1. Home
  2. davos

davos

Metaverse to bring ‘true productivity’ to industrial environments: Davos 2023

A panel of experts at the 2023 World Economic Forum highlighted how the metaverse could deliver practical use cases of large-scale industrial industries like healthcare and retail.

The metaverse continues to be a central talking point among leaders and decision-makers in global industries. For many, the vision of the future of the metaverse is not limited to a gamified version of reality.

At the World Economic Forum (WEF) 2023 in Davos, Switzerland, a panel of experts came together to discuss a global idea of an industrialized metaverse. With echoes of the industrial revolution, the industrialized metaverse will bring Web3 technologies into industries that are at play in everyday life.

The “Deployment in the Industrialized Metaverse” discussion started out with Abdullah Alswaha, the minister of communications and information technology in Saudi Arabia, expressing that the current reality of digital engagement doesn’t match up to its potential.

“The digital world that we live in today is not fit for purpose in the 21st century.”

Instead, it could, and arguably will be better off, leveling up the current digital communications for situations such as telework. Alswaha continued:

“I’m a big advocate of the metaverse that it’s going to be the next wave of how immersive experiences work for consumers, enterprises, and the industry.”

Peggy Johnson, the CEO of augmented reality company Magic Leap, said the industrial metaverse would only come into play when digital and physical worlds begin to merge:

“That’s when it really comes to life and brings true productivity in these industrial environments.”

Åsa Tamsons, the senior vice president and head of business area technologies at Ericsson, said this technology is already at play with big use cases in the healthcare, automotive and consumer electronics industries.

Another example was in retail onboarding:

“Huge retail and consumer goods companies are working on how to use this metaverse technology to improve and shorten the time for employee onboarding and training.”

When explicitly asked about metaverse technology in real-time situations in the healthcare industry, the CEO of Siemens Healthineers, Dr. Bernd Montag, said that although there are use cases, healthcare needs more time to catch on.

He clarified why the healthcare industry might be seen as being behind digitally.

“It is that you want to have ultimate safety. You want to have ultimate trust. This is sometimes harder to solve and that is why the adoption also doesn't come in with a big bang.”

However, he did mention that the shift to augmenting surgery with 3D is happening, albeit “very gradually.”

Related: Metaverse to possibly create $5T in value by 2030: McKinsey report

Both Tamsons and Johnson highlighted the need for governmental involvement in the release of new technology within a massive industry. This comes down to many things such as safety and privacy.

She continued to say there should be a line between under and over-regulation.

“I think that’s the appropriate way to bring new technologies. You don’t want to suppress innovation, but you also don’t want to allow [it] out in the wild without the proper constraints around it.”

At the recent Consumer Electronics Show 2023, new metaverse technology was showcased that could deploy touch and smell in digital reality, which has the potential to enhance interactions for both average and industrial usage in the near future. 

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

Metaverse not the endgame, but ‘ongoing digital transformation’: Davos 2023

Leaders in the Web3 space came together at the World Economic Forum in Davos to discuss first outputs from the “Defining and Building the Metaverse” initiative.

The metaverse has been a buzzword inside and out of the Web3 world over the last year. Moreover, development in the metaverse is something that has remained strong relative to the overall turmoil of the decentralized space.

It is also a hot topic at the 2023 World Economic Forum (WEF) in Davos, Switzerland. The WEF has been developing its own initiative, “Defining and Building the Metaverse,” with the participation of over 120 participants, for which it held a press conference on Jan. 18. 

The WEF panel highlighted the initiative’s first two papers, which cover interoperability, governance and the consumer’s role in the metaverse of the future.

Huda Al Hashimi, one of the panelists and the deputy minister of cabinet affairs for strategic affairs in the United Arab Emirates, framed the future of the metaverse as a space to break societal barriers and not recreate the same issues.

“We have to ask ourselves why we are still stuck in the domains we want to break through. We believe that a breakthrough will happen.” 

Particularly when it comes to governmental bodies creating their presence in digital reality, Hashimi says the vision of the initiative has reimagined the role of regulators.

“We also see that regulators will be acting more like referees rather than gatekeepers. That code of conduct will actually take precedence over formulating policies.”

