customers was the consensus for getting rid of crypto payments as explained by multiple venue owners.

Takeaway only. The Bitcoin Rocket Cafe is tiny  sandwiched between a post office and a bank
Takeaway only. The Bitcoin Rocket Cafe is tiny sandwiched between a post office and a bank. (Facebook)

Of those still around that accept crypto, you can grab a brew at Cat and Cow Coffee in Clovelly. The aptly named Bitcoin Rocket Cafe in Redfern takes Bitcoin over the Lightning Network for its coffees and Bnh ms. The cafes owner, Samantha Ho, said she charges a higher fee for those spending under $13 (20 AUD) when paying by Lightning and estimated around five in 100 customers actually pay using Bitcoin.

There are a variety of stores that accept crypto when ordering online. You can order a new skateboard from Boardworld, which has shops in the inner west suburbs of Newtown and St Peters. Retro Girl will accept Bitcoin for their vintage wares, or you can grab some (very expensive) lingerie at Babylikestopony, which also has a shop in Paddington.

Under the bridge is Bar Lulu, which operates CryptoLulu, an NFT-gated membership club that claims to offer private lounges, networking events and other benefits at the venue for NFT holders. While you can of course pay for the NFT membership using crypto, the bar itself doesnt take crypto payments right, now but thats apparently coming soon.

Controversies and collapses

For many years, there was much excitement about the ASX implementing a blockchain-backed solution for its clearing and settlements system. It first announced the plans in 2017, but it suffered multiple delays. Five years on and $170 million later, the ASX canned the project in late 2022 to much scorn from the central bank and the securities regulator.

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has undertaken its share of enforcement actions in the crypto space against Sydney businesses. It sued Block Earner in November 2022, claiming the latter offered crypto-based yield products without a license. ASIC hit comparison website Finder with a similar suit a month later, and the regulator claims Finder shut down its crypto-yielding products a month earlier because of its concerns.

In April 2022 after a targeted review, ASIC canceled the financial license of Binance Australia Derivatives (Oztures Trading), the futures business of the exchange. ASIC also claims it was sniffing out the Sydney-headquartered Australian entity for FTX months before the global company collapsed in November 2022. FTX Australia was able to gain a local financial license by taking over a company that already had one, a loophole that ASIC chair Joe Longo wants to close.

Holon was similarly whacked by ASIC in October 2022, which put a stop to crypto ETFs investing in Bitcoin, Ether and Filecoin. Holon later bailed on the idea altogether.

In late 2020, ASIC also unleashed a raft of charges against John Biggaton, a promotor of the infamous BitConnect Ponzi scheme. Conspiracy theories about Biggaton have been spun up after his wife, Madeline Bigatton, mysteriously disappeared in March 2018. She was suspected to have committed suicide at The Gap, a location infamous for such acts, but its a narrative that her family doubts.

Sydneysider Kathryn Nguyen is widely believed to be the first person charged with the theft of crypto assets in Australia. She was sentenced to two years in jail after stealing around 100,000 XRP in January 2018. The alleged Sydney-based Ponzi scheme Metafi Yielders is said to have stolen $135 million, but after it collapsed, the chief executive of the business, Michael Daher, claimed he was just a fall guy, and the real schemers were in Nigeria.

The Commonwealth Bank has seemingly done a 180 on its crypto stance in a relatively short time. In November 2021, it was gearing up to ship crypto trading within its banking app. At the time, its CEO, Matt Comyn, said the bank saw bigger risks in not participating in crypto and, in May 2022, was still seemingly trying to squeeze the product past regulators. But just over a year and a half later, the bank began censoring payments to crypto exchanges.

The controversial Satoshi claimant Craig Wright used to live in Sydney, and his house was notoriously raided by federal police in 2015 due to a warrant issued by the tax authorities, but he now lives in the United Kingdom.

Read also
Features

From Director of the United States Mint to the Very First Bitcoin IRA Customer

Features

Crypto leaders are obsessed with life extension. Here’s why

Crypto education in Sydney

A few higher-ed institutions offer courses or units of study on blockchain and Web3. Sydneys first university, the University of Sydney, offers a unit on Cryptocurrency Markets and Investments. It also does a course on blockchains and cryptography as part of its Master of Cybersecurity. 

Sydney Uni along with the CSIRO (a federal government scientific research agency) developed the Redbelly blockchain, which aimed to create a fork-proof network. The project was spun out of the uni into its own commercial entity in December 2021.

The University of Sydney
The University of Sydney. (Wikipedia)

The University of Technology Sydney (UTS) offers a free two-hour online course on the basics of blockchain tech, while the University of New South Wales (UNSW) offers postgraduate and undergraduate courses on Web3 and Blockchain Applications. UNSWs course on cryptocurrency and DeFi is a core course as part of its postgraduate major in fintech.

For those willing to pay $235 (350 AUD) to sit in a classroom for nine hours to learn the basics of crypto, blockchain and how to trade, then the Sydney Community College has a course aimed at introducing you to crypto and blockchain although this carries no accreditations like the others.

UNSW and Sydney Uni have a student-led society that semi-regularly hosts events and meetups called the University Network for Cryptocurrency and Blockchain.

In May 2022, UNSW received $4 million worth of USDC from Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin for the development of a pandemic-detection tool.

Kain Warwick is one of Sydneys most notable crypto figures
Kain Warwick is one of Sydneys most notable crypto figures. (Cointelegraph)

Notable figures

Synthetix founder Kain Warwick; Illuvium co-founders (and Kains brothers) Aaron and Kieran Warwick; Finder co-founder and Crypto Castle owner Fred Schebesta; Block Earner co-founder Charlie Karaboga; Australian DeFi Association co-founders Mark Monfort and Arturo Rodriguez; Kraken Australia managing director Jonathon Miller; Web3 blogger Joan Westenberg; KPMG director of metaverse Alyse Sue; StepN creator Jerry Huang; Algorand Foundation governance manager Adriana Belotti; Haymarket HQ CEO Duco Van Breeman; Immutable co-founders Robbie and James Ferguson, Independent Reserve co-founder Adrian Przelozny ; Virtually Human co-founder and Zed Run creator Chris Laurent; Global X ETFs AU CEO Evan Metcalf; Block8 co-founders Kim Bartlett, Alan Burt and Tim Bass; CryptoRecruit founder Neil Dundon; Koinly head of tax Danny Talwar; Coinbase APAC managing director John OLoghlen; Arkon Energy co-founder and CEO Joshua Payne; Smart Token Labs co-founder and CEO Victor Zhang; Holon co-founder Heath Behncke; Crypto lawyers Nick Abrahams and Michael Bacina (the latter is also the Blockchain Australia chairperson), Ethereum Smart Contract developer and community educator Bokky Poobah.

Cointelegraph team members and contributors based in Sydney: Felix Ng, Brayden Lindrea, Ciaran Lyons and Jesse Coghlan.

If you have suggestions for additions to this guide, please email: jesse.coghlan@cointelegraph.com.

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC Sees Subdued Trading Amid Bearish Signals

Your guide to crypto in Toronto: Crypto City

Toronto embraced digital assets sooner than most and is home to more crypto projects than anywhere else in Canada.

Contents

Overview
Crypto culture in Toronto
Where can I spend crypto in Toronto?
Crypto projects and companies in Toronto
Torontos crypto controversies
Toronto crypto education and community
Notable crypto figures from Toronto

Overview

The city lies at the center of the so-called Golden Horseshoe, a large urban area around the shore of Lake Erie that 9.76 million people about a quarter of all Canadians call home. Consistently rated among the worlds most livable cities, Toronto, much like Vancouver on the west coast, is notable for its ethno-cultural diversity brought on by waves of immigration. Its within a short flight of the capital Ottawa, as well as Montreal to the north and New York to the south. Toronto is seen as the countrys financial and cultural capital.

