1. Home
  2. Features

Features

‘Terra hit us incredibly hard’: Sunny Aggarwal of Osmosis Labs

Sunny Aggarwal has vivid memories of some of the worst days of his life earlier this year. The blockchain co-founder and his Osmosis protocol were hit hard by the TerraLUNA collapse and are still recovering from its fallout today.

The Terra crash hit us incredibly hard because we were one of the biggest DEXs for providing liquidity to TerraUSD and Luna Classic, he explains, At one point, it made up over 50% of our liquidity. 

I always tell people that the Terra Luna protocol was created by someone with either an IQ of 50 or 150. And frankly, I cant tell which one.

Aggarwal is a co-founder and leads the development of the $225-million Osmosis DEX, which, at one point, eclipsed $2 billion in TVL before the coming of the crypto winter.

The rise of cross-chain bridges 

Osmosis is a decentralized exchange (DEX) operating on Cosmos, the creator of the interblockchain communications protocol (IBC).

At the time of the last bear market, the development of interchain technologies, allowing users, data and tokens to port between chains, was close to being on the edge of the unknown. 

Laser-focused on price movements of tokens, few traders were across terminology, such as IBC, Tendermint or Cosmos. But fast forward five years, there are now nearly 50 blockchains using IBC to conduct more than 10 million IBC transactions daily across the ecosystem. And it still has more than $1 billion in total value locked across the protocol despite the market sell-off. 

Apart from his work in blockchain, Aggarwal is known for his eccentric selection of hats.

Osmosis aside, Sunny Aggarwal is also known for his splendid hat collection. Source: Sunny Aggarwal

The meme that started a crypto career

A good friend of mine walked up to me and said, Did you know that Dogecoin just sponsored the Jamaican bobsled team? he recalls. And I was like, What the hell is Dogecoin? What does it even mean?

Aggarwal first became aware of cryptos existence during his senior year at Bridgewater-Raritan High School in New Jersey. At the time, crypto was a relatively new phenomenon and there were no extracurriculars or school clubs about the subject. Instead, the idea of blockchain spread the old-fashioned way. 

That sentence didnt make any sense to me, Aggarwal tells Magazine. But Im always fascinated by what I dont know, so I went home that night and looked up Dogecoin for the first time.

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

Terra hit us incredibly hard: Sunny Aggarwal of Osmosis Labs

Features

Google and Coinbase strike a deal, BNY Mellon begins crypto custody and WisdomTrees Bitcoin ETF gets denied: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 9-15

Like many others, Aggarwal found the idea of Dogecoin interesting and quite funny but did not really expect the coin to evolve into a billion-dollar-market-cap asset with celebrities fussing over it as it has. 

Instead, Dogecoin became a gateway token for Aggarwal to explore the vast realm of digital currencies. And so, during his freshman year majoring in computer science and political economy at the University of California, Berkeley, Aggarwal joined a small blockchain club and began teaching the subject to a class of roughly 80 students in his first semester. 

Blockchain at UC Berkeley has since grown into a burgeoning community. Source: Blockchain at Berkeley

For me, the best way to learn something is to teach it. At Berkeley, theres this cool concept where students can teach courses as long as its backed by professors. And so, my computer science professor Dawn Song gave us the green light. 

A lateral path toward the interchain 

From the pool of students who attended his lectures, Aggarwal invited them to a new club he founded called Blockchain at Berkley, which is still ongoing and has since evolved into an award-winning blockchain consulting and development team. After learning the required knowledge, Aggarwal interned at Consensus, the creator of the popular MetaMask wallet, after his sophomore year in the summer of 2017. 

All of us in the club were pretty much Bitcoin maximalists at the time, but we felt like something was missing in the ecosystem, he says. At that time, Ethereum was gaining a lot of traction, and I wanted to learn more about it.

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

Terra hit us incredibly hard: Sunny Aggarwal of Osmosis Labs

Features

Google and Coinbase strike a deal, BNY Mellon begins crypto custody and WisdomTrees Bitcoin ETF gets denied: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 9-15

Contrary to expectations, Aggarwal did not find Ethereum to his liking. It just didnt click for me, and there was no roadmap as to how the network could have worked out in the long term. But the experience turned his attention toward a novel mechanism called proof-of-stake consensus. 

And so, Aggarwal went out and read all the proof-of-stake white papers he could lay his hands on. Out of all of them, it was the Tendermint piece that I liked the most, says Aggarwal, citing the protocols simplicity. Devs could build this in, like, a couple of months if we all wanted to. 

That summer, Aggarwal reached out to the Tendermint team, which is the core developers of the Cosmos and IBC ecosystem, and asked if any positions were available. At the time, the would-be Osmosis co-founder didnt even know that Tendermint was behind Cosmos. But after hearing about its projects in development, such as IBC and cross-chain bridges, Aggarwal felt that the ecosystem was a perfect fit. 

Sunny Aggarwal at Cosmoverse, with his iconic headdress. Source: Cosmoverse

Everything just clicked. The idea of Cosmos solved all the issues I saw with the Ethereum model. So, I dropped out of UC Berkeley that September and began working on Cosmos full-time. Ive been doing it for the last five years. 

According to Aggarwal, what really fascinated him about IBC was its scalability on both the technical and social levels. Just take a look at Ethereum, he says. It has gotten so big to the point where theres tens of thousands of DApps building on it. And that, in my view, means that technical advancement on the blockchain grinds to a halt. 

Aggarwal explains that its simply unfeasible to consider all Ethereum projects needs, given the sheer numbers. Things would be much simpler if instead of you had fully vertically integrated app chains that could iterate the protocol layer very rapidly like IBC. In addition, the history of Ethereum hard forks further solidified his belief in IBC.

Each application and community should have sovereignty over their own system. We cant fork a blockchain every time there is a disagreement. If one application wants to fork, that shouldnt cause my application to fork as well.

Osmosis developers at WeWork. Source: Sunny Aggarwal, Twitter

Users of the Osmosis DEX can make use of 89 cross-chain bridges across 45 blockchains on Osmosis. That means one can swap in and out of connected tokens in a noncustodial manner, as well as earn swap fees for providing liquidity. 

Like most co-founders, on an average day in Osmosis, Aggarwal spends most of his time taking calls and coordinating the teams internal focus. About 25% of his time is devoted to coding and the remainder is spent networking with stakeholders in the ecosystem and with those looking to join.

But the event made Aggarwal and his team think long and hard about the protocols vulnerabilities. Experiencing two tokens making up over half of our liquidity crashing to zero in a matter of days made us implement stricter safety controls. On Osmosis, bridge rate limiting is now in place where, for illustrative purposes, a pool containing $100 million of digital assets can only have $5 million or so moved across an IBC bridge every six hours.

IBC protocols such as the Osmosis DEX connects digital assets across blockchains. Source: Map of Zones

Reflections and the road beyond

Moving forward, Aggarwal sees himself working for Osmosis in the next five years or so. What Osmosis means will change over time; will it always just be a DEX, or transition into some other element? I cant say for sure. But its Aggarwals firm belief that most crypto projects will be built on Cosmos in the next decade. Hence, he says, I can definitely see myself working on this stuff for the long term.

As to his ultimate vision for DeFi, Aggarwal says it all boils down to one catchphrase hes polished over the years: 

Its all about enabling privacy for the individual and transparency for the system. 

He points to the example of Robinhood and the firms practice of selling customers order flow to big hedge funds to make a profit: Thats why we want to build a privacy-enabled DEX where none of that stuff happens. But at the same time, we want the system to be accountable. We want users to see, for example, how much overall leverage the protocol has. And not some clouded manifestation like in CeFi. Thats the vision I want to give. 

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

Terra hit us incredibly hard: Sunny Aggarwal of Osmosis Labs

Features

Google and Coinbase strike a deal, BNY Mellon begins crypto custody and WisdomTrees Bitcoin ETF gets denied: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 9-15

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Google and Coinbase strike a deal, BNY Mellon begins crypto custody and WisdomTree’s Bitcoin ETF gets denied: Hodler’s Digest, Oct. 9-15

Coming every Saturday, Hodlers Digest will help you track every single important news story that happened this week. The best (and worst) quotes, adoption and regulation highlights, leading coins, predictions and much more a week on Cointelegraph in one link.

Top Stories This Week

Breaking: Google taps Coinbase to bring crypto payments to cloud services

Starting in early 2023, Coinbases payment service, Coinbase Commerce, will facilitate crypto payments for customers purchasing Googles cloud services thanks to a deal between the two companies. Google will only allow certain crypto assets for payment, including Bitcoin. Initially limited to certain participants, the option to pay with crypto will eventually be expanded to other customers, an executive at Google Cloud told CNBC. Google Cloud has taken several other steps toward crypto and blockchain industry involvement in 2022. 

BNY Mellon, Americas oldest bank, launches crypto services

Banking giant BNY Mellon has entered the crypto custody field, offering certain customers Bitcoin and Ether custody services via a new platform. The 238-year-old bank will provide bookkeeping for clients crypto in a similar fashion as it does for traditional assets, while also handling clients private keys. BNY Mellons CEO of securities services and digital, Roman Regelman, said: With Digital Asset Custody, we continue our journey of trust and innovation into the evolving digital assets space, while embracing leading technology and collaborating with fintechs.

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

FTX partners with Visa, BNB Chain suffers exploit and Elon Musk returns to $44B Twitter deal: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 2-8

SEC rejects WisdomTrees application for a spot Bitcoin ETF… again

Following multiple delays, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has denied WisdomTrees spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) proposal, which the firm filed in January. The SEC cited fears of market manipulation and fraud as the rationale for its decision, which is consistent with its previous rationale for denying spot Bitcoin ETFs. The SEC also denied a spot Bitcoin ETF proposal from WisdomTree in 2021.

PayPal says policy to punish users for misinformation was in error

PayPals Acceptable Use Policy was set to change in early November to include a $2,500 fine for any platform users that promote, post, send or publicize so-called misinformation. PayPal has since claimed that the policy provision was added in error. PayPal is not fining people for misinformation and this language was never intended to be inserted in our policy, said PayPal. The fiasco has reignited concerns about centralized platforms among crypto users who view self-custody as an important pillar of self-sovereignty and financial inclusion.

Blockchain games and metaverse projects raised $1.3B in Q3: DappRadar

Data from DappRadar revealed that $1.3 billion worth of venture capital flowed into metaverse projects and blockchain games in Q3 a bright spot amid crypto bear market darkness. While venture capital funding for these sectors was down 48% compared with Q2, the Q3 figure was still more than double the amount invested in all of 2021.

Winners and Losers

At the end of the week, Bitcoin (BTC) is at $19,665, Ether (ETH) at $1,329 and XRP at $0.50. The total market cap is at $938.70 billion, according to CoinMarketCap.

Among the biggest 100 cryptocurrencies, the top three altcoin gainers of the week are Huobi Token (HT) at 87.06%, TerraClassicUSD (USTC) at 63.33% and Quant (QNT) at 22.07%.  

The top three altcoin losers of the week are Klaytn (KLAY) at -20.36%, Internet Computer (ICP) at -15.04% and eCash (XEC) at -14.48%.

For more info on crypto prices, make sure to read Cointelegraphs market analysis.

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

FTX partners with Visa, BNB Chain suffers exploit and Elon Musk returns to $44B Twitter deal: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 2-8

Most Memorable Quotations

Ethereum is the Hotel California of cryptocurrencies. You can check in, but you cant check out.

Charles Hoskinson, founder of Cardano

Elon Musk quotes posts about Dogecoin, you get seven times daily signups.

Alex Harper, co-CEO and co-founder of Swyftx

If we [the crypto industry] want to achieve internet scale, we need a solution for AML/CTF compliance.

John Henderson, partner at Airtree Ventures

A bear market is the best time to start working in crypto and find a job.

Raman Shalupau, founder of Crypto Jobs List

There is protection in gold. But in my opinion, Bitcoin is far superior. It’s got math and code. Its defended by a decentralized protocol. You dont mess with math.

Greg Foss, executive director of strategic initiatives at Validus Power Corp

Its incredibly important not to ever forget that we have an immense responsibility that influencers do not. They have their own risks in terms of their followers trust, but we have our responsibility to keep our integrity as journalists.