Across the globe governments have been exploring the metaverse. The UAE in particular has already launched a government-backed metaverse city in the country as one of its many initiatives in digital reality. 

Norwegian governmental offices have also opened up metaverse branches to cater to the generation of users.

Cathay Li, the head of Shaping the Future of Media, Entertainment & Sport and member of the ExCom at World Economic Forum Geneva, said regulations and value creation are two key issues that needed to be understood for a digital reality that is beneficial for users.

“There is tremendous economic and societal value in this. But if it is unregulated, then there might be some issues with privacy, safety and security.”

Li said that the metaverse should not be looked at as an “end state” to all of the work and developments underway now. Rather it should be seen as an “ongoing digital transformation” of human experience in digital reality. 

In addition to ideas of governance, the panelists touched on interoperability and user data generation within the metaverse.

Related: Seoul government opens city’s metaverse project to public

Siu Yat, the co-founder and executive chairman of Animoca Brands, noted that digital property rights are key to the interoperability needed in the next evolution of the metaverse. He said :

“If you don't have judicial property rights, then you can actually have digital freedom - the freedom to transact because it's always permissioned. I think that this lies at the foundation of making interoperability benefit everyone.”

All three panelists had a five year vision of the metaverse that is more integrated into most people’s everyday life, along with more clear governance structures in place. “The metaverse will be part of our lives whether we like it or not,” said Hashimi. 

Yat closed by highlighting that a metaverse in the near future will also have generated new economies, which could be of a national scale. 

“New national economies will spring out of the metaverse, like a virtual society that is real because of all the transaction value and all the commerce that's happening on it.”

He particularly stressed that with more robust digital properties, users will actually be able to have a stake in these new digital economies. Recently, McKinsey reported the metaverse to potentially create $5 trillion in value in the next seven years. 

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

Bitcoin Suisse explains why Swiss is a crypto pivot point: Davos 2023

Bitcoin Suisse CEO emphasizes importance of "Swiss quality" and "safe custody for crypto industry."

Switzerland is a “pivot point” for crypto adoption in Europe and continues to be the “center point of the next stage of institutionalization," said Dr. Dirk Klee, CEO of Bitcoin Suisse. 

The CEO divulged why Switzerland is still the top spot for crypto in Europe and will continue to attract institutional investors in an exclusive Cointelegraph interview streetside in Davos, Switzerland. 

In discussion with Cointelegraph reporter Gareth Jenkinson, Klee explained: 

“A lot of trust has been destroyed and eroded in the last year and we want to be kind of the center point of the next stage of institutionalization, you know, making the place more accessible, easier to use, but also safer.”

Founded in 2013, Bitcoin Suisse is one of the oldest Bitcoin (BTC) and crypto companies specializing in asset storage, including “custody solutions deep in the Swiss mountains,” stated Klee.

Switzerland is a well-known safe haven for crypto in Europe. The landlocked country is recognized for its role in the inception of Ethereum (ETH), and is home to Crypto Valley — a favorable environment for blockchain and cryptocurrency companies.

Switzerland is known for "Crypto Valley," in the canton of Zug.

Switzerland also boasts the Bitcoin and crypto-friendly city of Lugano, which hosts an annual Bitcoin conference and has even onboarded McDonald's into accepting Bitcoin Lightning. 

Related: Putting carbon credits on blockchain won’t solve the problem alone: Davos

However, even in Switzerland, crypto confidence took a knock in 2022, particularly in light of the FTX debacle and its contagion effects across crypto: “It’s a setback for the industry. It has destroyed a lot of trusts and–you know–has also left a lot of investors harmed,” Klee explained.

In such an environment it’s useful to hark back to historic Swiss values. Switzerland is still a “safe safe place to do business."

“The Swiss finish, the Swiss quality is a narrative and is a quality sign that this industry needs because–you know–you need to have a trusted place.”

Thousands of crypto enthusiasts have flocked to the crypto and blockchain events at the World Economic Forum. Hosted at the seat of the Alps, in the Davos ski resort, it appears the overarching bear market has not disturbed the Swiss charm.

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

Davos 2023: Education is key to driving sustainability in blockchain and beyond

Cointelegraph’s editor-in-chief Kristina Lucrezia Cornèr moderated a panel discussion at the 2023 Davos conference in Switzerland on sustainability in the world of blockchain.