Toronto was where Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin grew up
Toronto was where Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin grew up. Source: Pexels

Playing home to notable battles between indigenous peoples in the late 1600s, French traders from the mid-1700s and the British later that century, Toronto has seen a lot. In 1834, around the time of a failed rebellion against the British, it was incorporated as Toronto, which was a First Nations name, and the city became a destination for slaves escaping the American South. In the late 1800s, the city became a railway hub. Today, it is served by Pearson International Airport.

As a global hub of business and culture, Toronto resembles a northern version of New York, to the extent that many movies set in New York are filmed in the city due to their similar appearance. Winter weather can be formidable, with freezing rain in 1999 requiring the army to be called in for road clearing. The city is well-known as the birthplace of Ethereum and today hosts a majority of Canadas blockchain companies.

Crypto culture in Toronto

Vitalik Buterin, an elongated Toronto young man who looked brainy in a very literal way, had attended Anthonys first meetup and later brought to him an idea for a blockchain platform he called Ethereum.

So writes author Ethan Lou in his memoir, Once A Bitcoin Miner, much of which takes place in Toronto. Anthony Di Iorio, an early Bitcoin investor, started a crypto meetup named after his software company Decentral in a redbrick house in Torontos historical fashion district this is where the young Buterin walked in with his idea for Ethereum, which is, of course, another story entirely.

With the founding of Ethereum, Toronto cemented its position in the crypto canon. By 2018, Canadian startup blog BetaKit wrote there was a divide in Canada between the areas that embraced the cultural aspects of crypto on one side, and the financial aspects on the other.

Read also
Features

An Investment in Knowledge Pays the Best Interest: The Parlous State of Financial Education

Features

Australias world-leading crypto laws are at the crossroads: The inside story

While Toronto and Waterloo are understood to be lively crypto hubs, Vancouver is known for companies that privilege crypto-collectibles over currency, and blockchain art over tokens. 

This makes sense, considering Toronto is a city oriented primarily toward finance, while Waterloo, the birthplace of BlackBerry, is a tech hub an hours drive away. Thats where Buterin attended university briefly and was the home of the author of this article for nearly 20 years.

Toronto's famous Bitcoin sign at Decentral headquarters
Torontos famous Bitcoin sign at Decentral headquarters. Source: Decentral

In 2014, Decentral opened a physical location on the prominent Spadina Avenue, making it and its large Bitcoin sign something of an institution and a way in which Bitcoin touched the lives of average Torontonians. Featuring a Bitcoin ATM, the spot became almost a Bitcoin embassy in the city, hosting meetups and other events. 

As a financial hub, Toronto regularly plays host to blockchain conferences including the annual Blockchain Futurist Conference, the largest in the country. In 2022, the event coincided with ETH Toronto. The year also saw the Web3 & Blockchain World summit, AIBC Toronto and the Cardano Summit 2022. A quick browse of Meetup.com will reveal that there are dozens of cryptocurrency-, blockchain- and NFT-themed meetups in the city and surrounding area. 

The corporate nature of the city means there is more funding available than in most other comparable destinations, explains Charlie Aikenhead, senior vice president of marketing at WonderFi. And unlike south of the border in the United States, there is a general sense of regulatory certainty, which encourages a willingness to bet on the industry.

Canadian investors and citizens seem to have a more favorable view of the industry and have less worries about customer protections than other countries.

Where can I spend crypto in Toronto?

According to Coinmaps, there are a number of businesses in the city and surrounding areas that happily accept cryptocurrency as payment. In addition to crypto ATMs and various shopping outlets specializing from sportswear to TV antennas, one can have their teeth repaired at Downtown Dental Hygiene Clinic, with the same service available for their homes at B & B Cleaning Service. Down the street from both, Grossmans Tavern is happy to exchange beer for bits, while Toronto Brewing will sell you all you need to make drinks at home. Even cryotherapy is available at Vital Cryotherapy Toronto.

Coffee can be purchased at the nearby Snakes and Lattes board game cafe a few blocks away, while Urban Living Suites offers a good nights rest for crypto tourists roaming the streets without loonies or toonies what locals call $1 and $2 dollar coins, featuring a loon and two polar bears, respectively. Online services such as those offered by WebRocker Web Design are also available. 

While crypto acceptance is by no means the norm, it is notable to say that it appears very reasonable that one could go cashless and survive on cryptocurrency for the majority of their needs by seeking out crypto-friendly businesses in the region.

If one is determined, about anything can be purchases with crypto in the Toronto region
If one is determined, just about anything can be purchased with crypto in the Toronto region. Source: Coinflip

Crypto projects and companies in Toronto

Toronto has the largest concentration of blockchain startups in the country, to the extent that startupill.com published a list titled 82 Best Toronto Cryptocurrency Startups. Among the biggest ones include exchanges Coinsquare, CoinSmart, Tokens.com, Bitbuy, BitSwap, 3Commas, Coinberry and Coinlet among several others. Angel.co also lists 39 Top Blockchain / Cryptocurrency Startups in Toronto in 2022, many of which appear to be actively hiring.

On the mining side, Hut8 Mining is perhaps the most established player, being listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange with a market cap above $400 million. Bitfarms is also listed at a market cap of just under $200 million. DigiMax, Digihost and Cryptoster are also involved in mining. 

Andrew Kiguel, CEO of Tokens.com and former CEO of Hut8 Mining, explains that the mix of crypto companies and several large universities is the secret sauce to the citys industry success, which, he says, has a young and sophisticated crypto population.

There are several large universities, and many crypto companies are headquartered here. As a result, theres a large, active crypto community, he says. There are regular meetups and businesses that have launched in the city. It has a young and sophisticated crypto population. 

The crypto environment is generally cooperative and friendly. There is a large talent pool in Toronto seeking employment in crypto. Many crypto companies were launched in Toronto, and others, such as Galaxy Digital and Hive, were financed out of Toronto.

In addition to exchanges and mining, Toronto also hosts many financial services and advisory companies specializing in cryptocurrency. These include Signal, a market intelligence firm, Bitcoinblack, which provides crypto-backed credit cards, and payment transfer company Biquiti.

Jaxx Wallet, which allows users to easily manage cryptocurrency holdings via smartphone, is also based in Toronto.

Lower cooling costs are one positive note for the crypto mining industry un Canada
Lower cooling costs are one positive note for the crypto mining industry in Canada. Source: Pexels

Torontos crypto controversies

Earlier in 2022, authorities seized a Lambo and $2 million from local 23-year-old Crypto King Aiden Pleterski, whose company AP Private Equity Limited was accused of being a $35-million fraud according to court documents. Pleterski was allegedly renting out a lakeside mansion for $45,000 per month even as some locals say they lost money earmarked for their grandchildrens education. 

In early 2020, a Los Angeles billionaire named Josh Jones became a victim of a so-called SIM-swap attack, according to Ryk Edelstein, founder of 5-L Technologies, in Montreal. The attacker took $45 million in Bitcoin but was eventually tracked down to nearby Hamilton via a PlayStation username and IP address, where authorities found a teenager who later pleaded guilty. A friend, who witnessed the arrest, later recounted the story to local news: 

He told me, after the SIM swap, that he thought he got only $1 million. But when he looked at the total amount and saw it was $45 million, he panicked.