Kristina Cornr, editor-in-chief of Cointelegraph

Prediction of the Week 

BTC price hits 3-week lows on US CPI as Bitcoin liquidates $57M

For most of the week, Bitcoin traded sideways, slightly favoring the downside, according to Cointelegraphs BTC price index. The asset sustained a fair bit of price volatility on Oct. 13, however, in line with the release of Septembers U.S. inflation data. Bitcoins price dropped down near $18,200 following the news but subsequently rebounded above $19,000.  

In an Oct. 13 post, pseudonymous Twitter user il Capo of Crypto tweeted about the possibility of Bitcoins drop being a bear trap, noting a potential subsequent rally to $21,000, followed by a stark drop.

FUD of the Week

US Treasurys OFAC and FinCEN announce $29M in enforcement actions against Bittrex

Crypto exchange Bittrex faces charges from two different United States regulators: the Department of the Treasurys Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) and the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). The regulatory authorities have essentially alleged that Bittrex did not conduct proper due diligence on its customers and transactions between 2014 and 2018, which allowed users from sanctioned regions to use the platform. Bittrex confirmed it would settle with OFAC for around $24 million, which may also be applied as a credit toward its $29 million settlement owed to FinCEN. Looking to move forward from the situation, Bittrex stated that it has been up to date with expected standards since 2018.

$100M drained from Solana DeFi platform Mango Markets, token plunges 52%

Mango Markets, a decentralized finance platform running on the Solana blockchain, reportedly bled around $100 million from its treasury thanks to an exploit. Someone manipulated price data for the platforms native MNGO asset, letting them borrow crypto worth far more than the value of the MNGO they put up as collateral. MNGO suffered a roughly 50% price drop following news of the event. Later reporting saw the hacker coming forward, demanding a $70 million bug reward and other terms to return exploited funds.

CNN to shut down its NFT marketplace and issue 20% refund

After about four months, media outlet CNN has decided to discontinue its nonfungible token (NFT) endeavor, seemingly another bear market casualty. The media companys NFT project, known as Vault by CNN, essentially offered tokenized memories of historical news events spanning multiple decades through CNNs history. The projects roadmap projected six months of development, although the media outlet has since claimed the project was a 6-week experiment, according to an announcement from the Vault by CNN Twitter account. NFT buyers will get a 20% reimbursement of the price they paid to mint their NFTs, according to a CNN staffer on Discord.

Best Cointelegraph Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

zkEVMs are launching this month and offer a path to infinite scaling for Ethereum. But who will win the race between Polygon, zkSync, Scroll and StarkWare?

Mass adoption will be terrible for crypto

From reversible transactions to increased regulation and a rising tide of censorship, mass adoption is going to make crypto look more like the systems were trying to escape.

Cryptos downturn is about more than the macro environment

The global economic downturn should not have a long-term negative effect on cryptocurrency prices, even if it is influencing crypto in the short term.

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Attack of the zkEVMs! Crypto’s 10x moment

Crypto is currently languishing like the internet did in 1996 with slow speeds and few practical use cases, says Steve Newcomb, chief product officer of Matter Labs.

But a major increase in bandwidth and security soon after saw the internet become a crucial part of daily life across the globe and were right on the cusp of that happening for crypto in the next few months.

“Nobody trusted their credit card on it and everybody thought it was a fad and there weren’t any use cases for it,” Newcomb explains. 

“And then we had 10x moments in bandwidth and then SSL came, and HTPS where you got that lock that was a 10x moment in trust. Suddenly in 2005 ecommerce just went through the roof.”

Cryptos 10x moment could finally be here, with zkSync’s Ethereum Virtual Machine compatible mainnet launching on October 28. EVM is essentially the operating system for Ethereum and enabling it to work using zero knowledge rollups means everything running on Ethereum can seamlessly port over to experience a huge jump in speed and lower costs. 

Theyre not the only ones attacking the problem: Polygon launched its testnet for its own zkEVM this week with Aave, Uniswap and Lens all committing to deploy on it. Scroll launched its Pre Alpha testnet in July while StarkWares zk solution has been ploughing through millions of transactions a month

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin says zk rollups mean crypto can be finally be used for payments again
Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin says ZK rollups mean crypto can finally be used for payments again. (Andrew Fenton)

These solutions are all well funded, with Scroll raising $30M, Starkware raising $150M and Polygon raising $450M. Newcomb hints that zkSyncs own funding round is in the same ballpark as Polygons, but its yet to be officially announced.  

StarkWare is way out ahead of the pack, having launched its own zk rollup solution nine months ago and it turned on recursive scaling in August. But it also made the risky decision to use a custom programming language called Cairo in order to scale more efficiently. This could see adoption by the big protocols move to the path of least resistance on the EVM compatible solutions.

All of the solutions are also working on recursive scaling and/or Layer 3 implementations which will see Ethereum transactions potentially become thousands of times faster, remove the need for interchain bridges, and allow crypto to finally realize its true potential.

What is a zero knowledge thingamy?

ZK rollups are among the biggest buzzwords in blockchain today. The technology allows for thousands of transactions to be computed away from the achingly slow Ethereum blockchain, with a tiny “validity proof” verifying that all the transactions were carried out correctly. So you can “roll up” 10,000 transactions carried out elsewhere into a single ETH transaction. This is a big deal because even after the Merge Ethereum limps along at 15 transactions per second.

ZK rollups have been used for NFTs and financial transactions for some time now on platforms like Loopring, dyDx and others. But as co-founder Vitalik Buterin pointed out during ETH Seoul in August: 

“In general, I think we’ve learned that people don’t just want like a scalable money thing, they want a scalable EVM.”

Its one of what Newcomb calls five magic elements for ZK rollups. In his view a ZK rollup solution should be general purpose, EVM Compatible and support Ethereums programming language Solidity. It should also be open source to fit with cryptos founding ethos, and it should have a token distribution that decentralizes the protocol rather than concentrates wealth among the team.

By curious coincidence, zkSync has achieved all five of these self imposed metrics. (Newcomb says he cant detail the exact token distribution, but says around 30% for insiders seems to be the consensus.)

The checklist is something of a veiled criticism of competitor StarkWare which is set to give 49.9% of its StarkNet token supply to investors and core contributors. Its also not open source, although it plans to give control of the IP to its community. 

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

FTX partners with Visa, BNB Chain suffers exploit and Elon Musk returns to $44B Twitter deal: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 2-8

Features

Get your money back: The weird world of crypto litigation

Co-founder Eli Ben-Sasson explains that the only way to take full advantage of the scaling afforded by ZK rollups is to use a custom language like Cairo.

“I’m very confident people will realise once they turn on proofs that the goal is not to simulate EVM. The goal is to reach scalability. To put 10,000, 100,000, one million transactions and have their proof fitted inside a single block of Ethereum, he says.

“I’m willing to bet that you won’t see a full blown ZK EVM that can put a million transactions inside a single proof on Ethereum. As we can easily do today and have been doing for months and years.

Eli Ben-Sasson says its solution is faster and better than kludgy EVMs. (Andrew Fenton)

Scaling versus compatibility

StarkWare’s Odin-Free explained on Twitter there are complicated mathematical reasons behind the need for a custom language because “proof systems like Stark are based on polynomials over finite fields, giving a much more effective polynomial equation.” OK, lets take his word for it.

For Ben-Sasson, trying to soup up the EVM is just dumb:

“If you wanted to solve transportation, you could take a big truck and put it inside a plane and have the plane deliver it, he says.

“There are planes that can fit a truck inside, but that’s a very inefficient way of doing it. Far better way is just taking things and putting them directly in the plane.”

That said, the ecosystem does have a transpiler called Warp that turns Solidity code into Cairo code and which has just been used to port over a fork of Uniswap to StarkNet.

So essentially with zk rollups there is a choice to be made between total compatibility with the EVM and scaling. Total compatibility enables DApps and protocols to seamlessly port over and everything just works exactly like on Ethereum for devs and users, but in scaling terms, faster is obviously better.

Newcomb admits StarkWares solution will produce scale better, but says sacrificing accessibility means it is more suited to bespoke enterprise applications than being a fundamental part of Ethereum due to adoption friction.

They’re not EVM compatible, so it’s really hard to port to them. We’ve seen projects that take seven months to port to them.

Compatible but less elegant

Theres no agreed upon definition, but EVM equivalent usually means exactly the same as EVM so you can just deploy the existing smart contract on the solution without any changes.

Scroll is widely agreed to be equivalent, but its also not on a proper testnet yet and is many months behind the others with a comparatively small budget. Polygons zkEVM solution claims to be equivalent (however this is contested.) zkSync meanwhile, will be EVM compatible – which means its almost identical but a few things may not work due to some design choices to make the solution work better.

Steve Newcomb is passionate about why he believes zkSync has all five ingredients required for success. (Interview screenshot)

Polygon launched its zkEVM Public Testnet on Monday claiming Polygon is the first project ever to deliver a full-featured, open source implementation of zkEVM; a groundbreaking milestone, not just for Polygon, but for the whole industry. Polygon says the testnet includes a completely open-sourced zk-Prover the first of its kind to be released publicly.

Co-founder Mihailo Bjelic tells Magazine early tests show that Polygons zkEVM can reduce Ethereums network fees by approximately 90% and increase the networks throughput by several orders of magnitude.

He says that open sourcing the technology “proves our alignment with the ethos of the industry and increases security of the solution since anyone can review it and point out potential bugs. This is not the case with StarkNet or zkSync, which keep critical parts of their implementations closed source, at least for now.”

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

FTX partners with Visa, BNB Chain suffers exploit and Elon Musk returns to $44B Twitter deal: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 2-8

Features

Get your money back: The weird world of crypto litigation

Technical bit

According to Scroll’s Luozhu Zhang there are three potential types of zkEVMs: bytecode level, language level and consensus level. zkSync and StarkWare are at the language level and require a compiler or transpiler step, while Scroll and Polygon are bytecode level approaches. The human readable form of bytecode is called an opcode.

Bjelic says that Polygons solution is designed to be EVM equivalent whereas:

“Projects like StarkNet and zkSync are taking a different route they have their own custom virtual machines, and then they try to transpile Solidity, the most popular language built on top of EVM to the languages these virtual machines can interpret, he says.

There are two major challenges with this approach: (i) it is hard to build a transpiler that will support 100% of Solidity smart contracts and (ii) even if you have the transpiler you still can not leverage all the developer and end user tools like Polygon zkEVM can.”

Newcomb says there is bad information circulating. We do not transpile, we compile, he says. And he takes a shot back at Polygon saying that from looking at the projects Github that they are yet to develop a working general purpose prover integrated with a working sequencer.  

If this is the case then it means they have an undefinable amount of work to be done. The last 10% of any complex system is always the most difficult. This looks similar to where we were or even behind where we were when we launched testnet. And then after that it took us nine months.

Polygons Mihailo Bjelic says its solution is 100% EVM equivalent. (Twitter)

Mostly compatible

zkSync meanwhile is compatible with all but three of Ethereums 141 Opcodes one of which has been deprecated, another is being deprecated and the third one is used by  less than 1/10th of 1% of projects according to Newcomb.

So what did we get for not being fully equivalent? We got two things, our cost for performance is way better than any solution going after equivalence. We’re way faster, way cheaper. And the second thing we got is we were able to stick an LLVM compiler inside of our chain which you can’t do if you’re doing equivalent. And what an LLVM compiler does is we’re already looking at layer three.”

The LLVM would let a Python, Rust or C++ developer code on their solution, which then compiles down to work the same way with Solidity. 

“That is huge for adoption. So where this project that took seven months over here in Cairo that same ecosystem project ported to us in seven days. That’s compatibility.”

He concedes it would take just one day to port over if zkSync had total equivalence but would miss the LLVM and the increased scaling. So he says its a trade off worth making.

Layer 3 and recursive scaling

The coolest thing about being able to compress a large number of transactions into a single validity proof, is that the technology allows you to compress numerous other proofs into a single proof as well. 

Its called recursive scaling and Declan Fox, product manager for rollups at Consensys, believes its so powerful that in theory the entire global financial system could run on Ethereum. We have the technology to achieve that kind of throughput necessary, he says. With recursive rollups and proofs, we theoretically can infinitely scale.

Also read: Ethereum is eating the world: You only need one internet 

StarkWare turned on recursive scaling back in August and has processed more than 30 million transactions since using the tech.

