DPI
Index Coop to include BadgerDAO in DPI DeFi index from August
The DPI token’s price has crashed more than 64% in six weeks.
BADGER, the governance token of Ethereum-powered Bitcoin yield protocol, BadgerDAO, will be included in Index Coop’s DeFiPulse Index (DPI) token from August.
Index Coop announced the news on June 26, noting BADGER’s inclusion would be pushed back by one month due to prioritizing other upgrades.
Slight Correction
— Index Coop (@indexcoop) June 25, 2021
DeFi Pulse Index has added $BADGER to the methodology.
However, it will not be included in this month's $DPI rebalance due to the necessity to add support for a wBTC pair to our rebalancing operations.$BADGER will be added to next month's rebalance.
The DPI token is a market cap-weighted index spanning the 10-most popular Ethereum-based DeFi tokens listed on decentralized finance data aggregator, DeFiPulse.
The DPI index token rebalances on the first day of every month, adjusting allocations according to supply and price data provided by CoinGecko. Tokens will not be allocated a weighting higher than 25% during rebalancing.
As of this writing, UNI has the largest allocation in the DPI Index with roughly 26.5%, followed by AAVE with 18.4%, MKR with 13.5%, and COMP with 9.3%.
SUSHI, YFI, and SNX each have allocations of between 7% and 8.6%, while LRC, REN, KNC, and BAL are weighted between 1.2% and 2.4%. CREAM, FARM, and MTA represent less than 1% of the index each.
The index excludes wrapped tokens, synthetic assets, tokenized derived, tokens that are tied to physical assets, and tokens that represent ownership claims to other tokens.
Related: Overexposed: DeFi indexes aren’t as diversified as you think
DPI has shed nearly two-thirds of its value over roughly six weeks, tanking from a May 12 all-time high of $656.49 to last change hands for $234.
Despite suffering a heavy drawdown amid the recent crypto market crash, DPI is still up more than 300% from its November 2020 low of $57.20.
Vampire Attack or Innovation? Basketdao Storms the DeFi Index Scene
BasketDAO has announced its new DeFi index: BDPI.
By taking the same underlying assets and converting them to their yield-bearing equivalent, BasketDAO is offering better a better return than DeFi Pulse’s DPI. Innovation or vampire attack?
One DeFi Index to Rule Them All
At this point, DeFi Pulse’s DPI is a household name. Any DeFi user has seen DeFi Pulse’s analytics and has considered investing through their index DPI, representing many DeFi “blue chip” tokens. Still, competition has been mounting.
BasketDAO is trying to chip away at DPI’s dominance in the DeFi index game.
To do so, they will take the same assets with the same portfolio structure but convert these assets to their yield-bearing equivalent on lending protocols. Instead of SNX, for example, BasketDAO’s BDPI will have Aave’s interest-bearing SNX token, aSNX.
To encourage migration from DPI to BDPI, BasketDAO will offer its governance token BASK. BasketDAO declared that BASK is a governance token that will accrue value from the interest-bearing tokens in BDPI.
BasketDAO’s BDPI has already managed to reach a total value locked of $41 million, ranking it second behind Index Coop’s DPI in the list of DeFi indexes (Set Protocol is the website on which you can purchase DPI or other indexes).
Due to DeFi’s transparent nature, any project can build on top of any other project’s work. Sometimes, a new protocol is built on top of an older one because it has a different aim or target audience. This is the case with Cream Finance; built on top of Compound but targeted at a different audience. Often the cooperation goes smoothly.
There are cases, though, where the new protocol copies the older one and adds new incentives without truly innovating. This is what Sushiswap was accused of at its inception. To push users to migrate from Uniswap to its clone, Sushiswap offered its governance token as an incentive. This is referred to as a vampire attack.
In the case of BDPI, the line between innovation and vampire attack is hard to call.
On the one hand, BDPI is copying many elements of DPI’s product. On the other, the idea of replacing the DeFi tokens with interest-bearing ones is an important innovation that benefits users and guarantees higher returns. There is little reason for DPI holders to not migrate to BDPI – especially considering the liquidity mining rewards in the protocol’s governance token BASK.
Crypto Briefing asked Indexed.finance team member Lito Coen, another DeFi index project with $30 million total value locked, whether BasketDAO was likely to continue redirecting funds from DPI.
“We’ll see if BasketDAO can differentiate themselves over the long-term. DPI’s big strength is not the portfolio structure they use but their marketing skills and brand. This can’t be forked,” said Coen.
Disclaimer: The author held BTC, ETH, NDX, and several other cryptocurrencies at writing.