The city has seen a few crypto crimes from investment scams to sim-swaps
The city has seen a few crypto crimes from investment scams to SIM-swaps. Image: Pexels

Toronto also served as part of the stage for the infamous case of QuadrigaCX, whose late founder, Gerald Cotten, lived in the city while running the exchange. He reportedly died in India in 2018, seemingly taking the private keys to nearly $200 million with him to the grave which victims have later fought to exhume in a search for answers. In June 2020, the Ontario Securities Commission officially concluded that QuadrigaCX was a fraud and a Ponzi scheme.

Toronto crypto education and community

If you want to be a blockchain dev, at George Brown Universitys Casa Loma campus, you can participate in a one-year full-time Blockchain Development Program, which comes with a mandatory on-the-job training element. Tuition is only about $5,000 per year.

Toronto Metropolitan University offers a course called Blockchain for Business, which promises to help fill a knowledge gap for professionals seeking essential knowledge in the ways in which blockchain technology works and how it can be applied effectively to solve business problems. York University has a dedicated Blockchain Academy and offers a Certificate in Blockchain Development, which is more geared toward building than understanding, through its School of Continuing Studies. 

Torontos chapter of the International Institute of Business Analysis has provided its members with educational seminars on Blockchain Fundamentals, and Intellipaat provides a 27-hour IBM Blockchain Course. BlockGeeks also offers some free online courses.

There is also CryptoChicks, a nonprofit that has grown from Toronto to encompass chapters around the world helping thousands of women around the globe to learn and invest in blockchain, build new careers and businesses.

Notable crypto figures from Toronto

Vitalik Buterin (at least sometimes when he visits family, including father Dmitry Buterin), Ethereum co-founder Anthony Di Iorio; Author of Once A Bitcoin Miner and occasional Magazine contributor Ethan Lou; Tokens.com CEO Andrew Kiguel; Cannabanc founder Paresh Khatri; Bitbuy CEO Michael Arbus; Kylin Network co-founder Dylan Dewdney; Newton CEO Dustin Walper; CoinSmart CEO Justin Hartzman; Coinberry co-founder Andrei Poliakov.

Read also
Columns

We tracked down the original Bitcoin Lambo guy

Features

Bitcoin gets physical: Art or digital heresy?

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC Sees Subdued Trading Amid Bearish Signals

Crypto City: Guide to San Francisco Bay Area

This Crypto City guide looks at the San Francisco Bay Areas crypto culture, its most notable projects and people, its financial infrastructure, which retailers accept crypto, and where you can find blockchain education courses. You really might leave your heart in San Francisco with all the projects in the Bay Area.

Fast facts

City: San Francisco

Country: United States

Population: 887,711

Founded: 1776

Language: English

Crypto City: Guide to San Francisco Bay Area
The San Francisco Bay Area is a region in Northern California spanning the city of San Francisco and surrounding counties.

Understand

Though not the most populated part of California or the capital city, the San Francisco Bay Area is well-known for its iconic cable cars, views of the Golden Gate Bridge, and Silicon Valley both the television series and the real-life tech hub. Originally a Spanish colony and later part of Mexico before becoming a city in the U.S. state of California, many residents live in buildings more than 100 years old.

The Painted Ladies in San Francisco
The Painted Ladies in San Francisco. Source: Pexels

San Francisco is known for its proximity to the San Andreas Fault, responsible for some of the most devastating earthquakes in U.S. history, including one in 1906 that caused fires that burned down large sections of the city over several days. Another magnitude 6.9 quake hit the Bay Area in 1989, damaging the Bay Bridge between the downtown area and Oakland.

Because many historic buildings and picturesque places have endured despite the earthquakes and nearby Napa Valley and its wineries may help San Francisco attracts many tourists from all over the world and has been the filming location for movies too numerous to mention, including The Rock, Mrs. Doubtfire and The Matrix Resurrections. The city also includes the oldest Chinatown in North America, the former military base-turned-park Presidio, Golden Gate Park and the Mission District.

Neighboring cities are separated by the bay but are connected with a network of public transportation. Overall, more than 7 million people live in the area between the wine country in the north and Silicon Valley in the south. The city faces challenges, including one of the countrys largest populations of unhoused individuals, the rising cost of living and other issues common across large urban areas in the United States.

Crypto culture

A tech hub long before the advent of cryptocurrency in 2008, the Bay Area was a natural home for one of the earlier Bitcoin conferences. In San Jose in June 2013, now well-known crypto personalities including Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong and Bitcoin educator Andreas Antonopoulos spoke to attendees interested in crypto at a time when the space was considered by many to be fringe. 

One of the earliest Bitcoin Meetups in the Bay Area happened in January 2013, when organizers Ryan Singer and Jered Kenna who would go on to co-found Chia Network and become the CEO of the Tradehill exchange, respectively proposed setting aside the first Tuesday of every month to discuss the crypto asset. Other attendees reportedly included Kraken CEO Jesse Powell, Ripple Labs co-founder Jed McCaleb, Litecoin creator Charlie Lee, and Coinbases Fred Ehrsam and Armstrong.

There were a lot of cypherpunks at those early Bitcoin meetups that I went to, said Armstrong in a 2021 interview with Initialized Capital founder Garry Tan. 

As a predominantly Democratic U.S. state, albeit one containing many conservative voters, California has had its share of lawmakers proposing both pro- and anti-crypto policies as the space evolves. In 2022, the states Department of Financial Protection and Innovation issued cease and desist orders against BlockFi, Voyager Digital and Celsius Network related to allegedly offering unregistered securities. 

Californias Fair Political Practices Commission also lifted a ban first imposed in 2018, preventing candidates running for state and local offices from accepting donations in crypto. State Senator Sydney Kamlager introduced a bill in February proposing that lawmakers amend the states code to allow for the acceptance of cryptocurrencies for certain payments. 

Read also
Features

An Investment in Knowledge Pays the Best Interest: The Parlous State of Financial Education

Features

Year 1602 revisited: Are DAOs the new corporate paradigm?

At the state level, Governor Gavin Newsom announced in May 2022 that he had signed an executive order aimed at harmonizing a regulatory framework for blockchain between the U.S. government and California, as well as spurring innovation in the space. The executive action built upon President Joe Bidens executive order on digital assets signed in March.

The state looked as if it would be a battleground to watch in the 2022 midterm elections as pro-crypto candidates attempted to unseat those opposed or neutral about the space. However, both pro-crypto candidates, Democrats Aarika Rhodes and Greg Tanaka failed to win their primaries to represent Californias 30th and 16th Congressional Districts in the U.S. House of Representatives, respectively.

So many of our elected leaders dont support or understand technology, Tanaka told Cointelegraph in April. They throw rocks in the road in front of it.

The Bay Area has also hosts San Francisco Blockchain Week, blockchain conference d10e and the Converge22 Web3-focused conference in September.

Golden Gate Bridge
Golden Gate Bridge. Source: Pexels

Projects and companies

One would be hard-pressed to name a major tech firm that didnt get its start in the Bay Area or Silicon Valley. The area is home to three headquarters out of the big four tech firms, including metaverse-adjacent social media firm Meta, which rebranded from Facebook in October 2021. Social media platform Twitter and blockchain-focused payments firm Block also have their headquarters there, as do PayPal, Visa and Cash App.

