1. Home
  2. Indonesia

Indonesia

‘Dealt with firmly’ — Bali governor issues warning to tourists using crypto

Cryptocurrency trading is legal in Indonesia, but the use of crypto in payments carries hefty penalties including jail time.

Bali’s government is cracking down on tourists paying for goods and services using cryptocurrency, with the island’s governor sending a reminder that Indonesia’s fiat currency is the only legal tender.

On May 28, the government-owned news agency Antara reported Bali’s governor Wayan Koster hosted a press conference the same day and said tourists who “use crypto as a means of payment [...] Will be dealt with firmly.”

"Strict actions range from deportation, administrative sanctions, criminal penalties, closure of business premises and other tough sanctions," he added.

The meeting was attended by Bali’s chief police inspector and Trisno Nugroho, the head of the Bali Representative Office for Bank Indonesia — the country’s central bank.

Nugroho reaffirmed that trading crypto is allowed but the use of crypto for payments is banned.

Koster noted that Indonesia’s currency — the rupiah — is the only one that can be legally used for payments in the country. The use of other currencies carries a maximum potential sentence of one year in prison and an over $13,000 fine or 200 million rupiah.

The Bali governor's announcement comes days after a May 26 investigative report in Kompas, considered the country’s newspaper of record.

Related: Indonesian government looks to NFTs to preserve cultural heritage

Kompas reportedly found multiple Bali-based businesses that accepted cryptocurrency payments including a meditation retreat, a motorbike rental business and a crypto-themed cafe.

According to data from Coinmap, a community-driven project that aims to map crypto-accepting businesses, there are 36 businesses that accept crypto, mostly concentrated in Ubud — a tourist hotspot town.

Despite the hardline stance from Bali’s governor and Indonesia, the country is on the path to rolling out a national crypto exchange by next month.

Indonesia’s Ministry of Trade would reportedly act as a custodian and clearing house for the local cryptocurrency markets. The platform was originally meant operational by the end of 2022, but suffered delays.

Magazine: Cryptocurrency trading addiction — What to look out for and how it is treated

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

Indonesia Introducing New National Payment System to Protect Against ‘Geopolitical Consequences’

Indonesia Introducing New National Payment System to Protect Against ‘Geopolitical Consequences’Indonesia is introducing a new national payment system as the country furthers its de-dollarization efforts and protection against “possible geopolitical consequences.” The new payment system will replace Visa and Mastercard in state-owned institutions and companies, a top central bank official said. “We expect that very soon it will become widespread.” Indonesia Establishes New National Payment […]

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

10 Southeast Asian Nations Challenge Dollar Dominance With Push for Local Currencies

10 Southeast Asian Nations Challenge Dollar Dominance With Push for Local CurrenciesThe leaders of 10 Southeast Asian nations, members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), have agreed to “encourage the use of local currencies for economic and financial transactions.” The group comprises Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam. This move will help them reduce their reliance on the U.S. […]

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

Indonesia Is Following BRICS De-Dollarization Lead, Says Central Bank Governor

Indonesia Is Following BRICS De-Dollarization Lead, Says Central Bank GovernorIndonesia is following the BRICS’ lead in de-dollarization and shifting away from the U.S. dollar in trade settlements and financial transactions, according to the country’s central bank governor. The BRICS nations are working on creating a common currency to reduce their USD reliance. Indonesia’s De-Dollarization Efforts Bank of Indonesia Governor Perry Warjiyo said Friday that […]

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

Study claims 99.5% of crypto investors did not pay taxes in 2022

Finland and Australia had the highest proportion of tax-paying crypto investors, while the United States ranked 10th on the list, according to the study.

Swedish crypto tax firm Divly has released a new report that estimates that only 0.53% of crypto investors globally paid tax on their crypto in 2022 — however tax experts have cast doubt on the figures and methodology. 

The Divly report published on April 5 came up with the estimate after analyzing the relationship between the number of people who declared cryptocurrency in their tax returns, and the search volume for crypto tax-related keywords in various countries. It also used the number of crypto holders in each country according to Statista's Global Cryptocurrency Report in its calculations

The report estimates that Finland has the highest proportion of crypto investors who paid the required taxes on crypto in 2022 at 4.09%, with Australia following closely behind on 3.65% respectively.

The United States ranked 10th on the list, with an estimated 1.62%, meanwhile, India, Indonesia and Philippines had the lowest rates of tax-paying crypto investors, with just 0.07%, 0.04% and 0.03% respectively.

Source: divly.com

The methodology used to arrive at the estimates is questionable. The report itself qualifies the results by noting that search volume data may not accurately reflect the actual number of crypto taxpayers, as not everyone who pays tax searches for crypto tax-related information online.

Another assumption in the methodology was that the number of searches related to crypto tax reporting did not vary across different countries. Additionally, it cautioned that there could be a potential bias towards countries with greater internet accessibility and more accurate search volume data.