Recursion has already, at this early stage, increased the number of transactions in a single proof by approximately 8x, explains Ben-Sasson. What is more, its proving so efficient, soon after it went into production there’s a reduction of around 40% to our own cloud cost for proof generation.

These arent predictions or numbers we hope to see, but rather numbers from whats in production today. And I stress: this is just the start, and changes well make will mean these numbers will get more and more impressive.

The Starkware ecosystem is growing. (ZK Daily Twitter)

Polygon is about to implement its Plonky2 solution according to Bjelic. It’s an open source zk-SNARK solution. “This recursive SNARK can be used to verify transactions orders of magnitudes faster than existing alternatives. Plonky2 is also natively compatible with the Ethereum Virtual Machine, which allowed Polygon to develop the zkEVM.”

And the testnet for ZK Sync’s Layer 3 will be released soon, in time to take advantage of an Ethereum upgrade called Proto-Danksharding early next year designed specifically to give rollups the space on Ethereum to blossom. Newcomb expects Layer 3 to be in production within a year. They’re calling it Pathfinder, an ecosystem of ‘fractal hyperchains.’

‘We could probably go on for hours engineering wise, but functionally the further up the recursive chain you get away from Etherium the cheaper the data costs get and it’s a 10x, 10x, 10x, 10x, as you recurse off up with data costs, and that’s unique to zk.”

That’s where we get to 100,000 TPS and a million TPS,” he says. Visa chugs along at around 4000 TPS on a normal day, spiking up to around 65,000 TPS at peak times like Chrismats.

“ZK is the only way to get to like 100,000 TPS so that you can get to the levels where something like Visa replaces its underlying protocol with a blockchain. And when you do that, that’s your mass adoption moment.”

Another astonishing development according to Newcomb is that Layer 3 can get rid of the requirement for interchain bridges, which is where all more than $2 billion of hacks have occurred this year alone.

“One of the other things that we’ve already achieved up in Layer 3, we get rid of all bridges. And when you can have one prover doing the circuit for all of the hyperchains up in L3, any communication from one blockchain to another now is native. That’s the other reason why Vitalik said this is the end game because there are no more bridges.”

‘If you make it faster, cheaper by orders of magnitude, if you make it easier to use and more welcoming to a broader audience of developers by having more languages available, and then you make people trust it because you get rid of bridges. That’s what I always say is a star cluster of 10x moments up in L3 and that’s where the game is going to be had.”

Not fixed yet 

So that’s it? With the arrival of ZK rollups and EVM compatible scaling solutions everything has been solved?

Unfortunately not. ZK rollups are currently very good at taking computation off of Ethereum, but they still need to write enough data back to the main chain so that if the rollup stopped working or it taken over by bad guys, then some other outfit could step into the breach and work out who owes what to who.

Its called the data availability problem and a considerable amount of Ethereum’s roadmap with proto danksharding and full danksharding aims to solve it and allow for more data to be included. There are a couple of ways around this at present including storing data on Validiums, which are cheaper but less secure. 

So the way we describe it is if you have a baseball card collection, and many of these cards don’t cost a lot and you’ve saved them in Valdium but then one rare card that is worth a lot of money you will probably save on Layer 1,” says Ben-Sasson.

Polygon is working on a number of solutions to this same problem including Avail “a blockchain where information is available to everyone at any time, was designed specifically for this purpose, Bjelic says. 

zkSync’s Pathfinder will enable devs to choose from three options for data availability, a Validium, zkPorter (mixing on chain and off chain) and ZKRollup (full security).

zkSync is already on the road. (Pexels)

Dont expect a big bang from zkSyncs mainnet launch on October 28. It will be kind of underwhelming at first, with a couple of months of just Matter Labs testing and offering users bounties to try to hack it or exploit it. Then DApps will be allowed to port over, and start building and testing security.

“And then when we feel like we got everything done, we do what’s called lift in the gate. And then all the users can come into the system simultaneously and it’s called a fair release program. So we don’t favor any project over another. He says that 150 projects will launch at that point and there will no longer be any reason a project would wait around for Polygons solution to be finished..

It’s like they’re going to a racetrack and they’re showing up with the chassis of a car that doesn’t have any wheels, no steering wheel and absolutely no engine, he says.

And we have the whole product done. You know we have the Ferrari and we’re ready to go.

Read also
Features

Attack of the zkEVMs! Cryptos 10x moment

Features

FTX partners with Visa, BNB Chain suffers exploit and Elon Musk returns to $44B Twitter deal: Hodlers Digest, Oct. 2-8

Features

Get your money back: The weird world of crypto litigation

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Get your money back: The weird world of crypto litigation

Want to sue a crypto project that ripped you off? That will be $1 million, thank you. Luckily, there are options for those who face the daunting prospect of spending a small yachts worth of money in lawyer fees for their chance at crypto justice.

In practice, the majority of victims of international blockchain scams find themselves with little hope of recovering their money. According to crypto law expert Jason Corbett, a normal court case to recover $10 million$20 million dollars in the blockchain sector can easily cost between $600,000 and $1 million, with an average timeline of 2.5 years.

But there are a range of cheaper and better options to get a successful outcome if you learn how to work with the system. Legal investment funds can finance your case for a share of the judgement sort of like a VC firm for lawsuits.

The vast majority of lawsuits up to 95% are privately settled before they go to court, Corbett says.

Common blockchain disputes

Corbett has six years of experience in crypto law as a managing partner of international blockchain-specialized boutique law firm Silk Legal. Speaking with Magazine about his new crypto litigation financing project Nemesis, Corbett notes a clear increase in disputes stemming from deals gone wrong, contractual breaches and bad actors over the past months due to the bear market, which has seen many projects go sideways.

There are a variety of common disputes involving blockchain, from misuse of funds to smart contract failures, which are listed below.

Misuse of investment proceeds happens when fundraising proceeds go to founders Lambos and villas instead of legitimate business needs, he explains. While the occasional boat party networking or team-building event might be justifiable, salary packages are the main permissible routes by which invested capital can flow to the founders even dividends can only be paid from profit, not incoming investments.

The sale of fraudulent crypto happens when a token is sold to investors based on false claims. A possible (though not tested in court) example is found with the automated market maker protocol SudoRare, which suddenly shut down and disappeared with investors money. Such cases can easily cross the threshold into criminal territory, according to Corbett. However, he admits that pursuing the culprits can be very difficult unless the scammers have been reliably identified.

Illegal securities offering. One way that investors in flopped tokens can attempt to claw back money is by claiming securities fraud, demonstrating that the offering was illegal in the first place, such as an unregistered securities offering masquerading as a utility token sale. There are currently several U.S.-based class action lawsuits running against U.S. projects, such as those against Bitconnect and Solana. Corbett explains that such claims fall under securities law, being civil claims as opposed to those brought by the likes of the SEC classifying projects like Ripple as securities.

Difficult organizations to sue. Another area that can present a legal minefield is DAOs, which are often not registered anywhere and dont have any kind of legal personality, and individuals are just working on their behalf. Corbett warns that such arrangements can easily expose unsuspecting DAO workers to vicarious liability since the entity they believe they are acting on behalf of may not actually exist.

Even smart contract disputes can lead to the courtroom. If two parties agree to act according to a certain trigger on a smart contract, but it somehow malfunctions, that can put a lot of liability on the coder or smart contract audit firm, Corbett says. In such cases, the insurance policies of audit firms become critical.

There are many areas of law by which blockchain companies can find themselves in trouble
There are many areas of law by which blockchain companies can find themselves in trouble. Source: Nemesis

When it comes to IP infringement, it is easy to imagine NFTs where copyrighted images are being minted and sold without permission. Even code, however, can be protected by copyright or patents, in which case implementing the code of other projects or even forking certain tokens may result in a serious claim. (This is obviously not the case with open-source software, which is why Uniswaps code has been forked so often.)

High costs

Irena Heaver, a Dubai-based lawyer specializing in blockchain, explains that while the aggrieved party is responsible for funding civil lawsuits, criminal cases are pursued by the state. As criminal cases deal with criminal matters rather than mere torts or mistakes, like a breach of contract and can result in prison instead of monetary judgements, the bar is set much higher in regard to evidence.

As an ideal, a criminal conviction can happen only when all reasonable doubt is removed, whereas a civil judgement can be made on a balance of probabilities, meaning that one party is at fault more likely than not. It is also the state, instead of the victim, that decides whether to pursue a criminal case something that happens infrequently when the alleged thieves are far overseas.

If the state isnt going to fund it and you cant afford to drop seven figures on the uncertain outcome of a court case, what can you do?

Alternative dispute resolution, involving either arbitration or mediation, is a cheaper option than formal courtroom proceedings. While arbitration is usually a binding process that can be viewed as court lite, mediation is a lower-cost private process in which a third party actively helps the parties come to a mutual understanding and agreement, Heaver explains. I always recommend mediation, she says, explaining that she has mediated dozens of crypto disputes where both parties have reached a satisfactory conclusion.

Sometimes conflicts can be amicably settled through cost-effective mediation
Sometimes conflicts can be amicably settled through cost-effective mediation. Source: Pexels

When a case does go to court, Heaver emphasizes that the judge needs to understand what is going on, which is far from self-explanatory when it comes to complex questions involving newfangled monkey-DeFi derivative crypto meta-chain utility tokens.

That means judges rely on expert testimony, and we all know about the fake experts in this space. These experts are selected and paid for by the parties themselves, and Heaver laments that for the right amount of money, you can find an expert whatever you want, naturally requiring the other party to pay for their own expert to refute the other.

When there are a large number of potential claimants, class-action lawsuits can pool them together into a single case. These are often undertaken by law firms as entrepreneurial undertakings, where the law firm does not charge claimants, who instead agree to give the firm a share of any settlement or winnings. 

An example can be found in a class action against billionaire Mark Cuban, who Moskowitz Law Firm argues used his fame to dupe millions of Americans into investing in many cases, their life savings into the deceptive Voyager platform and purchasing Voyager Earn Program Accounts, which are unregistered securities.

DeFinance

Another way to raise an army of lawyers without selling both kidneys is legal financing, also known as settlement funding or third-party litigation financing, which happens when a private investor gives a plaintiff money in return for a percentage of a legal settlement or judgement. This is effectively an outside investment toward a successful lawsuit, and the invested funds are generally directed toward funding the lawsuit in question.

Its about pairing someone with a risk appetite with a plaintiff who has a lawsuit but no funds, explains Bill Tilley, managing partner of legal venture fund LegalTech Investor, who has been working in the legal financing industry for 15 years. Funds like his look into an average of 20 cases for each one they take on, with the full due-diligence process costing up to $100,000 before a decision can be made to fund. This involves not only determining that a case is likely to succeed but that the defendant can actually be made to pay.

The big challenge in a crypto case is whether you can find and collect the money, even if you win the case resources need to be spent to trace the money. 

Determining the jurisdiction in which a case can be tried can also be a huge challenge in itself. In his own litigation funding research, Tilley has come across a perplexing trend of crypto-mystery. Weve looked at some crypto cases where just nailing down the jurisdiction is a nightmare theyll have multiple entities domiciled in multiple countries, he recalls. Crypto law is not an easy industry to crack.

Enter Nemesis

For the past several years, Corbett has been planning to create a blockchain-specialized litigation fund. There was no point launching this when everything was going up, he says, but now with the bear market bringing increasingly disappointed investors to law offices around the world, things are looking up for crypto law. His litigation fund, Nemesis, has now gone live.

The litigation funding industry is growing fast and becoming a financial solution for a handful of use cases. Part of its maturity is increasing competition on investments, which requires the funder to, in addition to providing capital, add value to the case. Therefore, there is a rise in domain focus funds, he says.

Like any investor, it is important to build a trustable relationship with the plaintiffs and make sure their expectations from the case are reasonable and their motivations are in the right place. It is also important to have legal teams, consultants and experts with a proven track record in the subject matter.

Jurisdiction plays a decisive role. We cant enforce judgements against people in certain countries, so we have to pass on matters like that, he says, adding that the United States and the United Kingdom, where enforcement of court orders is relatively straightforward, are the biggest markets for blockchain law. The British Virgin Islands are also interesting because a lot of blockchain projects have used those structures, he notes. The EU, U.S., U.K. and Australia have mature legal funding industries, he says, adding that not all jurisdictions allow for cases to be financed by third parties.