In addition, many major cryptocurrency or crypto-adjacent projects likewise began in the tech hub, possibly due to the high density of talent. Coinbase made an early appearance at the San Jose Bitcoin Conference in 2013, where CEO Brian Armstrong personally attended to guests approaching the booth. The Bay Area is also home to the headquarters for Ripple Labs, Chainlink Labs, Robinhood Markets, Compound Labs, decentralized music streaming service Audius, crypto hedge fund manager BitBull Capital, dYdX, Brave Software, Lightning network developer Lightning Labs, Hyperledger Foundation, Andreessen Horowitz, Abra, Earnity, Anchorage Digital, Layer1, crypto and blockchain-focused investment fund Pantera Capital, NuCypher, blockchain ecosystem Rally, Aptos Labs, Scalar Capital, BitGo, Stellar Development Foundation, BlockCypher, Framework Ventures, Securitize, Oasis Labs, Near Protocol, Protocol Labs and CipherTrace as well as local branches of Galaxy Digital, Gemini, Bitfury, Nium, MakerDAO, Solana Labs and crypto miner Crusoe Energy Systems.

20Mission, a co-working space in San Franciscos Mission District, opened one of the earliest retail stores that accepted Bitcoin in 2015 called Nakamotos electronics. Still in use today, the art and technology creator hub was home to many crypto-related startups, including Block-Chain.info, 37Coins, Tradehill, Piper Wallet and Purse.io. Crypto Castle, an office and co-living space that was once home to crypto entrepreneur Jeremy Gardner, was located in the citys Potrero Hill district and hosted a number of crypto and blockchain projects.

Bitcoin ATMs

Financial infrastructure

In March 2014, a community tech center named Hacker Dojo installed the first Bitcoin ATM in the San Francisco Bay Area in Mountain View. The installation of the ATM, operated by Robocoin, was followed by another at the Workshop Cafe of San Franciscos Financial District later that year. According to data from CoinATMRadar, there are roughly 469 crypto ATMs in the San Francisco Bay Area, operated by companies, such as Coin Cloud, CoinFlip and Bitcoin Depot

Where can I spend crypto?

Crypto as a medium of exchange hasnt reached mainstream levels of adoption in the U.S., but there are more than 100 businesses in San Francisco that accept Bitcoin and other tokens for payments according to Coinmap. These include restaurants, bookstores and even optometrists offices. 

Across the Bay Area, retailers including Starbucks, Whole Foods and others accept crypto payments through third-party apps. In addition, residents and workers in Silicon Valley can spend their crypto at more than 50 businesses in the area. Though seemingly offering only payments in fiat and through third-party apps, Meta opened a brick-and-mortar retail store in Burlingame in May, which offers hardware for its metaverse ambitions.

Read also
Features

North American crypto miners prepare to challenge Chinas dominance

Features

Satoshi Nakamoto saves the world in an NFT-enabled comic book series

Education

San Francisco State University offers a blockchain bootcamp through its Lam Family College of Business and recently collaborated with Ripple Labs and the Warsaw University of Technology to allow students to develop blockchain-based solutions to projects, including supply chain tracing and the commercialization of artwork. 

Across the Bay, the University of California, Berkeley currently has a student-run blockchain innovation hub for consulting, education and research. Stanfords Center for Blockchain Research held its fifth blockchain conference in August 2022. The Palo Alto-based university offers courses on blockchain and cryptocurrency through its School of Engineering for the autumn semester, while in the city, the University of San Francisco lets students learn about blockchain through its College of Arts and Sciences.

The potential application for Bitcoin-like technologies is enormous, says the Stanford course description.

San Francisco has a range of blockchain education courses
San Francisco has a range of blockchain education courses. Source: Pexels

Controversies and collapses

In 2013, authorities arrested Ross Ulbricht, creator of the infamous darknet marketplace Silk Road, at a San Francisco Public Library. Federal Bureau of Investigation specialist Christopher Tarbell led the team, which tracked down Ulbricht using VPN server records corresponding to an internet cafe in the city where he had also logged into his Gmail account. The information ultimately led to the arrest of the Dread Pirate Roberts and the eventual end of Silk Road. Ulbricht is currently serving two life sentences without the possibility of parole.

Though not forced to shut down by excessive regulations or orders from law enforcement, crypto exchange Kraken unexpectedly shuttered its San Francisco office in April 2022. CEO Jesse Powell said the companys headquarters on Market Street was closed following complaints that numerous employees were attacked, harassed and robbed on their way to and from the office. Coinbase also announced plans to shut down its San Francisco headquarters in 2022, but as part of an effort to go remote rather than due to threats while commuting.

Notable figures in the San Francisco Bay Area

Bitcoin core developer and Blockstream co-founder Pieter Wuille; Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg; Solana co-founder Anatoly Yakovenko; Audius CEO and co-founder Roneil Rumburg; BitBull Capital CEO Joe DiPasquale; Pantera Capital head of investor relations Kerry Wong; Pantera CEO and Bitstamp chair Dan Morehead; Robinhood co-founder Vlad Tenev; Ripple Labs chief technical officer David Schwartz; Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse; Ripple co-founder Chris Larsen; Coinbase chief operating officer and president Emilie Choi; Framework Ventures co-founder Michael Anderson; Crypto Council for Innovation CEO Sheila Warren; Rally co-founder Kevin Chou; Coinbase co-founder and Paradigm co-founder Fred Ehrsam; Brave Software CEO Brendan Eich; Scalar Capital co-founder and managing director Linda Xie; Earnity co-founder and CEO Dan Schatt; Coinbase board member Kathryn Haun; former Twitter CEO and current Block Head Jack Dorsey; dYdX founder and CEO Antonio Juliano; BitGo CEO Mike Belshe; Andreessen Horowitz co-founder Marc Andreessen; Oasis Labs co-founder and CEO Dawn Song; Compound Labs founder Robert Leshner; Protocol Labs founder and CEO Juan Benet; PayPal co-founder and crypto investor Peter Thiel; Ripple Labs and Stellar Development Foundation co-founder Jed McCaleb; Stellar Development Foundation CEO Denelle Dixon; crypto and tech investor Tim Draper; Visa head of crypto Cuy Sheffield; Abra founder and CEO Bill Barhydt; CipherTrade CEO David Jevans; former Tradehill CEO and current CEO of 20Mission Jered Kenna; Cointelegraph team members: Rachel Wolfson.

If you have any suggestions for additions to this guide, please contact turner@cointelegraph.com.

Read also
Features

Tokenomics not Ponzi-nomics: Influencing behavior, making money

Features

How the crypto workforce changed in the pandemic

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC Sees Subdued Trading Amid Bearish Signals

Crypto City Guide to Prague: Bitcoin in the heart of Europe

Prague is the birthplace of the worlds first hardware wallet, the first Bitcoin mining pool, and, reportedly, even the first Bitcoin cafe. It is among the most affluent cities in Central Europe, visited by millions of tourists each year.

Ranked as one of Europes most charming and beautiful cities, Prague is a burgeoning tech hub with a new generation of crypto-saavy individuals populating its streets.

 

Fast facts

City: Prague
Country: Czechia
Population: 2.7 million (Metropolitan Area)
Established: 8th Century
Languages: Czech, Slovak, English, Ukrainian, German, Vietnamese, Russian

 

Crypto City Guide to Prague: Bitcoin in the heart of Europe
Prague was a leading metropolis in the adoption of Bitcoin.

 

 

Understand

Known for its bridges, majestic fortifications and Bohemian architecture, Prague was voted the most beautiful city in the world last year by Time Out Magazine. At the crossroads of Europe, its visited by over 8 million tourists annually and has become a popular choice among filmmakers as a backdrop, including the makers of Mission: Impossible and Casino Royale.

More than 1,000 years ago, the migration of the Czech people a Western Slavic tribe founded the City of Prague on the banks of the Vltava river. Prague quickly developed into a major metropolitan center in medieval times and was the seat of many Bohemian kings who would also reign as the emperors of the Holy Roman Empire.