The World Economic Forum (WEF) in Davos, Switzerland, brings together global leaders and thinkers across various industries to hone in on global issues each year. As the world of crypto and blockchain continues to push into the mainstream view, it, too, has become a topic of discussion at the legacy event. 

Cointelegraph editor-in-chief Kristina Lucrezia Cornèr moderated a panel on Jan. 17, which touched on sustainability efforts in the blockchain industry. 

Even though not all panelists come from the same background, they unanimously highlighted education and learning as the key way to drive sustainability in emerging technologies during "The emergence of Breakthrough Technologies" panel.

The focus of the panel viewed sustainability in the blockchain industry through two lenses. One of which is in the “green” sense of the word - more energy efficient and sustainable for the environment. While the other speaks to the long-term impact of projects and initiatives in the greater Web3 space.

Mark Mueller-Eberstein, the CEO of business consultancy Adgetec Corporation, pointed out that the industry does suffer from “greenwashing,” but verification standards that can be taken from the blockchain can bring out productivity in sustainability practices in the industry.

“Knowing that we can trust the data is extremely important. This is why I think blockchain especially is so important.”

He continued to say that educating the community, especially the next generation, will be “the cornerstone for all of us, as societies and individuals."

Related: From games to piggy banks: Educating the Bitcoin ‘minors’ of the future

Christina Korp, the president of Purpose Entertainment and founder of SPACE for a Better World, pointed out the significance of education in older generations as well with an example of a U.S. congressman over the age of 70 who began educating himself on artificial intelligence.

“How can all these people make the decisions about what happens with the laws, when they don't even understand the technology or this new world?”

The CFO and treasurer of the Hedera Foundation, Betsabe Botaitis, also touched on trust as a foundation for a more sustainable industry, especially she said, as the blockchain industry can sometimes have a bit of a negative reputation.

“We need to be careful with that because it is easy to think that a new idea can be immediately funded. And that’s not always the case.”

Botaitis used carbon credit tracking as an example of a trust-building niche, in which blockchain can be utilized for this transparency and verification.

“It's such an honor to see how companies are coming together to really build this trust infrastructure, an immutable layer.”

Botaitis continued by saying that creating and leaving a sustainable legacy for the next generation is not just about wealth, but having a safe environment for that wealth and education, once again, the key.

“There's very, very little technology that is given for the education of wealth management. I think that it is the private sector that needs to have that education, the regulators and everyone that is having this conversation.”

Education continues to be a major touch point in the Web3 space, with many brands and initiatives focusing on educating users alongside technical developments. 

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

‘I thought SBF was the Mark Zuckerberg of crypto,’ says Anthony Scaramucci

Anthony Scaramucci said blockchain "skepticism is usually born from a lack of knowledge," while sharing his crypto holdings of Bitcoin, Ether, Solana and Algorand.

In a candid interview with Cointelegraph at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Anthony Scaramucci, cofounder of SkyBridge Capital, lambasted Sam Bankman-Fried and shed light on his crypto portfolio. 

Scaramucci trusted the former CEO, Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF) of FTX, which imploded in late 2021. Scaramucci said in a panel preceding the interview that the “Ninth circle of hell” is reserved for SBF. He added further color to the comments in discussion with Cointelegraph:

“I actually thought he was the Mark Zuckerberg of crypto. I didn't realize he was the Bernie Madoff. And that's something I have to own. And so I own it.”

The “Mooch” as he is known, explained he's happy to speak about his mistakes in trusting SBF. “I like speaking about it because if I can prevent somebody else from having a calamity like that, just from learning from us, that's worth it to me,” he explained.

Scaramucci is currently working at clawing back his company’s share that FTX lost. He is confident that the 30% stake that FTX Ventures acquired would be returned sometime in 2023.

The Cointelegraph team is reporting live from Davos.

Speaking with Gareth Jenkinson, senior reporter at Cointelegraph, Scaramucci also divulged his crypto portfolio:

“I started marking Bitcoin investments in 2020. We then started buying Ethereum in the early part of 2021. We have some Solana, we have something called Algorand, which is a smaller layer one, but it’s got very good technology.”