An overview of Nemesis' investment criteria
An overview of Nemesis investment criteria. Source: Nemesis

Similarly to Tilleys firm, Corbett says that his Nemesis team vets cases to select those which are most attractive from an investment perspective. We look to earn either multiples or a percentage of the investment, he says, explaining that much of the potential outcomes are determined by the defendants directors insurance plans, which often become the payers of last resort. If the opponent has no money, the action often goes by the wayside, Corbett concludes.

In addition to making oodles of money, Tilley explains that legal funders get the added benefit of helping some people that have been wronged that wouldnt otherwise have had access to the justice system today.

We can be part of fixing the problem of the bad actors by holding them accountable so crypto will be bigger, stronger and better 5 or 10 years from now.

Have an idea for a kickass story? Find me at eliasahonen@cointelegraph.com, or on Twitter

Read also
Columns

Wall Street disaster expert Bill Noble: Crypto spring is inevitable

Hodler's

Putin gives Snowden citizenship, Interpol elicits help in Do Kwon search and FTX US buys Voyager: Hodlers Digest, Sept. 25-Oct. 1

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Wall Street disaster expert Bill Noble: Crypto spring is inevitable

“It’s 10% up or 10% down each day. I don’t have to wait five years in between crises. As a matter of fact, I only have to wait about 45 minutes.”

In another reality, Bill Noble would be just another guy in a suit behind a big desk at the Fed or the SEC, probably murmuring negative incantations like crypto is bad.

Hes certainly got the track record for it: JP Morgan, UBS, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs. But thats Noble in an evil mirror dimension. In our world, he is a true crypto guy, talking to me in a t-shirt with bicycles in the back of the room. He turned from the Dark Side and joined the rebels.

He is known for his popular YouTube podcasts and TV appearances. Currently, he is a senior market analyst at Token Metrics.

Wall Street career

While studying economics (19871991) at Rutgers University in New Jersey, he managed to wangle one of only two sought-after internships at the time at JP Morgans forex desk on Wall Street. Noble started off when trading technology was primitive and lots of analysis was done by hand on paper. In August 1990, he was put in charge of the desk, while everyone went on holiday, Cos nothing happens in August, let the kid fill in. Then Iraq invaded Kuwait, and all sorts of craziness broke out in the markets.

Charting Made Easy
John J. Murphys Charting Made Easy.

The price volatility seemed so extreme to me. I had no idea how anyone kept track of this. So, I went to the technical analyst who was attached to the currency unit. I said, I bet everybody comes to you looking for help trying to figure this out.

He goes, Actually, no one does. So, he gave me John Murphys chart book [Charting Made Easy] and took me out for sushi. And I was off to the races from there using charts.

During his years of progression through the conventional Wall Street milieu, he became an expert technical analyst, which he combined with writing reports on different markets. During crashes and Black Swan events like the 1998 implosion of Long Term Capital Management, which nearly cratered the western financial world Noble was the go-to guy. Im like a firefighter: When everybodys running out of the burning building, Im running in, he jokes.

From stocks and bonds to crypto analysis

In 2017, he became intrigued by crypto. He went to an Austin, Texas Bitcoin conference and started doing charts for Ether by hand, which eventually became a gigantic scroll as the price went up and down. Then he met Bitcoin early adopter Charlie Schrem walking through an airport (who has had a crypto career with spectacular ups and downs, even doing jail time connected to the Silk Road marketplace implosion). They got together in crypto.IQ, a consultancy service aiming to improve cryptocurrency analysis with stocks, bonds, interest rates and other mainstream data, which no one else was doing at the time.

 

 

Bill on stage
Bill Noble on stage at DCentral Miami. Source: Twitter

 

 

In September 2019, Noble joined Token Metrics as a senior market analyst. Led by CEO Ian Balina, the subscription service provides retail traders with AI-driven insights, combined with the work of analysts researching the volatile cryptocurrency markets to assist in making beneficial trades, whatever the overall conditions.

He explains it puts an artificial intelligence system together with my charting. You effectively have a quantitative research product, an institutional quantitative research product that we can deliver to retail, which, you know, is not, is not really around. I mean, there are data and service providers, but, you know, we can provide you with tools you can use yourself. Plus, we have top analysts that look at everything from charts macro to NFTs.

 

 

 

 

Noble has 17,600 Twitter followers, a popular YouTube channel and is a sought-after guest analyst on crypto TV, with his Tony Soprano-esque, no-nonsense New Jersey accent.

He thrives on cryptos volatility, Its 10% up or 10% down each day, he says. I dont have to wait five years in between crises. As a matter of fact, I only have to wait about 45 minutes.

Noble stresses that you need to be very flexible in crypto technical analysis and not tied to one methodology. Surprisingly, he looks to the distant past for his basic systems, Gann works very well [William Gann, an influential early charting pioneer]. I find that the systems Wyckoff is another anything that worked in the early 20th century when stocks were the wild west, and there were 50 publicly traded car companies [work well]. I find Fibonacci is also helpful; Tom DeMarks work is excellent.

 

 

The current state of the market

Taking something of a contrarian position, he sees the current crypto winter as having a long-term benefit: clearing out the market and liquidating terrible projects.

The previous run-up was driven by a massive liquidity push by central banks. Then when central banks had to pull the liquidity, you had the 2008 crash of crypto. Speculative assets that never should have gone up, to begin with, went back to zero.

Noble forecasts that for the crypto economy, we can see the beginning of spring, a resumption of growth, after the crash, much like the many crises he weathered in the conventional financial markets, such as 2008 or 1987. He points out that various gurus like Warren Buffett wrote off the internet and Amazon after the 2002 crash. Buffett told CNBC in 2019 that hed been an idiot for not buying shares in Amazon in the past.

 

 

Wall Street disaster expert Bill Noble: Crypto spring is inevitable
Noble is attracted by cryptos volatility and ever-changing nature.

 

 

Bear markets are good times to do your homework because Mr. Market is now sorting out whos gonna win and whos gonna lose. He is bullish on Ethereum as a Web3 backbone. Web3 is the next internet, connected by Ethereum and Polkadot.

Noble is also bullish on privacy coins and approving quotes from United States National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden: One day, your wealth could be held against you. The central banks push toward centralized digital currencies, which will mean that all transactions will be watched by Big Brother, will create momentum for privacy coins like Zcash. Privacy coins are going to go from being for pirates to being for regular people.

 

 

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.



By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

Psychology of trading

Psychology plays a big part in trading. Noble explains that many of the best traders use physical exercise early in the morning to prepare themselves for the stresses of trading.

Its really about emotional management, he says. They also set up a research framework and stick to it. You have to have a method or a style, and you have to study to get there.

He explains that the legendary trader Bill Williams (who invented numerous indicators, including Awesome Oscillator, the Alligator Indicator and the Market Facilitation Index) made his students do three pages of stream of consciousness writing before he would let them trade, to empty their heads of emotional and intellectual blocks to trading. Noble encourages people to read Williams book, Trading Chaos.

 

 

Bill Noble and Julian Jackson
Bill Noble and Julian Jackson prove that not everyone in crypto is 23 years old.

 


Noble recommends that more emotional investors should adopt a long-term approach rather than the intense ups and downs of day trading. Hold a portfolio for a significant time and only make a few trades per month or year. With yield farming, you would still be getting a return on your investment.

And of course, if you can hold on, then Noble says that long term, the future is bright.

During a tightening cycle, crypto is going to get hurt, like anything else, but as the tightening cycle comes to a close, crypto is the future of money.

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

5 years of the ‘Top 10 Cryptos’ experiment and the lessons learned

“Index investing can be boring, but it saves you from the worst possible outcomes.”

When Redditor Joe Greene started the Top 10 Cryptos experiment in 2018, he bought $1,000 of Dash, NEM and Iota, among others, only to watch it crash to $150. But five years on, his experiment has paid off big time.

The rules: Buy $100 of each of the top 10 cryptocurrencies on Jan. 1, 2018, 2019, 2020 and 2021. Hold only. No selling. No trading. Report monthly.

Every January since 2018, Greene has reviewed a list of the top 10 cryptocurrencies by market cap from his tropical office in Bali. He puts $100 of his own money into each, tracks the performance every four months or so, and publishes the findings on his website and on Reddit.

When he began, crypto indexes were few and far between, so there wasnt an easy alternative. Having invested in stocks for years before moving into crypto, Greene predicted that chasing tokens on a hot streak was dangerous unless done consistently and this was indeed proven so by his experiment with the Top Ten Crypto Index Funds.

Bitcoin 2017

Like almost everyone else that year, Greene was mesmerized by the sudden rise of Bitcoin during the 2017 bull market. I remember looking to buy a rig to do some mining, but it turns out they were all sold out. So, I thought, Whatever, Ill just go out and buy some coins instead, he tells Magazine. A combination of the underlying technology, the financial elementsand the future direction of the asset class kept Greene in the sector. He has been blogging with the project ever since.

At the beginning, Greene was relatively new to crypto like his audience. He explains:

I came through Reddit and some online articles, and everyone was pretty much shilling sketchy returns, although there were a few diamonds in the rough.

Faced with uncertainty, Greene decided to stick with his normal investing philosophy of holding on to what he purchased and refraining from excessive trading. Outside of crypto, Im not a trader, and Im convinced that very few people are traders. Something like only 0.5% of traders are profitable over the long run, says Greene. So, yeah, I aint a trader. And I learned my lessons long ago. Greenes basic philosophy is that its safest to invest in low-cost, super diversified index funds which is Warren Buffetts advice for the majority of investors, too. But there simply wasnt anything like it at the time in late 2017. So, Greene decided to make his own.

 

 

Greene provides regular updates on his portfolio performance, and has been doing so for the past five years.
Greene provides regular updates on his portfolio performance and has been doing so for the past five years.

 

 

Winner takes all

The thinking was that, like stocks, cryptocurrencies have also exhibited signs of winners take all, where over a long period of time, the winners keep winning and the losers keep losing in terms of investment gains. After all, the best performing cryptocurrencies attract all the media attention, Google searches, institutional interest, retail euphoria, etc. So, Greene theorized that for individuals who didnt know much about the crypto space, their best bet was to just stick with the top players and be consistent about doing so.

And so, from 2018 onward, Greene compiled a list of the top 10 cryptocurrencies on CoinMarketCap at the beginning of each January and tracked their performance over time.

 

 

Greene says that the best lesson he has learned during this period is the power of dollar-cost averaging purchasing an asset on a regular basis without any regard for its market price. This smooths out the volatility in the purchase price and brings it closer to the average price over the period in which it was bought.

What goes up doesnt always stay up, but the risks can be mitigated with monthly rebalancing, he said. My initial portfolio in 2018 consisted of tokens such as Dash, NEM, Iota, etc. Even though there was a bull market from 2020 to late 2021, none of the tokens I spoke of managed to recover their all-time high prices witnessed five years ago. But there were rallies thereafter, and if you stuck with rebalancing, you would have done well.

 

 

Top Ten Cryptos bought in 2018 still havent recovered to their all-time highs
Top Ten Cryptos bought in 2018 still havent recovered to their all-time highs.

 

 

Crypto winter OG version

In fact, when Greene placed $1,000 in each of the top 10 cryptocurrencies in January 2018, his portfolio slid to be worth less than $150 just 12 months later.

However, patience is rewarded, and for someone who consistently invested $1,000 into the top 10 cryptocurrencies by market cap every January from 2018 onwards, the model portfolio would have returned a cumulative 87%. During the same period, the S&P 500 benchmark would have yielded 24%.

 

 

Greene's portfolio performance on a cumulative basis.
Greenes portfolio performance on a cumulative basis.

 

 

Greene points out that the strategy of sticking to the big winners if done consistently would have worked out in the long run. The 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022 Top 10 crypto portfolios he tracked have returned +126%, 338%, +177% and -69% (not surprisingly), respectively, to date, essentially offsetting any poor performance made during the bear years.

 

 

The same experiment, conducted in 2019, yielded good results
The same experiment, conducted in 2019, yielded good results.

 

 

Its not anything spectacular, like how Twitter shills claim you can get 10,000% in a week by putting your life savings into crypto, he says. For any kind of an index, youre never going to get the best return, but its going to protect you from the worst possible outcomes.