Ruled over variously by the Austrian Empire, a short era of independence, and then by Nazi Germany, Prague managed to escape destruction at the hands of Nazis or Allied bombers. But after just three years of independence after the war, communists backed by the Soviet Union staged a coup and toppled the countrys democratic government in 1948. Development stalled during communist times, and despite a flicker of hope for liberalism in the Prague Spring of 1968, it wasnt until the Velvet Revolution protests that the ruling communist party resigned on Nov. 28, 1989, putting the local people once again in charge of their own destinies.

 

 

The Powder Tower during the Habsburg Era | Photo Source: Old-Prague.com
The Powder Tower during the Habsburg era. Source: Old-Prague.com

 

 

Crypto culture

Today, Prague is a leading tech hub in Central Europe. Having changed currencies once a generation due to their various rulers and independence, the Czech people are known for monetary skepticism and have enthusiastically adopted digital currencies. This interest has been compounded by the growing inflationary pressure on the Czech koruna (CZK), which stood at 18.0% per annum in June 2022.

 

 

 

 

Firms such as SatoshiLabs, Alza, Trezor, Braiins and many others have ramped up education about digital assets in the country. However, the Czech National Bank has largely remained on the sidelines with regard to regulating the industry. While interest in crypto remains strong among the Czech people (especially those in Prague), recent industry blowups and bear market sell-offs have hampered confidence somewhat.

But that does not take away from the fact that it was here where the worlds first hardware wallet, first Bitcoin mining pools and first Bitcoin coffee shop all came into action within the past decade. In recent years, Prague has also become a hotspot for digital nomads, being voted as the top destination in the world for remote work, along with Krakow, Poland in 2021. Thanks to the effort of early adopters, the city is rife with crypto meetups, hackathons, venues and seminars that make it distinct from its neighbors in Central Europe.

 

 

 Pragues Old Town Square
Pragues Old Town Square. Source: Zhiyuan Sun

 

 

Notable Projects

Nowadays, cryptocurrency hardware wallets are renowned for their ability to safeguard investors assets in a self-custodied manner, but just who invented them? The idea all started in 2011 after a Bitcoin conference in Prague.

Two crypto enthusiasts, Pavol Stick Rusnk and Marek Slush Palatinus envisioned a small, single-purpose computer that would securely store users Bitcoin private keys. In 2013, the two founded SatoshiLabs. The following year, the first-ever Trezor wallet Trezor One launched. Then came the Trezor Model T, which added a touchscreen to the device. Both devices have sold over 1 million units since inception, with their firmware patched monthly or so. It has become the standard for hardware crypto storage worldwide.

 

 

 

 

SatoshiLabs comprises a basket of companies (Trezor, Invity and Tropic Square) forming the forefront of crypto and tech development in Czechia.

Trezor model T
The famed Trezor Model T

Apart from its flagship product, it is also responsible for creating over 20 industry standards, such as the recovery seed and passphrase used in all cryptocurrency hardware wallets today.

Like many in the crypto industry, they were incensed by the Russian invasion of Ukraine this year and wanted to help. Vojtch ern, head of commerce at Trezor, and Bach Nguyen, head of business development at Invity, drove nearly 900 kilometers to the SlovakUkrainian border town of Vel’k Slemence, delivering humanitarian supplies and bringing back four women and two children refugees to safety in Czechia.

SatoshiLabs also donated 1 million euros worth of Bitcoin to charities helping Ukraine shortly after the war started, citing the effects of occupation and destruction of individual freedom during five decades of Communist rule over Czechoslovakia as the inspiration.

Invity is another branch of SatoshiLabs.

The firm is a price aggregator that scrutinizes every crypto exchange and other platforms to find the best rates for purchasing cryptocurrency. It combines everything in one place with a straightforward interface designed for users just getting into crypto. Invity also has a wide range of resources about education for novel crypto enthusiasts.

Lastly, during the development of Trezor at SatoshiLabs, it became clear that the firm needed an auditable integrated circuit with better security solutions than market alternatives. Thus, Tropic Square was born with an ambitious plan to make an open-source, auditable custom chip to transform low entropy code into high entropy data for cryptographic operations. Led by tech-savvy developers such as CEO Even Englberth and chief technology officer Jan Pleska, chips developed by Tropic Square are now found in each and every one of Trezors hardware wallets.

 

 

Tropic Square staff at SatoshiLabs headquarters | Photo Credits: Tropic Square
Tropic Square staff at SatoshiLabs headquarters. Source: Tropic Square

 

 

Before he created Trezor, Palatinus founded the first Bitcoin mining project in Prague in 2010, which was simply called Bitcoin.cz. After he moved on, Braiins, a company doing embedded Linux development and research, took over the mining pool and renamed it accordingly (until recently rebranding it back to Slush Pool), with 1.3 million BTC mined since inception.

Fast forward to now, Braiins/Slush Pool has grown to become one of the biggest Bitcoin mining pools. There are currently over 15,000 users of the firms mining optimization software in the space, with its total hash rate accounting for 5%8% of the overall Bitcoin network. The company derives 100% of its income via BTC and charges a 2%2.5% commission from its mining firmware.

Kristian Csepcsar, chief marketing officer of Braiins, explains that mining and Bitcoin is a way of life not just a way to make money:

Bitcoin miners are one of the most hardcore Bitcoiners, and their commitment to secure networks can be seen in the global hash rate numbers. Bitcoins price fell more than 70% recently, but the hash rate has only dropped about 20% from all-time highs. Bitcoins relative price to fiat can change, but Bitcoin will be forever one Bitcoin, and miners deeply understand this point.

 

 

Braiins core team at Bitcoin Mining Conference 2022 in Prague | Photo Credits: Braiins
Braiins core team at Bitcoin Mining Conference 2022 in Prague. Source: Braiins

 

 

General Bytes is the worlds second-largest Bitcoin and ATM manufacturer, with offices in Prague and Bradenton, Florida. Since its inception in 2013, the company has sold over 13,000 machines across 142 countries, most of which are located in the United States.

A General Bytes ATM
A General Bytes ATM. Source: General Bytes

More than 180 fiat currencies can be used to purchase 60+ types of digital assets at its cash machines. Over 22.5 million crypto transactions have been performed worldwide on its network of Bitcoin ATMs.

Backed by the $2.5-billion Rockaway Capital, the Rockaway Blockchain Fund is a venture capital firm backing leading Web3 founders. Founded in 2020, the Prague-based firm has now invested in 36 projects and 26 funds. In addition to investing capital and boosting liquidity, Rockaway backs its projects through community networking, a staking team that runs its validator nodes, and an in-house development team known as RBF Labs. It was one of the early backers of Solana, along with several investments in the Cosmos ecosystem, including Agoric.

Rockaway raised $123 million in its first VC fund, which is now nearly 75% deployed with a portfolio value of approximately $300 million as of June 30. In addition to that, RBF also has a separate lending fund that provides loans to market makers and liquidity to DeFi protocols, with an asset under management of approximately $35 million at the end of June.

Where can I spend my crypto?

Located near the heart of Pragues Old Town is Bar No. 7, a laid-back venue with multilingual staff thats extremely popular among expats and locals alike. Its also a great place to go for value on ones crypto: One can get delicious cocktails for around 150 CZK each ($6.24) and a pint of beer for just 25 CZK ($1.04) all paid for with crypto. Theres also a Bitcoin ATM located right inside the venue. But beware it gets packed quickly in the evenings almost every day of the week.