SkyBridge Capital's investments in crypto may come as a surprise to a thought leader who once tweeted he “could care less” about Bitcoin (BTC). Indeed, since Scaramucci first tweeted about Bitcoin one decade ago in 2013, the currency is up over 1,000%.

Scaramucci concluded he had made many mistakes during his Bitcoin and crypto journey. It took him many years and interactions with leaders in the space, such as the Winklevoss twins, before he invested. He shared that “Skepticism is usually born from a lack of knowledge.”

“The more homework you do on the blockchain, the more you understand how the blockchain is going to be a very big part of our future.”

The Mooch is now a regular commentator on the crypto space, and recently shared 2023 price predictions for Bitcoin in the six-figure territory. The "mainstream" is yet to really get to grips with the blockchain, he shred

Related: Scaramucci to invest in crypto firm founded by former FTX US boss

Ultimately, as more and more people begin to understand the importance of transacting with one another without a third party, the Bitcoin and blockchain space will take flight:

“When you understand the magnitude of that, it will be a wonderful layering mechanism that will lead to great economic efficiency and innovation. So that's why I'm in the space.”

According to Scaramucci, there is still plenty of room for growth in the Bitcoin, blockchain and crypto markets.

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

Cointelegraph heads to Davos for World Economic Forum

Cointelegraph will be on the ground as prominent figures from the cryptocurrency and blockchain space converge on Davos during the World Economic Forum.

As the World Economic Forum brings global leaders together to tackle global issues, a number of cryptocurrency and blockchain events will create a vibrant sideshow in the snowy ski destination in the Swiss Alps.

Cointelegraph will be on the ground to cover the World Economic Forum (WEF) as well as a host of blockchain-focused events taking place. Key members from global governments, businesses and civil society converge on the town annually for the WEF conference, but cryptocurrency and blockchain events are beginning to make their mark during the exclusive event.

The official WEF agenda for 2023 has made provision for cryptocurrency and blockchain as talking points featuring during the week-long conference. A session titled ‘Finding the Right Balance for Crypto’ on 19 January (15:00 CET) will explore the ‘boom and bust’ in crypto markets in 2022, and is set to consider the creation of ‘robust regulation’ of cryptocurrencies while ensuring ‘positive macroeconomic and societal outcomes.’

Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse features in the session alongside the Netherlands central bank president Klaas Knot, the European Commission’s Mairead McGuinness, and Omar Sultan Al Olama, the UAE’s Minister of State for Artificial Intelligence, Digital Economy and Remote Work Applications.

Circle CEO Jeremy Allaire will head up a session on Tokenized Economies on 17 January (16:15 CET), delving into which industries could see the biggest influence from tokenization.

Related: Crypto knocking on the WEF’s door: The view from Davos

The Metaverse is another topic that is set to be covered during WEF. A session titled ‘Deployment in the Industrial Metaverse’ is scheduled for 19 January (09:00 CET). Meanwhile, Meta’s chief product officer Chris Cox headlines a panel discussion, ‘A New Reality: Building the Metaverse’, which will unpack an estimated $180 billion in investment into the sector and its potential development driven by research, innovation, investment, and policy. This session is scheduled for 18 January (15:00 CET).

WEF is also tapping into the metaverse through its own 3D offering, allowing delegates to create avatars to explore different immersive environments.

Cointelegraph’s editor-in-chief Kristina Lucrezia Cornèr will attend WEF for the publication and is scheduled to moderate a number of panels at events during the week.

This includes a session during GBBC's #BlockchainCentral Davos 2023 titled Interoperability and Climate Change on 17 January (13:40 CET). Cornèr will also lead a panel on Liquidity in Climate Markets & Discovering a Global Carbon Price at Hedera Haus on 16 January (15:35 CET).

A panel at Greek House on 17 January (09:30 CET) will see Cornèr drive a conversation around ‘The emergence of Breakthrough Technologies: new ways to mobilize finance for Sustainable Investments’.