Greene elaborates that his method would have worked out better if the index was able to track the entire market, and not just the top crypto. Over the same period, an all-market crypto index would have yielded 224% growth, he stated.

Thats the beauty of index investing. I have a normal job and a family to take care of. Because of that, I cant spend 10 hours a day like on Twitter and Discord and trying to figure out which crypto is going to go up the most. I also suck at NFTs. So, we need an investing method for ordinary people whose lives arent devoted to crypto.

Greenes experiment and methods have attracted a lot of interest among the crypto-curious on social media. When asked about any interesting investment behavior or trading pattern he has observed among his followers over the years, Greene says that there are lots of people who view price movements with the benefit of hindsight: Its like saying, Hey, I bought Doge because it went up, you should have gotten it as well. I cant respond to that, and theyre right. But the trick is predicting that beforehand.

 

 

Top Ten Cryptos
Spoiler: The lesson was not to invest in anything in January 2018.

 

 

There have also been plenty of surprises: A lot of Bitcoin fans switched to Ethereum over the years, for starters. Then there was BNB Coin, nobody really expected that coin to become big, and I think not even Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao expected that.

On his blog, Greene also has a section dedicated to financial literacy, pointing out that retail investors should track their bills and have their finances in satisfactory condition and never risk more than they can afford to lose. His approach means he became acquainted with folks of a more conservative mindset.

 

 

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.



By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

Its folks that arent day trading crypto, he explains. And I tell them, Dont throw everything you have into crypto thats a bad idea.

A decade of Top 10

Greene plans to continue Top Ten Crypto Index Funds until it hits a decade or so. After all, I have a family and a full-time job commitment, which can get quite stressful at times.

 

 

Greenes experiment for 2022 has been on a downward spiral
Greenes experiment for 2022 has been on a downward spiral.

 

 

But Greene warns that even though the experiments cumulative performance has been good, its important to be on the alert for severe drawdowns: Take this year: Theres now four stablecoins on the top ten list. Its a bit boring, so I would have to move things around a bit, he says, adding, But I should probably stick to what I know best. I also tried this year to get a bonus on DeFi. It was 130 bucks starting with USD Coin, which I swapped for TerraUSD, just for fun, and then I sent it to anchor on LUNA, which crashed magnificently.

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Toss in your job and make $300K working for a DAO? Here’s how

“The collaboration-maxi nature was a welcome breath of fresh air.”

Increasing numbers of employees are quitting 95 corporate jobs to work for DAOs. While the moneys great, DAOs fall into a legal gray area, and it can be tricky to get your foot in the door.

Researchers Nataliya Ilyushina and Trent MacDonald from the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology Blockchain Innovation Hub take you through how to get started.

This year could see two emerging workforce dynamics come to a head. Twenty-one million Americans quit their jobs in 2021 heralding the Great Resignation era after an extended experience working remotely during COVID-19 lockdowns and dissatisfaction with conditions upon reentering their workplaces.

One in 5 workers reported an intent to quit their jobs in 2022. At the same time, the peak number of members of decentralized autonomous organizations at the start of August 2022 was 3.4 million, with over 140,000 new members joining in July 2022 alone.

Although the Little Migration to DAOs pales in comparison to the Great Resignation, we might still wonder if these two trends are connected in some small way.

For one, the demographics of both groups are strikingly similar: workers typically between 30 and 45 years old and with the tech industry most affected. Secondly, DAOs are digitally native organizations and a natural fit for many of the disaffected workers seeking new remote employment opportunities.

So, why are people migrating from working in traditional corporations to become digital nomads working in new settings such as DAOs? Could this be your next career move?

 

 

DeepDAO keeps stats on DAOs
DeepDAO keeps stats on DAOs. Source: DeepDAO

 

 

Decentralized alternative

DAOs are a new form of organizational structure offering an alternative to corporations. For workers, the critical difference is the horizontal structure, where there is little formal hierarchy and no bosses.

DAOs offer a revolutionary new type of employment: a hybrid of ownership, traditional employment, freelancing and volunteering. Every member is a boss and a worker (both paid and unpaid) and is free to contribute when and where they see fit. Each member is free to choose how much time they want to spend working, voting and participating in discussions. Moreover, one can be a member of multiple DAOs and choose how much time and effort they devote to each.

According to DeepDAO, numerous top DAO contributors are members of dozens of DAOs at once, with the most prolific contributor currently part of more than 80 DAOs. In other words, employment in a DAO is flexible, discretionary, overlapping and deregulated.

 

 

Work for a DAO
You can make good money working from home. Sure, it sounds like a scam, but its actually what a DAO entails.

 

 

DAO employment offers considerable worker flexibility in terms of their overall supply of labor, working hours and variety of tasks due to the digital, remote and asynchronous nature of DAO operations.

Today, it is possible to earn a living working for a DAO or across multiple DAOs, with some earning as much as $300,000 a year in 2021. A survey of 422 DAO members conducted by Gitcoin and Bankless showed that half of the respondents were able to earn a living from working in one or more DAOs.

 

 

The top five DAOs on DeepDAO
The top five DAOs on DeepDAO. Source: DeepDAO

 

 

A long road to be paid

However, the remuneration rarely comes as a traditional salary and is commonly paid in tokens. Furthermore, the moment one starts working for a DAO and the moment they get paid can be two entirely different points in time.

Here is how the evolution of working for a DAO typically looks. The moment one joins a DAO (usually by purchasing a token), they can start contributing by participating in a community forum (often on Discord) and voting (using Snapshot or something similar). At this point, however, there is a slim chance of getting paid. As ones reputation grows, the DAO community may reward them based on discussion and participation KPIs (usually via airdrops).

 

 

Once a member has familiarised themself with the DAO and proved their reputation, they might start contributing to the core DAO project. At this stage, this usually happens in the form of completing a bounty: a small, disconnected task. Bounties are paid and lead to further accumulation of reputation and DAO-specific skills.

 

 

 

 

The next step is to secure a part-time or full-time position within a DAO. While relatively rare and hard to get, these jobs are very well-paid. Longer-term or ongoing positions such as these are usually associated with the core operations of the DAO project: for example, a software developer role in a protocol DAO or a graphic designer role in an NFT art production DAO. If one does not want to have a fixed arrangement, they can continue contributing when convenient, and the peer review process will decide how to remunerate the value they add to the DAO.

Everyones story transitioning to work for a DAO is different for example, an anon dev called Squelch tells Cointelegraph he went through this entire typical lifecycle of DAO employment in merely a week.

Before joining DAOs, they built carbon market trading exchanges and natural disaster insurance, worked in investment banking, and helped to create an alternative interest rate benchmark to Libor called Ameribor and ran an insurtech company.

Theyve been interested in blockchain since first hearing about Bitcoin in 2009, but it wasnt until the DeFi summer in 2020 that they began to spend every waking moment learning about protocols and smart contracts.

 

 

Group photo of the anons at Tracer DAO
Group photo of the anons at Tracer DAO. Source: Tracer DAO

 



It was still a big leap to ditch their eclectic financial services job but took the plunge when they saw a job ad for Tracer DAO (now Mycelium) looking for someone to build a decentralized derivative. After chatting with the Tracer people, it turned out they idolized Richard Sandor, who was Squelchs mentor.

I jumped on a call with and told them about my experience, and they asked me to be a pro-bono type advisor to the project. Within a week, they asked me to join as a full-time paid contributor and, a week later, asked me to run a core team providing services to the DAO.

Despite earning big bucks in their prior role, money didnt come up in the Tracer DAO chat, and it rarely comes up as the main motivation for joining a DAO. Most say the appeal is in no longer working for a boss. The absence of a hierarchical structure promotes teamwork and the feeling of being part of a community. DAO contributors often mention the fairness and transparency of the organization. They operate like worker collectives operating via blockchain in which each member has a say about how to reward the work of others. The community makes all the decisions.

The collaboration-maxi nature was a welcome breath of fresh air, Squelch says.

It is interesting in that you are connecting and collaborating with people that are also passionate about similar ideas and ideals. However, the challenge is creating coordination mechanisms and incentives so that everyone is working together in tandem to help solve these goals.

They go on to add, Even with the struggle of working in a DAO structure, I see them as being incredible tools to bring people together full-time, part-time and every so often to help bring things together.

 

 

You can be a member of as many DAOs as you like
You can be a member of as many DAOs as you like. Source: DeepDAO

 

 

Irregular hours and no job security

The benefits of decentralization and deregulation also come with risks.

The flexibility of the work comes with a lack of job security and employment entitlements. Like rideshare drivers and other gig economy workers, who work when they want but often do not receive the same entitlements as standard full-time employees, DAO workers are not guaranteed sick, maternity and annual leave provisions.

 

 

Blockchain law expert Aaron Lane from the RMIT Blockchain Innovation Hub says that working for a DAO is in a regulatory gray zone at present. There are established legal tests in most jurisdictions about whether someone is treated as an employee or an independent contractor, he says, adding, Organizations structured as a DAO cannot limit its liability just by virtue of that structure.

DAOs are not immune from other issues, such as workplace discrimination and harassment, but their deregulated nature does not easily allow the prosecution of those practices. After all, which jurisdictional authority does a global DAO fall under?

 

 

 

 

The lack of job security and a legal framework might discourage women from joining if they are worried about the lack of provisions for careers or maternity leave as well as the overall perceived high-risk nature of the industry. There is no data on those issues yet, but it may be one factor in the lack of gender balance in the sector. A Bankless survey of DAO members found seven times more males than females.

But Lane remains optimistic: While critics may say that there is potential for workplace rights to be eroded under a Work-for-the-DAO model, workers have a lot of power, as blockchain and crypto skills are in high demand, and this new technology could actually allow new forms of collectivized employment terms to emerge.

 

 

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.



By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

While DAO employment still needs to be more clearly defined, there are significant benefits, and its only set to rise throughout 2022. The new employment relationship is attracting talent by offering flexibility, transparency and ownership along with the prospect of generous remuneration.

And the few risks posed by the deregulated nature of DAO employment do not seem to have hampered the growth in DAO membership yet. How all this plays out with respect to the Great Resignation is still unknown, but DAOs have been picking up at least some of the slack in terms of employees moving away from traditional corporations during the pandemic.

Read more: How to bake your own DAO at home with just 5 ingredients!

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Saving the planet could be blockchain’s killer app

“Putting Paris Agreement carbon markets on Ethereum and connecting the national carbon accounts of the world, is blockchain’s killer app.”

The sustainability movement has emerged as a 21st century megatrend, and it shows no signs of abating. Record heat in Europe, wildfires in the U.S. West, floods in Pakistan, drought in China, and accelerating ice cap melt in Greenland and Antarctica have driven home to many the looming threat of climate change.

Meanwhile, the New York Times declared in December “the sustainable industrial revolution is just getting started,” and even heavy industries like shipping, steel, and plastics are beginning to grasp the importance of an ecologically sustainable future developing products like “green steel,” which is a fossil-free steelmaking process.

But hurdles remain, including questions about transparency, accountability, traceability, trust, data integrity, and even greenwashing (making false or insincere environmental claims.) Or as the Times asked: “Can some of historys highest-polluting industries be trusted?” in spite of their professed good intentions.

This is where blockchain technology could make a difference. Like the sustainability movement itself, blockchain tech is global, 21st century, and mostly unformed though likely to be shaped soon by new laws and rules. Blockchains can simplify and lower costs of ESG (environmental, social and governance) reporting, build trust in “collected” data, develop new eco-related trading markets, and suggest new sources of innovation.

Blockchain can prove that green energy is really green2
Blockchain can prove that green energy is really green. (Source: Pexels)

In March, for instance, automaker Volkswagen announced that it was using blockchain technology to help ensure that electric vehicle (EV) charging stations were using sustainable sources to recharge their electric cars. This move is aimed at consumers who want validation that the energy being used to recharge their vehicles isn’t coming from brown coal-powered electric companies or the like. BMW is said to be developing something similar.

Elsewhere, energy giant Shell announced in June the launch of Avelia, a sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) solution for business travel. The project uses a public blockchain to promote and validate SAF, which can reduce lifecycle emissions by up to 80% compared to conventional jet fuel.

Many now foresee a blossoming partnership between environmentalists and blockchain developers, especially as Ethereum with its big Merge, as well as other networks, move closer to carbon zero and even carbon negative platforms.