 

 

Bar No. 7 Praha. Source: Zhiyuan Sun

 

 

For scenic, short-term rentals or long-ish stays, you can book and pay for lodging with Prague Siesta Apartments using Bitcoin. Apartments are located at the heart of Prague, a minutes walk away from attractions such as the Old Town Square and the Astronomical Clock. Prices vary by season and typically fluctuate above or below 2,000 CZK per night ($83.08) with discounts for longer stays.

Paraleln Polis is the first coffee shop to accept cryptocurrencies in Central Europe and has been active since 2014. Though it has now largely evolved to become a co-working space and club venue, hosting various events, projects and refreshments for its members. But one can still purchase the venues original Bitcoin Coffee at its doorstep. Bitcoin, Litecoin or Lightning Network are accepted. Its named after Czech activist Vclav Bendas 1973 concept of Paraleln Polis (Parallel Polis) an independent society not oppressed by laws and decisions of representatives of central authorities. The idea became a rallying call for political dissidents and sounds very much like Libertarian Bitcoiner politics.

 

 

 

 

Alza is a leading e-commerce platform in Central Europe with close to $1.2 billion in annual sales. It has a catalog of crypto-related hardware devices that customers can pay for with Bitcoin (Ether and Litecoin payments are expected in the future). It also accepts Bitcoin on its local e-commerce subsidiaries operating in Slovakia, Germany, Austria, the United Kingdom and on Alzashop.com.

For crypto tourists who dont have an address in Prague to deliver to, you can get products shipped to the unique Alza Boxes package lockers for pickup. And thanks to General Bytes, it is also possible to buy cryptocurrencies at some of Alzas retail locations via in-store ATMs.

Finally, A Maze in Tchaiovna is a solid venue for tea and craft beer lovers alike. It is an all-in-one stop that combines elements of a teahouse, theater, gallery and bar. Cryptocurrency can be tendered for beverages and snacks. Live music is available periodically.

 

 

 

 

Education

Braiins, the company behind Slush Pool, runs a regular blog about how to get started on ones Bitcoin mining rig, along with the economics of such an operation. Similarly, Alza has its own blog series dedicated to educating readers and shoppers about Bitcoin. But Braiins takes it one step further by also publishing a series of books about the nature of Bitcoin decentralization and the future. They are free to read and are available in both hard copies and as complete pdfs on its site.

Currently, the University of New York in Prague is issuing digital diplomas using blockchain technology for all degrees accredited by the Czechias Ministry of Education. Students are provided a hyperlink to such accreditation with a QR code attached to verify its authenticity and can be freely shared among social networks.

 

 

Bitcoin: Odluka penz od sttu (Bitcoin: The Separation of Money From the State) by Josef Ttek and published by Braiins (in Czech) | Photo Credits: Josef Ttek
Bitcoin: Odluka penz od sttu (Bitcoin: The Separation of Money From the State) by Josef Ttek and published by Braiins. Source: Josef Ttek

 

 

Controversies

Being a closely-knit crypto community, Prague is not known for crypto scams or digital asset-related crime. The majority of misconduct happened in the previous decade, such as the collapse of the Bitcash.cz crypto exchange in 2013 and the theft of approximately 485 BTC. Another instance involved Czech national Tom Jikovsk and his alleged role in laundering $40 million worth of BTC in stolen funds from a securities fraud case in 2015. Earlier this year, an incident occurred with Trezor where the firms customer data was breached on third-party data vendor Mailchimp. It subsequently evolved into a phishing scam before it was quickly addressed.

That said, a much more serious incident occurred on August 18. Via a zero-day bug, hackers made themselves the default administrators of General Bytes’ ATMs and modified settings so that all deposits were transferred to their wallet address. A central client access server hosting the entirety of the company’s operation was compromised. General Bytes has urged customers to refrain from using its servers until its owners patches the exploit in an update.

 

 

(function() {window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || {listeners: [],forms: {on: function(evt, cb) {window.mc4wp.listeners.push({event : evt,callback: cb});}}}})();

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.


By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

Notable People

Pavol Stick Rusnk, co-founder of SatoshiLabs; Mark Slush Palatinus, co-founder of SatoshiLabs; Pavel Moravec, co-CEO of Braiins; Jan Capek, co-CEO of Braiins; Bach Nguyen, head of business development at Invity; Vojtch Frgl, CEO of General Bytes; Even Englberth CEO of Tropic Square; Jan Pleska, chief technology officer of Tropic Square; Josef Ttek, economist and SatoshiLabs brand ambassador; Kristian Csepscar, chief marketing officer of Braiins; Vojtch ern, head of commerce at Trezor; Tommy Poole, owner of Bar No. 7 Praha.

Cointelegraph members based in Prague:

Ever wonder whose creative mind is behind that of Cointelegraphs signature artistic style? Well, Cointelegraphs talented art team is led none-other by lead artist and art editor Anastasia Zhdanova, who is based in Prague. With an art career spanning 13+ years, Zhdanova is also the creator behind the (The Grey Everyday Life of Magicians) comic series. She graduated from the prestigious Stieglitz Academy of Art and Design in Saint Petersburg, Russia.

 

 

Europe and Crypto as portrayed by the Cointelegraph Art Team
Europe and crypto as portrayed by the Cointelegraph art team

 

 

If you have any suggestions for additions to this guide, please get in touch with zhiyuan.sun@cointelegraph.com

 

 

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC Sees Subdued Trading Amid Bearish Signals

Crypto City: Guide to New York

This Crypto City guide looks at New York Citys crypto culture, its most notable projects and people, its financial infrastructure, which retailers accept crypto, and where you can find blockchain education courses and theres even a short history of the controversial regulatory regime required to operate in the city.

 

Fast facts

City: New York
Country: United States
Population: 8.8 million
Established: 1624
Language: English

 

New York City is a bustling metropolis in the American state of New York. The city is divided into five separate boroughs the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and Staten Island each with its own unique geography and culture. While the states capital is Albany, NYC is its most widely known city and is one of the most famous cities in the world.

The most populous city in the United States, NYC is home to an estimated 8.8 million people, with an additional 1 million people traveling to the city every day for work (pre-pandemic). In 2019, the city also welcomed nearly 70 million tourists seeking to take in the bright lights of Times Square, see a Broadway musical, visit the Empire State Building, and enjoy NYCs dining and nightlife, among the many other sites and attractions the city offers.

New York City has been the setting for countless major films and television shows, which adds to its attraction as a tourist destination. Some of the most famous movies filmed in NYC include The Godfather, Ghostbusters, King Kong, Taxi Driver, West Side Story, Goodfellas, Breakfast at Tiffanys, Saturday Night Fever and many, many others. Sitcom classics Seinfeld and Friends were set in the city, and the long-running live sketch show Saturday Night Live broadcasts every weekend from 30 Rockefeller Plaza.

With Wall Street and the New York Stock Exchange located in lower Manhattan, the city is generally recognized as the financial capital of the United States, perhaps even the world. Its also the nations fashion capital and one of its major technology, music, film and television hubs. Home to around 3 million immigrants, NYC is widely known for its cultural diversity, with the Statue of Liberty famously inscribed with the words: Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.

 

 

New York
View of New York City skyline. Source: Pexels

 

 

The citys status as a hot location for crypto and blockchain culture has a lot to do with it being a major junction where finance and technology meet, according to Michael Moro, CEO of digital asset prime brokerage Genesis: New York City has always been the epicenter of the capital markets and, over time, has earned a global reputation for being an innovation and technology hub.

NYC is also a very wealthy city. The advantage of the city is really Wall Street, right? says Michael Shaulov, CEO of Fireblocks an institutional digital asset custody, transfer and settlement platform. You have a huge concentration of people who understand finance. You have a huge amount of capital flowing in from traditional finance into crypto. All the big venture capitalists are based in New York and are pushing into crypto.