Cointelegraph journalist Gareth Jenkinson will be covering GBBC's #BlockchainCentral Davos 2023 and CV Labs’ Blockchain Hub Davos. Jenkinson is also set to moderate a session titled ‘Reports of Decentralized Finance Demise Are Greatly Exaggerated... DeFi 2.0 is Coming!’ at Blockchain Hub on 17 January (15:30 CET) as well as a panel on ‘The Future of the Metaverse’ at GBBC on 18 January (17:20 CET).

A host of influential industry participants from the cryptocurrency and blockchain space are set to feature prominently at different events including the likes of AVA Labs CEO & co-founder Emin Gün Sirer, SkyBridge Capital founder Anthony Scaramucci, and Cambridge Analytica whistleblower and data protection advocate Brittany Kaiser.

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

Bitcoin at the WEF: What did the world’s elite think of crypto?

In a Cointelegraph video, the world's elite and some crypto believers rub shoulders to share their views on crypto.

Cointelegraph introduces “Crypto Street,” a series of spontaneous conversations with strangers on the street to educate, entertain and take a temperature check on the world’s relationship with crypto.

The first episode comes from the gates of the World Economic Forum (WEF) in Davos, Switzerland. Cointelegraph reporter Joseph Hall attempted to speak with the world’s elite where he was rejected, ridiculed, and ignored before stumbling across crypto believers among the WEF attendees.

Sporting a Cointelegraph sweatshirt with the loudest Bitcoin (BTC) logo, Hall asked passersby to guess what was print represented. Some WEF-goers refused to talk on camera while others claimed ignorance.

“That’s not Bentley, it’s Bugatti!” One passerby at the World Economic Forum joked. That, or they genuinely believed that the Bitcoin logo is a luxury car brand.

The shoot then moves to the blockchain streets of Davos, where cryptocurrency companies outweigh the tradfi presence. Irina Heaver, a crypto lawyer and Bitcoin believer told Cointelegraph that Bitcoin is “freedom.” She explained that for her family:

“When the Soviet Union Collapsed, they were left absolute penniless — so did millions of other people [...] If they could have some of that (Bitcoin) can you imagine how their families would be better off?”

Heaver also explained that more and more Russians transact with Bitcoin and crypto, reflecting the growing popularity of cryptocurrency in the country. WEF attendees from India, where crypto education is weak at best, explained that the “younger generation is a lot more curious about Bitcoin and cryptocurrency.”

“Some rethinking and action need to happen to make it [crypto] more sustainable.”

The International Monetary Fund is close friends with the WEF, and it consistently pushes for central bank digital currencies as well as moving cryptocurrencies away from proof-of-work blockchains to less energy-intensive proof-of-stake blockchains.

Related: ‘CBDCs are the natural evolution,’ says HyperLedger director Barbosa

There’s also a cameo from Nas Daily, the Youtuber and Bitcoin HODLer who lost $200,000 on Bitcoin to date. He appears on camera and exclaims, “I lost so much money.”

Finally, there’s also a Golden Retriever who holds his tongue regarding Dogecoin (DOGE) price predictions for 2022, and an acapella rendition of Nina Simone by up-and-coming vocalist, Evan Klassen. Incidentally, Klassen is signing at the FIFA World Cup in Qatar this year; will he croon a crypto tune?

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

Digital assets still make a lot of sense, says Codex co-founder

In a Davos interview, Codex's Alex Gordon-Brander talked about the Ethereum launch, Codex’ liquidity specialties, and solving real-world problems with crypto.

Co-founder and chief evangelist officer for Codex, Alex Gordon-Brander, spoke to Cointelegraph about his Bitcoin story, the real-world use cases for crypto, and the economic downturn during a World Economic Forum interview in Davos, Switzerland. 

Standing curbside in front of Davos’ “Crypto House” at dusk, where Gordon-Brander had just finished demonstrating Codex’s capabilities during a crypto panel, the co-founder shared an upbeat outlook on crypto.

A long-serving crypto enthusiast and trad-fi veteran, Gordon-Brander told Cointelegraph he was exploring digital and energy-backed currencies prior to discovering Bitcoin (BTC). He researched a “distributed currency based on renewable energy credits and governments,” but he concedes it was “super complicated.”

Around the time, a friend shared a Bitcoin idea with Gordon-Brander, but like most people that first hear about Bitcoin — especially so early on — Gordon-Brander thought it’s “probably not going to work.”