I continue to believe that putting Paris Agreement carbon markets on Ethereum and connecting the national carbon accounts of the world, is blockchains killer app, Joseph Pallant, climate innovation director at Ecotrust Canada and founder and executive director of the Blockchain for Climate Foundation, tells Magazine.

But if this promise of a blockchain/ESG alliance is to reach fruition, some questions need to be resolved, including:

  • Are public permissionless blockchains sufficiently scalable to handle the sheer amount of data to be tracked for sustainability use cases?
  • Looking off-chain, do blockchain-based sustainability-related projects face an oracle problem? Who is going to attest, for example, that carbon offset credits entered on the blockchain are legitimate and that they are really doing something beneficial for the environment?
  • Finally, blockchain technology might be a useful tool in the quest to develop a global sustainable future, but is it a necessary one? Does the sustainability movement really need public blockchains to succeed?

 

 

 

 

Tokenizing for more efficient markets

Many think that blockchain tech can make ESG-related markets more efficient, including the rapidly growing Voluntary Carbon Market, or VCM, where parties voluntarily buy and sell carbon credits that represent certified carbon removals or reductions of greenhouse gasses (GHGs).

Corporations can purchase carbon credits to meet their carbon neutrality commitments. A significant proportion of carbon credits issued this year have been minted on-chain, Charlie Moore, head of Carbon and ESG Solutions at Chainlink Labs, tells Magazine, adding:

The carbon credit market has historically been manual, slow, opaque, and inefficient. By moving carbon credit markets on-chain, the market inherently becomes automated, fast, transparent, and highly efficient.

Globally, carbon dioxide (CO2) permits grew to $851 billion in 2021, a gain of 164% compared with the previous year, according to Refinitiv, with most trading taking place within the European Union.

But multiple challenges remain in scaling Web3 carbon markets, adds Moore, including the lack of market standards. In addition, there are hundreds of layer-1 blockchains with little interoperability between them.

The blockchain trilemma looms, too. In building networks, its commonly believed that developers must choose among three key benefits decentralization, scalability and security. They can have two but not three. So a project can have decentralization and security, but not scalability. Or scalability and security, but not decentralization, etc.

 

 

John Bulich, Technical Director and co-founder of Powerledger, along with Dr Jemma Green, Executive Chairman and co-founder
John Bulich, Technical Director and co-founder of Powerledger, along with Dr Jemma Green, Executive Chairman and co-founder.

 

 

Powerledger, for example, is an Australian company that uses blockchain technology to enable neighbors in Indias Uttar Pradesh state to trade solar energy on a P2P basis. Its secure network is able to process an impressive 50,000-plus transactions per second, the projects founder and CEO Jemma Green tells Magazine. But Powerledger uses a permissioned network not a public, decentralized one.

By comparison, Nori, an innovative carbon removal marketplace, has expanded using secure, decentralized platforms like Ethereum and more recently Polygon through creating and selling NRT tokens, each one representing one tonne of removed CO2 stored. The idea is that farmers are paid for adopting regenerative agricultural techniques while other stakeholders, including consumers, can purchase tokens to reduce their carbon footprint.

Scaling up is still a challenge, however. We can scale up the amount of supply/inventory that we have by further partnering with agriculture companies who can source large numbers of farmers for us, Nori CEO Paul Gambill says, though we’re sold out at the moment [in mid August] because the demand for carbon removal has outpaced the new supply enrollment. Projects like these may take time to reach a global scale.

Beyond carbon removal

Carbon removal isnt the only sustainability use case, of course. Indeed, a system like Noris which uses two assetsan NRT as a reference token, and NORI as medium of exchange token — could arguably be used in other ecological contexts, like ocean plastic recycling in the developing world.

 

 

Can blockchain help alleviate the effects of drought
Can blockchain help alleviate the effects of drought? (Source: Pexels)

 

 

Yes, I would love to see this two-asset model adopted in other social impact areas, Gambill says. Another intractable problem is wildfires that grow to such huge sizes because of low brush and debris on the ground that acts as kindling. It should be possible to incentivize removal of that in a similar manner. Ocean plastic is also applicable.

Blockchain technology can also help to alleviate a water shortage in parts of the U.S., where water is being diverted away from lakes, reservoirs, and rivers at unsustainable rates, says January Walker, a U.S. Congressional candidate in Utah. Often there is no accountability as to where it goes, she tells Magazine:

Blockchain distributed ledger technology can be combined with IoT water parameter monitoring to track where the water is going, who is using the most, and provide a means of collaboration across state lines to drastically reduce water usage.

The sustainability movement needs to harness the power of frontier technologies like blockchain to help reach its goals in a faster and more efficient way, Amna Usman Chaudhry, a founding member of the Oxford Blockchain Foundation tells Magazine. Blockchain offers various advantages such as increased transparency, security, immutability, and decentralization which can be utilized to find new innovative solutions to age old problems, including plastic pollution, particularly in oceans.

Similarly Blockchain offers immense potential for sustainability for smart cities, such as is the case with Dubai, which through its implementation of the Dubai Blockchain Strategy aims to save USD $3 billion in operational costs, 398 million printed documents per annum and 77 million work hours annually, Chaudhry adds.

 

 

The Dubai Blockchain Strategy aims to save $3 billion in operational costs
The Dubai Blockchain Strategy aims to save $3 billion in operational costs. (Source: Pexels)

 

 

Volkswagens EV pilot: Pick your energy source

Then theres Volkswagens smart-charging electric vehicle (EV) pilot project which enables car owners to specify their favored source of energy. Drivers pulling into charging stations can select to charge using wind and solar resources, from energy assets within a 10 km radius […] with an accurate breakdown of their sessions carbon footprint, says project partner Jesse Morris, CEO at Energy Web, a firm that claims to have built first enterprise-grade, public blockchain tailored to the energy sector.

An algorithm determines the optimal charging schedule to maximize usage of clean, locally sourced electricity, while a smart-contract deployed on Energy Webs network issues to the EV owner after charging an ERC1888 NFT, a fractionalized renewable energy certificate that proves the provenance and volume of clean electricity generated and consumed. VWs innovation group is now working out how to roll this out at production scale.

A huge catalyst for renewal energy

Solutions like these can help solve the sustainability movements greenwashing problem. Some are skeptical that EVs are really carbon neutral given that they require recharging from electric sources that as far as they know could be generated by brown coal, Anthony Day, global head of ecosystem stewardship at Parity Technologies, commented in a recent LinkedIn post.

This is consistent with Web3 project designs that, generally speaking, seek to make owners out of users and users out of owners. The EV is generating information all the time for the grid — temperature, traffic conditions, and so on, Day tells Magazine. Your vehicle becomes an oracle. It could be identifying potholes on the road.

 

 

 

 

Solutions like VW’s will also be of interest to businesses that own fleets of cars and need to document the carbon footprint of their vehicles, especially in Europe. If you can show that your vehicles are topped up on fully renewable energy, thats a major contribution toward reducing a businesss carbon footprint, Day adds.

A boost from U.S. legislation?

The U.S. Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), signed into law in August, has earmarked $370 billion for the fight against climate change. Could the legislation indirectly spur blockchain adoption? Blockchain technology will provide an immense boost to the impact of climate-related investments embedded in the Inflation Reduction Act, Pallant tells Magazine. On-chain carbon pricing tools can help ensure that the most capital efficient climate solutions are selected in future projects, as well as providing the needed transparency for verifying the ultimate impacts of this third of a trillion dollar spend.

Not all agree, however, that the U.S. legislation will do much for blockchain adoption. Having read through the IRA, I believe that it is unlikely to boost the utilization of blockchain as it does not make specific suggestions to lean into the technology, says Walker.

To make a difference, blockchain would need a champion on every project being funded. The only portion of the bill that I think would even help is the $4 billion for a water project. That however will go mostly to research and replacing a few 90-year-old pipes across the nation instead of innovating water technology and tracking, adds Walker.

 

 

Theres only one planet so there are no alternatives
Theres only one planet so there are no alternatives. (Source: Pexels)

 

 

Is it really helping the planet?

It needs to be remembered, too, that blockchain technology has inherent limitations, and by itself blockchain wont save the world, according to Day, who has a podcast by that title. Before ESG-related projects can be tokenized, someone or group needs to verify that the projects exist, they are useful for the environment and that they wouldnt have happened without tokenized funds they must have ‘additionality,’ in other words. The human factor cant be finessed. The sad fact of life is that the more manual you make that verification, the less scalable the system is, says Day.

Verification in carbon markets is typically done by third parties based on standards developed by offset registries like Verra and Gold Standard. Recent efforts to meld blockchain with the registry process hasnt gone smoothly. Earlier this year, for instance, crypto firms Toucan Protocol and KlimaDAO were criticized for promoting cheap, low-quality carbon credits that dont actually help the environment, according to Bloomberg.

Indeed, a recent analysis by non-profit research organization CarbonPlan found that over 99.9% of Toucans BCT reference token came from CORSIA-ineligible credits, i.e., the low-quality end of the carbon market, Danny Cullenward, policy director at CarbonPlan, tells Magazine, including zombie projects like Dayingjiang-3, a Chinese hydropower dam project that has been operating since 2006. Credits from existing dams dont do much to help the environment, many people argue.

 

 

 

 

Even if the registries are the most culpable actors, Cullenward continues, Toucan, Klima, and other tokenization efforts point to registry standards as proof of quality. Anyone who is professionally engaged in these areas either knows or should know about the underlying quality control problems that remain, so I don’t have any patience for what effectively amounts to passing the buck.

In response to the Bloomberg story that raised similar concerns, KlimaDAO published in April a letter-to-the-editor response, which acknowledged the problem on the supply side regarding the quality and integrity of carbon credits in the Voluntary Carbon Market (VCM), but it also noted that the article fails to consider the widely accepted need to scale up the VCM to meet the emissions reduction targets prescribed by the Paris Climate Accord.

To avoid the worst effects of climate change, according to the Taskforce on Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets, the volume of the VCM will need to grow by up to 15 times by 2030, wrote Natacha Rousseau.

Other veterans of carbon markets like Pallant stand by Toucan and KlimaDAO, even after their BCT and KLIMA tokens plunged in price this year KlimaDAOs by 99% and Verra announced that it was prohibiting the practice of creating tokens based on retired carbon credits.

Klimas price collapse mirrored […] the crash in crypto prices generally, Pallant tells Magazine. I think the actual story is how crazy it was that KlimaDAOs price got so high, rather than that it has gone low. I dont think anyone at KLIMA expected the price to go to $3,000 plus. Shortly after its October 2021 launch, Klima soared over $3,600. It was trading at $3.84 in early September, according to CoinGecko.

 

 

Klima DAO soared and then crashed
Klima DAO soared and then crashed. (Source: Pexels)

 

 

Toucan, for its part, acknowledges that many of the criticisms around the tokenization of dormant credits were valid, John Hoopes IV, strategy and ecosystem at Toucan Protocol, tells Magazine, while Toucan is developing technologies to improve the quality and integrity of the VCM, including a system to store the digital monitoring, reporting and verification [dMRV] data that will underpin many credit types. As for the problem of dormant credits:

We also introduced a rule to prevent carbon credits issued more than 10 years after emission reductions have taken place from using our technology and be converted into a carbon-backed token.

Day isnt giving up on tokenizing carbon credits, either. I think it has a significant potential to be one of the largest blockchain use cases. Global climate initiatives often struggle because of local regulation. What is accepted in Argentina may be different from what is accepted in France, says Day. With a standardized token anybody can participate in that system purchase, trade, invest. You can get liquidity into that system. Thats very powerful if those token standards are recognized.

As with many new technologies, a certain amount of patience may be required. Both crypto and carbon are pretty complex and difficult and when you put them together, its like difficulty squared, Ollie Gough, strategy lead for the carbon-rating startup Sylvera, tells Time. Mistakes have been madeand were waiting to see how it pans out.

Is blockchain tech a must have?

Is blockchain technology really essential for the sustainability movement, though? We see blockchain as something akin to using barcodes in supermarkets, Powerledgers Green says. Barcodes and scanners are now integral to a supermarket. […] they facilitate supermarkets operating at high volumes and low margins.

Could supermarkets have taken off without barcode technology? continues Green. The answer is probably, but at a much slower pace, because the high volume, low margin [success] is hard to achieve with just a manual input of prices into a till.