 

 

 

 

Crypto culture

New York City has a long, well-established culture around cryptocurrency and blockchain. Way back on New Years Eve 2013/2014, Bitcoin Center NYC, a brick-and-mortar center dedicated to promoting and educating the public on the premier cryptocurrency, was launched by Nick Spanos a real estate executive turned Bitcoin evangelist. The center quickly became a hub for fans of the still fairly underground cryptocurrency.

Spanos tells Magazine that Bitcoin Center NYC brought Bitcoin from the back alleys to Wall Street, from something hidden to something celebrated, from something unknown to something open and transparent.

Bitcoin Center NYCs brick-and-mortar space. Source: Bitcoin Center NYC

Spanos later also founded the Blockchain Center, which is dedicated to education on the power of blockchain technology. He adds that while Bitcoin Center NYC has been relatively quiet during the COVID-19 pandemic, we have a new space and are looking at bringing back the popular Satoshi Square gatherings with an embrace of the growing crowd of Wall Street blockchain specialists and new believers.

The Big Apple hosts a number of major blockchain and crypto conferences, including the annual New York Blockchain Week. Though it was ultimately canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic, New York Blockchain Week 2020 was set to feature Consensus, the Digital Asset Summit, Ethereal Summit, The Block Summit, Magical Crypto Conference, ETH NYC and Smart Contract Summit #0. Some of the events went virtual, and the conference was again put on hold in 2021.

In-person conferences reappeared toward the end of 2021, including Blockworks Digital Asset Summit 2021, Mainnet 2021 and SALT, which were held in September, and CoinGeek Conference in early October, while NFT.NYC 2021 is scheduled for November.

Alex Mashinsky, a New Yorker who serves as CEO of crypto borrowing and lending platform Celsius Network which is headquartered just across the river in New Jersey tells Magazine that New York really is a crypto city: You have money, you have people, you have tech, and you have a lot of customers who consume this technology. Its a very cosmopolitan city, so you have people from every country and walk of life. He adds, We see a lot of wealth here. If rich people want to put 1% to 5% of their wealth into crypto, its going to happen here.

 

 

 

 

New York City has also been part of the burgeoning nonfungible token art scene. In March 2021, the artist collective Superchief opened what it alleged to be the first-ever brick-and-mortar NFT art gallery, and the Postmasters gallery in lower Manhattan has an NFT-focused division called PostmastersBLOCKCHAIN. Meanwhile, Beeples $69-million sale of Everydays: The First 5000 Days in March took place via the NYC branch of auction house Christies.

However, some warn that NYC has been undergoing a brain drain that has seen top talent going elsewhere, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic.

During the pandemic, other cities and states have been aggressively courting the crypto community with business, tax and regulatory incentives, and some have chosen to leave, says Moro.

Mashinsky adds, When you look at how fast Miami is moving, they created a coin for the city. They did all kinds of stuff, so were definitely behind. Were almost reacting instead of enacting.

Maybe thats why crypto has been shaping up as an election issue. In June 2021, Eric Adams, the Democratic frontrunner for NYCs next mayor, proclaimed that he would turn the city into the center of Bitcoins. Meanwhile, his Republican competitor, Curtis Sliwa, has pledged to make New York the most cryptocurrency-friendly city in the nation.

 

 

(function() {window.mc4wp = window.mc4wp || {listeners: [],forms: {on: function(evt, cb) {window.mc4wp.listeners.push({event : evt,callback: cb});}}}})();

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.


By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

Projects and companies

Many crypto and blockchain companies have called the tech and finance hub home. While New York States strict regulatory requirements may have prevented some exchanges from setting up shop (more on that later), Gemini still has its headquarters in NYC, as does the decentralized exchange Uniswap. Blockchain.com also maintains its U.S. headquarters in New York City, though it recently announced that it intends to relocate to Miami.

Several investment firms active in the crypto space are based in NYC, including New York Digital Investment Group, Galaxy Digital, Grayscale Investments, Union Square Ventures and Digital Currency Group.

Research firm Chainalysis is headquartered in NYC, as are infrastructure provider Bison Trails (which was recently acquired by Coinbase); financial services providers Fireblocks, Paxos and Paxful; digital-asset prime brokerage Genesis; NFT marketplace OpenSea; Ethereum-based software engineering firm ConsenSys; crypto-centric PR firm Ditto; peer-to-peer trading protocol AirSwap; and media company Cointelegraph. At least one-half of the team behind NFT tokenization platform Fractional is based in New York City.

Genesis Moro, a native New Yorker, tells Cointelegraph that he has always loved the energy, grit and determination that defines New York. He adds that Genesis has no plans to leave the city:

Genesis was born here. Our clients are based here. As an institutional prime brokerage, we think its important for us to be here. Because of the elite and diverse talent looking to enter the industry, particularly from the universities and Wall Street, our strong preference is to continue to grow our business here.

Several other companies are headquartered elsewhere but have a physical presence in the city, such as Pantera Capital, Bitwise and Horizen Labs. Meanwhile, Celsius used to have an office in the city but shuttered it when the pandemic struck. (A recent letter from the New York State Attorney Generals Office asking for details about the business may be a factor in whether Celsius reopens its office)

The city has itself launched blockchain projects. For example, in January 2019, the New York City Economic Development Corporation opened the NYC Blockchain Center, a 4,000-square-foot facility that operated for one year and focused on supporting entrepreneurship and promoting diversity and education.

New York Citys Blockchain Center initiative. Source: NYC Blockchain Center/New York City Economic Development Corporation

Financial infrastructure

New York City is a notoriously difficult place in which to trade cryptocurrencies, as only exchanges that have been awarded a coveted BitLicense from the New York State Department of Financial Services are allowed to offer virtual currency services to New York-based customers. At the time of writing, only three centralized exchanges Coinbase, Coinbase Pro and Gemini are accessible to New York residents. In addition, the number of coins available to trade on these platforms is limited when compared with what is available in other states. For New Yorkers who are willing to brave the waters of decentralized exchanges, all of the top DEXs such as Uniswap, 1inch, PancakeSwap, SushiSwap and others can be accessed from the city.

The citys hustle and bustle may result in you needing to buy BTC on the go. Thankfully, the city that never sleeps has dozens of Bitcoin ATMs scattered throughout the five boroughs though only a small handful of them allows you to also sell BTC. The city also has a Bitcoin Cash ATM located in the Bronx, an Ether ATM located in downtown Manhattan, and one ATM in the Bronx that will let you buy and sell Bitcoin, Ether, Litecoin, Dash and Zcash.

NYC residents have a number of options when it comes to traditional banking, including Chase Bank, Citibank, Wells Fargo, Bank of America, Capital One and more. But when it comes to using the money in ones bank account to purchase crypto, banks have historically been somewhat hesitant, with credit card purchases a notorious sticking point. In February 2018, crypto exchange Coinbase reported that customers of Chase, Bank of America, Citibank and Capital One were being blocked from purchasing crypto via the exchange.

However, banks seem to be easing up, and Mashinsky points out that August and September were very good months for crypto from a bank standpoint, with multiple major Wall Street banks announcing crypto services. Definitely plenty of progress this year from the tier-one banks.

NYSE
New York Stock Exchange building, located on Wall Street. Source: Pexels

Where can I spend crypto?

If you want to spend your hard-earned cryptocurrency, most retailers still wont accept it. However, New York City does have a small handful of crypto-friendly locations, according to Coinmap although many of them appear to be now closed.