He tried to get hold of some satoshis but his employer at the time, Bridgewater Associates– — founded by former Bitcoin basher turned Bitcoin bull, Ray Dalio — “couldn’t handle the compliance.” Fast forward to 2015, the year the Ethereum network launched, and Gordon-Brander realized the cryptocurrency space had legs.

“I’d been really intrigued by Bitcoin but the idea of a programmable currency — the idea of a world computer and an interoperable financial system, that blew me away,” he said.

From 2015 onwards, Gordon-Brander assisted the launch of a crypto exchange and participated in the initial coin offering boom before joining Codex Labs.

Related: ‘CBDCs are the natural evolution,’ says HyperLedger director Barbosa

Although interest among investors in decentralized applications is swelling such as those keen to acquire their first Ether (ETH), there is still “a lot of Bitcoin first” interest from institutions. Finally, while the bear market price action drags on, there is hope for Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies:

“As a secular trend bet, digital assets still make a lot of sense.”

Ultimately, Gordon-Brander explains, there has been an awakening regarding crypto finance and the role it can play in solving real-world problems, from “ordinary people realizing that their money in the bank was no longer safe if their government doesn’t like their politics,” to tackling climate change:

“The world is in a much better place with this technology than it would be without it.”

His former boss at Bridgewater, Ray Dalio, now recommends a small allocation to Bitcoin and the optimism that crypto brought to the WEF was hard to ignore.

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

‘CBDCs are the natural evolution,’ says HyperLedger director Barbosa

In an interview filmed during the World Economic Forum in Davos, Daniela Barbosa gives the floor to enterprise blockchains and the future of currencies.

For Daniela Barbosa — general manager of blockchain, healthcare and identity at the Linux Foundation and executive director of Hyperledger — digital currencies and cryptocurrencies have made it among the big banks at the World Economic Forum in Davos. 

In an interview with Cointelegraph shot against the backdrop of the Swiss Alps, Barbosa explained that in the few years she has attended the WEF, the presence of cryptocurrency companies has steadily grown. What's more, we should not be afraid of central bank digital currencies (CBDCs).

“CBDCs are [a]natural evolution of digital dollars and digital currencies.”

While the WEF saw calls from some bankers for a CBDC rollout to slow down, Barbosa explained that a CBDC could be with us in this decade.

Hyperledger’s work overlaps that of CBDCs, particularly in light of a partnership with the Digital Dollar Project. The nonprofit organization seeks to further the research into a U.S. CBDC. The key to CBDC implementation, however, is in succeeding with “privacy-preserving methods.”

An advocate for digital identity, privacy and “having control of your data,” Barbosa also shared the story of how she got into Bitcoin while living in San Francisco and working for Dow Jones in the mid-2010s.

“I did go to a [Bitcoin] meetup once and I was older than everybody else and also female—and I thought, maybe this is not for me?”

Fortunately, Barbosa kept abreast of Bitcoin and the market when time allowed before joining HyperLedger, an enterprise blockchain solutions-based company, in 2016.

Related: UN agency head sees 'massive opportunities' in crypto: WEF 2022

While blockchains can sometimes be touted as a catch-all solution, Barbosa explained that sometimes blockchains are not the ideal situation and “should not be used.” Many blockchain use cases in 2016 and 2017, for example, wanted the “media to pay attention.” In 2022, a blockchain works when:

“You want to use a distributed ledger when you have multi parties that are working together—you don’t want to have to create another middle layer than helps disintermediate all the assets going around.”

HyperLedger now covers everything from pharmaceuticals to finance while its blockchain solutions tackle climate change

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’

Report: Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse Hints at Future Mergers and Acquisitions

Report: Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse Hints at Future Mergers and AcquisitionsWhile visiting the World Economic Forum (WEF) event in Davos, Ripple Labs CEO, Brad Garlinghouse discussed the firm’s growth opportunities and despite the crypto economy’s downturn, Garlinghouse spoke about future mergers and acquisitions. ‘I Think We’re More Likely to Be the Buyer,’ Ripple Labs CEO Brad Garlinghouse Said During an Interview in Davos Just recently, […]

TRUMP dips after president admits ‘I don’t know much about it’