 

 

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.



By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

New areas may emerge. ESG investing is yet to embrace smart contracts at any real scale, says Chainlinks Moore. There is enormous potential for smart contracts and blockchains to transform areas such as green bonds through tamper-proof automation.

With the European Council and European Parliaments recently agreed-upon rules for corporate sustainability reporting, nearly 50,000 EU companies in coming years will have to report ESG data, up from a mere 11,600 firms at present, according to EY. Blockchain technology could potentially make those filings more accessible, transparent, and credible for citizens, consumers and investors, many believe.

I’m generally very bullish on future blockchain use cases, especially in the sustainability space, Noris Gambill tells Magazine, while Pallant adds that Weve seen an absolute flood of new minds, talent and capital flow into the ReFi [regenerative finance] space over the last year. Well thought out, successful projects in that space will deliver profound value to climate, nature, forests, and seas by leveraging blockchain to deliver credible environmental assets.

 

 

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Guide to real-life crypto OGs you’d meet at a party (Part 2)

"I think OGs are hard core believers who went all-in when nobody else was paying attention to the space."

In Part 1, we detailed three of the different kinds of crypto OGs you might meet at an industry party.

They were: (1) shadowy super coders and/or anon founders, (2) reputable and respected OG industry leaders like Vitalik Buterin and Brian Armstrong, and (3) the comeback OGs, who were trying to shake off the stink of a failed project.

This time around, we meet even more categories of crypto OGs, with insight from the insiders most familiar with them.

 

 

Guide to real-life crypto OGs you’d meet at a party (Part 2)
Here’s your guide to the Crypto OGs you’d meet … if you could wangle an invite to one of these parties.

 

 

4. The NeoGs market makers and traders

There are a select few crypto players who joined the game late, yet they rose to prominence to become behemoths in terms of net worth and impact. Usually, these are savvy market makers and traders who are often mistaken for OGs.

Take, for example, Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of FTX trading exchange and quant trading firm Alameda Research. Amid the recent crypto collapses, he gained even greater prominence as he stepped in big to provide bailouts and minimize the contagions.

Sam Bankman Fried in a Youtube interview
Sam Bankman Fried in a Youtube interview
(Source: The Jax Jones and Martin Warner Show.)

Noobs may mistake SBF as an OG, but he only joined the industry in 2017. Bankman-Fried made his wealth from arbitrage crypto trading, which he leveraged to build his empire.

The 30-year-old is a self-made billionaire who is a regular in legacy financial media, invited to speak at all the top crypto conferences, and one of the default industry representatives weighing in on U.S. congressional hearings. His wardrobe seems to consist exclusively of FTX T-shirts.

SBF has famously stated that he does not necessarily believe in the future of any cryptocurrency, yet he sees them as attractive opportunities. Bottomline, he is the type who is in it for the money (but only for the purposes of altruistic donation at some later stage).

I dont think you can call those who joined in 2017 an OG, says Darius Sit, founder of successful Singapore-based crypto trading firm QCP Capital, which he also founded that year.

Thats my definition anyway. I think OGs are hard core believers who went all-in when nobody else was paying attention to the space, so thats certainly way before 2017.

Like SBF, Sit was also in crypto primarily to make money, and since its founding, QCP Capital has become one of the worlds larger crypto option trading firms with $1.5 billion in assets deployed back in 2021. Its

Darius Sit
Darius Sit
(Source: QCP Capital)

venture arm was an early investor in many prominent projects, such as Deribit, dYdX, Algorand, Tokocrypto and Nansen.

Judging from their successes, and the fact that the top three highest net worth in the cryptocurrency industry currently come from market-making businesses, one may wonder whether the winners in the industry are the savvier opportunists, instead of the holding believers.

Sit insists that market making is also a concrete use case and innovation of blockchain, instead of merely a money-making endeavor.

I think Sam and I shared and probably still share very similar views, and maybe I can provide some nuance here. Many crypto or blockchain initiatives promise incredible things that may or may not happen. But what is very real to me and what I believe in is the crypto capital markets.

To some extent, this is nothing new, he continues. It is the same market structures and practices with a different underlying: crypto assets. At the same time, it is also completely different.

Crypto is not attached to any particular country or authority; it is a non-aligned asset class that is accessible to anyone from any jurisdiction. It is the only scalable financial ecosystem that is independent.”

He adds: “In a world where geopolitics has become increasingly unstable, I think that counts for something. I enjoy being part of this developing market.

In the wake of this years macro sell-off and the liquidation of many Singapore-based whale trading firms and exchanges like Three Arrows Capital that sent shocks across the cryptocurrency market globally, QCP Capital has held its ground.

 

 

 

 

We were always wary of the leverage and rehypothecation in the borrowing and lending markets, and so, we never participated in a big way. I did feel quite stupid at times, especially when folks around us were making billions from the balance sheet expansion and easy leverage. In the end, the choice to just focus on trading and developing the derivatives markets might not have been the most profitable, but it was the right one, Sit comments.

At any networking party, you can find Sit having a quiet conversation outside with a couple of other people. I dont like crowds and prefer deep, quality conversations, he says.

 

 

Herbert Sim
Herbert Sim
(Source: Herbertsim.com)

 

 

5. The flashy influencers and YOLO bros

Last but not least, influencers are the OGs most likely to throw a networking party in the first place, in order to convert normies into crypto investors.

Even the letters OG conjure up images of swaggering, bling-bling-studded social media shiller types, wearing loud Bitcoin paraphernalia (cue The Bitcoin Man), driving lambos and popping champagne in the clubs, or otherwise chilling on a yacht somewhere in the Bahamas.

Often derided, theyve played a critical role in painting a dream of what is possible when one jumps onto the bandwagon of a deflationary asset class. Theyve all made life-changing amounts of money early from cryptocurrency due to astute intuition or dumb luck, and they want the whole world to know about it.

Whether buying flashy Lambos or super yachts or setting up a commune on a tropical island, these people are passionate about enjoying life to the fullest. They tend to be attractive and inspirational with larger-than-life personalities, making them suitable as event promoters, marketers, content creators and social media influencers. For better or worse, they are the face of the crypto industry in the mainstream.

 

 

I think people like me, like Kyle Chasse, are doing the hard work daily of preaching the gospel of Bitcoin to the masses, explains The Bitcoin Man aka Herbert Sim, a social media influencer with hundreds of thousands of followers on Instagram and Twitter.

An easily recognizable regular at conferences, Sim wears a Bitcoin necklace everywhere he goes and regularly posts on his social media about the virtue of investing in cryptocurrency.

I am very public about my identity because I have never done anything shady in the past. Plus, I am only shilling Bitcoin, and I 100% believe that it is safe and advisable for everyone to invest in Bitcoin.

Back in the days, I remembered a bunch of us would be partying hard at a club, and we would flaunt to everyone that we got rich from Bitcoin. We would hire girls with big boobs wearing tiny T-shirts with Bitcoin logos to drink among us in the club, Sim recalls fondly.

 

 

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.



By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

Sim got into cryptocurrency during his college years at Oklahoma City University in the United States. He was helping out a professor researching blockchain and got deep into the cypherpunk movement. This was as early as 2009 and 2010. In 2010, someone I cant disclose gave me some funding around 100 grand to host CryptoChainUniversity, one the worlds oldest academic repositories for research and education of crypto and blockchain.

The definition of OG is rather fluid, but I would say that the latest deadline for OGs to enter cryptocurrency should be around 2014, said Sim.

He has since worked in many different capacities in the industry, for example as the global operations director of Huobi Exchange and as the chief marketing officer of Cryptology. He also founded a U.K.-based venture capital fund trademarked The Bitcoin Man. In his free time, he likes to draw illustrations and write fantasy short stories inspired by the crypto industry.

Horsfall at a party
Horsfall at a party.
(Source: Zebu Digital)

People like us, we are the life of the party; we are not jaded at all with the industry, chips in Harry Horsfall, CEO of Zebu Digital a Web3 launchpad accelerator and marketing agency based in London, United Kingdom.

Horsfall bought his first Bitcoin in 2011 and went all in around 2013. I am not a whale, and I am certainly not Lambo rich. I have lost my crypto throughout history, but the most important thing is to get back on it and to keep believing in the future! gushes Horsfall enthusiastically.

Before crypto, Horsfall used to run music festivals, and now he organizes a lot of Web3 parties, for example, Zebu Life, Defi Life, Avalanche Summit, Ethereum Collective, Hijack Collective and so on.

The thing about crypto parties is they are not that great because they are predominantly male. So, we used to hire girls all the time. Now things are changing, and we are happy to see more and more girls coming into the ratio of 50:50.

6. OG is a spectrum

This guide is a rough sketch of the different types of OGs based on their roles and characteristics in the industry. But many OGs may straddle a few different categories, and others defy easy categorization.

What if you invested $1 in Bitcoin back in 2010? Would you count as an OG?

Victoria feeding a Bitcoin ATM machine with a fifty-dollar note back in 2014
Victoria feeding a Bitcoin ATM machine with a $50 note back in 2014.
Source: Victoria Au

No, an OG would be a person who originated the technology or utilized the technology in creating new business opportunities that addressed key pain points previously ignored or unbeknownst. I wouldnt consider myself an OG, but an early casual believer-adopter, as I invested $50 SGD into Bitcoin back in 2014. To this date, this has become my best performing investment, says Victoria Au, now a business director at fractionalized real estate investing platform RealVantage.

Zing Yang, who first bought crypto in 2014 and became one of the board directors of Litecoin, has an identity crisis around this label.

I think I am an OG from timeline and participation, though, by my definition, I feel like an imposter, as I am not techy enough or part of the developer community who got in early since the 2009 days because of ideological reasons or enamorment with the tech, she says.

Yang has now switched careers completely to join a global food production conglomerate Cargill, where she feels like she can make a more concrete contribution with her talent and skills.

Marcus Eng, the kid OG, now 25 years old
Marcus Eng, the kid OG, now 25 years old
Source: Writers phone

Being an OG is not all kittens and rainbows, says Marcus Eng, a rare former child OG, who got into cryptocurrency 11 years ago when he was just 14. I stumbled into crypto in a Bitcoin talk forum. And I have had my fair share of adventures since then. I was also an early Dogecoin OG.

Now 25 years old and working as an investment lead for QCP Capital, Eng thinks that he has finally started making concrete contributions to the industry.

When I was 14, I was so young. I was just fooling around. I was a rebel, and I got in for crypto idealism. I also could not manage my fortunes well and lost a lot of it throughout the years. Now I am much more discerning and critical towards the industry and able to help others navigate this space.

Being rich overnight so early also brought him some mental health issues. For a while, I was depressed because I lost motivation to do anything else in life besides for my own amusement, he says.

In conclusion, OG should simply mean anyone who has believed in the vision of blockchain since its early days, made contributions to the industry, and adopted and invested significantly in cryptocurrencies since 2014 latest.

Bear in mind though, theres always someone who is going to be more OG than you in so many different ways. It is not binary it is a spectrum, adds Yang.

 

Check out Part 1 of our Guide to Real Life Crypto OG’s below.

 

Insiders guide to real-life crypto OGs: Part 1

 

 

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal

Ethereum is eating the world — ‘You only need one internet’

“Is there a need for more than one internet? And we know the answer is ‘Hell no.’”

Theres a version of the future thats tantalizingly possible in which Ethereum becomes the base layer for pretty much everything.

Recent advances in a technology called zero-knowledge Rollups from StarkWare, Polygon and zkSync enable the blockchain to move from fewer than 20 transactions per second to well, an infinite number of TPS.

In theory, it would allow the entire worlds financial system to run on Ethereum.

I think its theoretically possible, explains Declan Fox, product manager for rollups at Consensys, which provides Ethereum infrastructure and apps like MetaMask. We have the technology to achieve that kind of throughput necessary.

With recursive rollups and proofs, we theoretically can infinitely scale.

He adds it obviously hasnt been proven in production yet, so thatd be the next step.

The tech is so new and so promising that soon after it became viable, Ethereum rearranged its entire roadmap to take advantage of it. This weeks Merge is arguably the least interesting bit of the coming changes.

 

 

Ethereum is eating the world - You only need one internet
Ethereum is eating the world metaphorically that is.