If you are craving a bite to eat, bagel spot Forest Hills Bagels, Middle Eastern restaurant Shawarmania and Chinese food eatery Yong Sheng all located in Queens accept BTC. But if shopping is more your thing, vintage womens clothing store Marmalade in Brooklyns Greenpoint neighborhood, family-friendly apparel boutique Little Hippie in Williamsburg, or mineral seller Astro West on the Upper West Side of Manhattan may interest you.

The Postmasters art gallery in lower Manhattan accepts Bitcoin and Ether for any object available for purchase. The sale is done as a wallet-to-wallet transaction, and digital art sales come with freshly minted NFTs certifying ownership. Tamas Banovich, co-director of Postmasters, tells Magazine, There is this whole new market opening up with people having cryptocurrency. I think very soon, they will be interested in all kinds of art, not just digital and NFTs, and I want to be there early and make it available.

Meanwhile, private gym The Fitness Office on the Upper East Side of Manhattan accepts crypto, as do non-alcoholic bar Kavasutra in Manhattans East Village and Yeras Restaurant Sports Bar in Jackson Heights, Queens.

Education

There are multiple educational and training programs in New York City. Graduate students at Fordham Universitys Gabelli School of Business in the Bronx can take on a secondary concentration in blockchain technology. The program promises to give students the opportunity to master the skills needed to stand out in this space. Enrollees will take courses exploring the technology itself, the role and function of cryptocurrencies, and the business and legal concerns surrounding the space. The school also hosts the Fordham Fintech Network, which connects students with fintech firms and professionals.

New York Universitys Stern School of Business in lower Manhattan offers a fintech specialization that includes courses such as Accounting and the Blockchain, Topics in Cryptocurrency Investing and Digital Currencies, Blockchains, and the Financial Services Industry. Separately, students at NYUs School of Professional Studies can receive certificates in alternative investments and in fintech, both of which include a course titled Blockchain and Cryptocurrencies. Those looking for further on-campus engagement can join the Blockchain Lab @ NYU student group.

While Columbia University in upper Manhattan doesnt have a specific crypto concentration or certificate program, students can enroll in several courses focusing on blockchain and its various implementations, offered by Columbias engineering and business schools. The university also hosts the Columbia-IBM Center for Blockchain and Data Transparency, which is focused on education, research and innovation around blockchain and data. In addition, high school students can participate in a summer university immersion program and take a three-week Blockchain, Cryptocurrencies, AI, and Beyond course.

Meanwhile, Hunter College on Manhattans Upper East Side has previously offered an Intro to Blockchain course, and Cornell University, which is upstate in Ithaca, has an MBA program through which students can participate in an NYC-based fintech intensive consisting of four courses including Blockchain and Cryptocurrencies that are taught over seven weeks in the spring.

 

 

 

 

Regulatory controversies

New York City and crypto represent an interesting dichotomy. On one hand, NYC is a major hub for finance, technology and innovation; on the other, the state of New York is the most highly regulated place to do business in the nation. Any organization seeking to carry out virtual currency business activities in the state or to serve customers located in the state is required to acquire a license known as a BitLicense. The application process, maintained by the New York State Department of Financial Services, is known to be long, costly, arduous, confusing and highly complicated. Companies may also choose to apply for a limited-purpose trust charter and face even stricter regulations but receive additional benefits, such as fiduciary powers.

When the requirement was first implemented in mid-2015, a significant number of companies that had been serving NYC residents simply stopped offering their products to New Yorkers rather than go through the intense application process. At the time, the New York Business Journal dubbed it The Great Bitcoin Exodus.

Spanos tells Magazine, The NY DFS BitLicense was the death knell for crypto innovation in the entire state. It was the ultimate backroom deal cut in a smoke-filled room that allegedly protected consumers but actually harmed New Yorkers and restricted their free choice. He adds, If you do not have massive capital, you will not get off the ground.

Some of those that pulled out of the state include exchanges Kraken, Poloniex, ShapeShift and Bitfinex; peer-to-peer marketplace LocalBitcoins; mining firms BTC Guild, Genesis Mining and Eobot; and payments service GoCoin. While Paxful remains headquartered in the city, it is in the strange situation of not being able to actually serve anyone who lives there.

Mashinsky tells Magazine, The BitLicense was not put in place to protect the consumer or protect the community. That was something that this or that regulator put to create a job for themselves. He adds that the requirement also reduces healthy competition, resulting in higher fees for customers such as those seen on Coinbase. The reason they can get away with it is because they have a BitLicense and others dont.

However, Shaulov holds a different perspective, saying that the citys firm regulation is ultimately beneficial. At least there is some level of clarity of what is required in terms of what its like to operate in the city, he tells Magazine, adding, In the long term, where regulation will exist everywhere, clarity even if its somewhat unclear is best.

The inconvenient reality is that you cant escape regulation forever. At some point, you need to deal with it.

In 2019, the state initiated a new crackdown, this time on Bitfinex and Tether. It alleged that the sister companies lied about the backing of USDT and intentionally covered up massive financial losses. In February 2021, New York Attorney General Letitia James announced that the two companies neither of which has a BitLicense were banned from all trading activity involving New Yorkers, would pay a fine, and would submit to mandatory reporting requirements. A week later, James issued a warning to the industry: You either play by the rules or we will shut you down.

In addition, cryptocurrencies must be approved by the state before they can be listed or used in New York. The Department of Financial Services maintains a Greenlist of preapproved assets, which includes a handful of major coins, such as Bitcoin, Ether, XRP, Litecoin and Binance USD. Crypto assets not included on the Greenlist must be individually certified.

These controversial regulatory decisions trickle down to the average investor as well, as the opportunities to buy, sell and trade cryptocurrencies in New York City are rather limited. Its no wonder that Reddit is full of posts asking questions like Why is it so hard to buy cryptocurrency in New York state? and Why does New York suck so much ass for crypto investors?

Notable figures

New York City is home to a wide range of interesting characters, including many crypto pioneers, entrepreneurs and advocates. Some of its more notable figures include:

Hayden Adams, creator of Uniswap and CEO of Uniswap Labs; Charles Cascarilla, co-founder and CEO of Paxos; Devin Finzer, co-founder and CEO of OpenSea; Michael Gronager, CEO of Chainalysis; Robert Gutmann, co-founder and CEO of NYDIG; Letitia James, attorney general of the State of New York; Joe Lallouz, co-founder and CEO of Bison Trails; Joseph Lubin, co-founder of Ethereum and co-founder and CEO of ConsenSys; Alex Mashinsky, founder and CEO of Celsius Network; Michael Moro, CEO of Genesis; Michael Novogratz, CEO of Galaxy Digital; Anthony Pompliano, prominent investor; Michael Shaulov, co-founder and CEO of Fireblocks; Laura Shin, host of crypto-centric podcasts Unchained and Unconfirmed; Barry Silbert, founder and CEO of Digital Currency Group; Michael Sonnenshein, CEO of Grayscale Investments; Nick Spanos, founder of Bitcoin Center NYC and the Blockchain Center; Ross Stevens, founder and executive chairman of NYDIG; Cameron Winklevoss, co-founder and president of Gemini; Tyler Winklevoss, co-founder and CEO of Gemini; Andrew Yang, former presidential candidate and cryptocurrency advocate; and Ray Youssef, co-founder and CEO of Paxful.

Cointelegraph team members and contributors based in New York City: Jay Cassano, Jonathan DeYoung and Gordon Meyer.

Suggestions for additions to this guide are welcome. Please email: j.deyoung@cointelegraph.com

 

 

 

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC Sees Subdued Trading Amid Bearish Signals