 


One of the pioneers of zero-knowledge proofs or validity proofs as he prefers to call them is StarkWare co-founder Eli Ben-Sasson. He worked on the problem for two decades, helping nurture it from an abstract theoretical concept something that is completely galactic and impossible, not enough atoms in the solar system to record even one such proof down to something that can efficiently be generated on a laptop.

At its most basic, the process employs high-level mathematics to generate a tiny validity proof that verifies that a whole bunch of other transactions has been carried out correctly. Instead of putting all the transactions on the slow and creaky blockchain, you just record one proof in a transaction.

This technology lets you send a very succinct proof that asserts that a computation was done correctly even when you werent watching, which I think is the most magical aspect, he explains.

What validity proofs deliver, they deliver integrity; they let me know that the right thing was done by others that someone processed 10,000 transactions, even when I wasnt watching, and they didnt steal my money. Thats what they deliver.

Tens of thousands of transactions being compressed into a single transaction on Ethereum is impressive enough, but the magic doesnt stop there.

Validity proofs work a little bit like fractals the closer you look, the further into the distance they stretch. You can take 10 validity proofs each representing 10,000 transactions and generate an entirely new validity proof verifying that those other 10 proofs are correct.

Suddenly you have 100,000 transactions rolled up into one. This is called a recursive proof, and you can just keep doing it over and over again.

It is a proof of proving. And so, you can further compound the savings because each time you generate a proof, youve compressed the process of verifying computation. So, basically, you can compress again and again.

 

 

StarWare co-founder Eli Ben-Sasson and Cointelegraph Magazines Andrew Fenton
StarkWare co-founder Eli Ben-Sasson and Magazines Andrew Fenton.

 

 

Our interview is held the same week that StarkWare puts recursive proofs into production. The zkSync project, which uses the slightly different zkSNARKS instead of zkSTARKS starks, has implemented its own version of recursive proofs.

StarkWare has already rolled up as many as 600,000 NFT mints into a single transaction on ImmutableX, and Ben-Sasson says theyll be able to cram 6 million NFTs into a single transaction soon and then 60 million with more engineering and tweaking.

While there are still some problems to overcome, this type of scaling capability puts crypto back in the game for everyday payments and microtransactions such as paying a few cents to read a paywalled article rather than being forced to take out a monthly subscription. Long hampered by high fees and 10-minute wait times for payments to go through, crypto finally has the opportunity to fulfill Satoshi Nakamotos original vision of becoming peer-to-peer cash.

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin told attendees at last months Korea Blockchain Week that scaling meant payments were back on the table:

Its a vision that has been, I think, forgotten a little bit, and I think one of the reasons why it has been forgotten is basically because it got priced out of the market.

Do you even need another blockchain, bro?

Infinite scaling on Ethereum means some people mostly Ethereum people, to be fair can no longer see the justification for competing layer-1 blockchains like Solana or Cardano. Delphi Digital calls this the Monolithic view of cryptos future as opposed to a multichain view.

It doesnt necessarily mean there wont be any competitors, just that its likely that there will be far fewer of them as the space coalesces around a single general-purpose execution environment. (For the record, Delphi Digital Labs is throwing its research efforts into the Cosmos ecosystem, not Ethereum.)

 

 

 

 

Chatting downstairs at ETH Seoul, I ask Ben-Sasson if he can see any need for any blockchain other than Ethereum in the future.

His bespectacled face breaks into a grin.

I can argue both sides because one side says: Is there a need for more than one internet? And we know the answer is Hell no. It would be a completely stupid idea to have two internets.

One side of me says that that is the case. The other one says that maybe because this has all kinds of macroeconomic considerations, maybe its a little bit more like fiat currencies, where in that aspect, you probably want more experimentation.

 

 

Sergej Kunz, co-founder of 1Inch
Sergej Kunz, co-founder of 1inch.

 

 

Sergej Kunz, co-founder of DeFi aggregator 1inch Network is less circumspect. He sees Ethereum dominating the entire space, with layer-2 and layer-3 recursive-proof solutions running on top of it and benefiting from its decentralization and security.

I dont think any layer 1 apart from Ethereum will get a huge share on the market, he says.

Yeah, I see layer-2 solutions on top of Ethereum (because) Ethereum is kind of a safe haven and super decentralized after proof-of-stake. He adds:

I love also that the Ethereum guys tried to keep it as simple as possible, the main chain. Other layer 2s above it can be very complex, providing proofs to the safe chain that everythings fine.

Kunz says 1inch is eagerly awaiting the launch of zkSyncs mainnet by the end of the year and is even toying with running its own layer 3 for 1inch Pro.

What I heard is possible; the plan in the future is that it would be possible to have a layer 3 above the layer 2, he says.

Were thinking about spinning up our own network for 1inch to manage because of our centralized entity in Switzerland kind of only allow specific addresses to interact in this compliant DeFi environment. And it makes sense to spin up our own network and all those who can pass KYC/AML can participate in this network.

And we can use zkSync technology for layer 2 In our layer 3, we would have also… our throughput would be affected by the throughput of layer 2.

Polygon also has a variety of zk-Rollup solutions in development but was, unfortunately, unable to put forward an interviewee in time for this piece.

 

 

 

 

The original P2P cash: Bitcoin

Obviously, Bitcoiners will be getting extremely annoyed reading about Ethereum eating the world with zk-Rollups, but heres the thing: Bitcoin could also scale massively using zk-Rollups, and StarkWare and various others have been researching that possibility.

Although it lags behind in smart contract capability, Bitcoin may be able to underpin the worlds financial system if it fully embraces rollups, too.

But there is a major problem: Ben-Sasson says itd require a fork to allow a Stark verifier. The block size wars of 2017 and the jealous guarding of the original code and principles by Bitcoiners to ensure its integrity suggest the community may be unwilling to embrace change.

Ben-Sasson says he was orange-pilled way back at the San Jose Bitcoin conference in 2013 and that former Bitcoin core devs Greg Maxwell and Mike Hearn had expressed strong interest in exploring ZK tech. He adds:

Its not a technological problem. Its only a political problem. But its a big political problem.

In fact, zk-Rollups can theoretically scale any blockchain out there, but having no capacity constraints anymore undermines the primary appeal of competing layer 1s, which is that they are either faster or cheaper than Ethereum.

There are major advantages to using the most decentralized and secure chain available. And if Bitcoin is out of the picture, Ethereums slow and cautious development could be about to pay off.

 

 

Co-founder Vitalik Buterin outlines the post Merge plans for Ethereum at Korea Blockchain Week
Co-founder Vitalik Buterin outlines the post-Merge plans for Ethereum at Korea Blockchain Week.

 

 

As Ethereum stans are fond of pointing out, its easy enough to scale blockchains if you cut corners on reliability (like Solana, which has been knocked offline half a dozen times in recent months) or just require all the nodes to spend millions buying super fancy computers to run the network (like Internet Computer).

The embrace of proof-of-stake in the Merge has been carefully designed so that a poor farmer in Ecuador running an ancient secondhand laptop can easily validate transactions on the network. (No one knows why and how a poor farmer would get the 32 ETH required to join the network with an old laptop, but it is possible.) But anyone can join a decentralized pool with a mere 0.1 ETH.

In theory, this should make it more decentralized and secure than any other smart contract chain (although not everyone agrees). Ethereum already has 420,000 validators and encouraging network effects, in terms of users, developers and apps, than any other blockchain.

 

 

 

 

So, why deploy on a competing layer 1, when its instead possible to use a layer 2 (or layer 3) solution with infinite scaling on Ethereum and spin it up as fast as you need while still inheriting Ethereums underlying decentralization and security?

We are not quite at that point yet, however, and while zk-Rollups are a key component of scaling, they dont solve all of Ethereums problems by themselves.

Starknet solves the problem of computation. It doesnt solve the problem with data availability, Ben-Sasson explains.

To simplify this to very broad brushstrokes: Basically, a zk-Rollup still has to verifiably publish enough data on-chain about the transactions it performed off-chain so that if the rollup stopped working or fell into the hands of super villains or something, then another group could step into the gap and figure out who owed what to who i.e., recreate the state. This is an important part of what makes blockchains decentralized and trustless.

While they only publish a very small amount of data on-chain, blockchains like Ethereum are extremely limited in the amount of data they can include in each block.

Warning: Technobabble

There are a few different plans to deal with the data availability bottleneck. Theres Ethereum Improvement Proposal 4488, which reduces the cost of posting data on chains with the aim of supercharging rollups. Theres proto-danksharding, which introduces blobs of data and makes data availability cheaper again, and then theres actual danksharding (named after Ethereum dev Dankrad Feist), which will allow a bunch of chains to work in parallel and enable data availability sampling (which allows blockchain nodes to verify that data for a proposed block is available without having to download the entire block).

 

 

The best of blockchain, every Tuesday

Subscribe for thoughtful explorations and leisurely reads from Magazine.



By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

 

 

If youre not a hardcore dev and that sounds like a bunch of technobabble, the important thing to note is that Ethereum blocks currently carry 50100kB of data, which will increase to around 1MB when proto-danksharding is enabled (sometime next year), and 16MB under full danksharding (sometime in the future). Or to put it another way, expect a 10x increase in the current capability within a year, and 160x in a couple of years.

The upgrades are designed to move Ethereum from a monolithic and slow blockchain, where every validator computes every transaction and stores the history of the chain, to something more like a peer-to-peer style torrenting model where the work is dispersed rather than duplicated.

(Note that the above is not a comprehensive breakdown of the many upgrades coming to Ethereum, in the hope of keeping this story vaguely coherent.)

 

 

Hold on, when did this all happen?

While hardcore Ethereans are across the plans, loads of crypto traders and enthusiasts are only vaguely aware that a lot of this is even happening. As Professor Jason Potts from the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology Blockchain Innovation Hub told Magazine in our piece about crypto critics:

This is such a fast-moving experimental space where just the knowledge gap between the frontiers and what we knew before is so vast that unless youre actually involved in the space and building, its really easy just to fundamentally misunderstand whats going on.

Its a full-time job to keep up with everything going on, and Ethereum keeps dynamically adapting its roadmap as new technology is invented and various people propose bright ideas.

An earlier Ethereum layer-2 scaling tech was called Plasma, but it proved too difficult to work with for more complicated applications. Then the roadmap for a long time was the transition to the mythical promised land of Eth2, which incorporated the Merge and scaled the blockchain with the OG version of sharding, which was like spinning up 64 Ethereum blockchains all working in unison.

 

 

Ethereum creator Vitalik Buterin
Ethereum creator Vitalik Buterin had a simple message to the devs at ETH Seoul: Build ZK apps!

 

 

Buterin ditched that plan when Optimistic Rollups and zk-Rollups began to look viable, and he published the new rollup centric roadmap in October 2020. The name Eth2 has been quietly retired ahead of the Merge, possibly because everyday users wont actually notice enough difference post-Merge to justify calling it something new. Its not going to be much faster or cheaper as a result.

During a weird virtual press conference at ETH Seoul, where he answered prescreened questions, Buterin noted that while his ideas about what needs to be done for scaling havent changed over the years, the tech has:

Today, they take advantage of a lot of technological discoveries that we have now that we did not have 10 years ago. So, like, data availability sampling… did not exist before 2017 2017 was when I published my first work on it. Optimistic and zk-Rollups did not exist, like, really before around 2019.

He described that his vision is to get Ethereum into tip-top shape as the base layer blockchain and then stop mucking around with it, with much of the scaling and experimentation to happen using layer-2 solutions.

This concept of a roll-up-centric roadmap, thats a new idea that only became possible because of the technology. Just zkSNARKS becoming a reality and becoming simpler and simpler, I think contributed a lot to that.

The moment of truth for crypto

Proper scaling, of course, will be the moment of truth for blockchain technology. Until now, most of crypto has been about hopes and dreams and speculation about what the technology will be able to do in the far-off future. Thats all about to change.

In the next 10 years, pretty much crypto has to transform into something that is, like, not based on promises of being useful in the future, but is actually useful. And I expect scaling to be the trigger for that, Buterin said.

If an application fails, after we have scaling and after we have proof-of-stake and even after we have zero-knowledge proofs, then chances are that application probably just doesnt make sense for a blockchain at all.

 

 

 

 

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC’s Short-Term Correction—What the Charts Reveal