Danny Talwar, global head of tax at crypto tax software Koinly, disputed the large portion of crypto investors not paying tax that the report suggests. He told Cointelegraph:

“It is likely that 99.5% is not reflective of countries that have specific crypto tax guidance and strict compliance requirements such as USA, Canada, Australia and India.”

Chartered Accountant Greg Valles, a board member of Blockchain Australia, also said he would not be able to “say conclusively that the methodology is 100 percent accurate.”

Both tax specialists noted government data matching and surveillance efforts meant it was getting progressively more difficult to avoid crypto taxes.

Valles said that as government technology gets more sophisticated and specialized, it will become easier to detect anyone that is not complying and warned that those who fail to report their crypto profits now, risk it catching up with them in future years.

Related: Biden’s policy on crypto taxation undermines his environmental goals

Talwar emphasized that although the risk of non-compliance for crypto is comparatively higher than other asset classes, tax authorities in many countries have processes in place to obtain data from crypto exchanges.

He added that Koinly has seen awareness in crypto tax “increase considerably” amongst investors in these jurisdictions, with only “15% of surveyed crypto investors” being unaware of their crypto tax reporting duties.

Magazine: Best and worst countries for crypto taxes – plus crypto tax tips

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

India to Facilitate International Settlements in Rupees to Reduce Dependence on the US Dollar

India to Facilitate International Settlements in Rupees to Reduce Dependence on the US DollarThe government of India has announced that it will facilitate the settlement of international transactions using its national currency, the rupee. As part of its foreign trading policy framework implemented on April 1, the country introduced this measure to facilitate payments for countries experiencing a U.S. dollar crush. India to Offer Rupee-Based Settlement Options for […]

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

Indonesian government looks to NFTs to preserve cultural heritage

The Deputy of Indonesia’s Ministry of Tourism and Creative Economy explains how NFTs and cryptocurrency can help solve social and economic challenges within Indonesia.

One of the primary benefits of blockchain technology is the ability to record and capture information in a permanent, tamper-proof record. Once data is on a blockchain network, it cannot be altered, making it an ideal solution for record-keeping. 

Tokenized assets, such as nonfungible tokens (NFTs), can also be placed on a blockchain. This can verify ownership while demonstrating that certain events occurred at particular times. For example, the Meta History Museum tokenized data from the war in Ukraine in May 2022, placing the information on a blockchain network to preserve records of the war.

Ensuring that specific events take place is also becoming more important than ever due to the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) and its ability to generate deep fakes, along with historical images that may appear realistic.

NFTs for preserving cultural heritage

Preserving information using decentralized technologies is gaining traction. For instance, Muhammad Neil El Himam, deputy chairman for digital economy and creative products in Indonesia’s Ministry of Tourism and Creative Economy, told Cointelegraph that he recently formed a partnership with Quantum Temple — a privacy company using NFTs for preservation — to help maintain the country’s cultural heritage. Himam explained that NFTs could ensure that heritage can be preserved and created without limits:

“I believe that NFTs can contribute to preserving Indonesia’s cultural heritage while enhancing virtual tourism. NFTs may also be a medium in ushering in the next billion users into the crypto space, especially if the NFT elements of the cultural heritage are well-known and appreciated.”

Linda Adami, CEO of Quantum Temple, told Cointelegraph that her firm developed a multichain NFT marketplace to bring cultural heritage and tourism to the Ethereum and Algorand blockchain networks. Adami explained that the platform is working closely with Indonesia’s Ministry of Tourism and Creative Economy to tokenize tangible and intangible cultural heritage as unique digital assets.

Recent: The secret of pitching to male VCs: Female crypto founders blast off

“Digital representations include traditional ceremonies, craftsmanship, and knowledge of nature and our universe, but also musical and oral expressions, dances and pilgrimages. By tokenizing cultural heritage, three critical areas of value are created: immutable archives of culture, transparent alternative income streams through royalties, verified provenance and recognition for cultural creators,” she stated.

On March 21, 2023, Quantum Temple launched its “Paths to Alangö” NFT collection at L’Atelier des Lumières in Paris, France, during Paris Blockchain Week. “The collection includes 11 unique NFTs that represent different aspects of Balinese cultural heritage, such as dances, temples, landscapes and philosophy. The NFTs are created by local artists and cultural heritage experts,” Adami said.

NFT artwork displaying a Galungan celebration at Penglipuran Village in Bali, Indonesia. Source: Quantum Temple

Adami said that technological innovations such as blockchain could play a significant role in addressing key challenges within a country’s cultural sector. 

“Authenticity and quality are fundamental to cultural heritage’s tangible and intangible value. Blockchain can be used to create an immutable and invaluable record that recognizes authorship and guarantees the authenticity and provenance of creative assets,” Adami remarked.

Harry Halpin, CEO and co-founder of decentralized privacy platform Nym, told Cointelegraph that documenting things like cultural artifacts is becoming critical to prevent manipulation. According to Halpin, blockchain technology is one of the best ways to ensure this, noting that Nym has been working with the decentralized storage provider Filecoin to document war crimes on its blockchain network.

With this potential in mind, Himam believes that it is highly likely other regions will incorporate blockchain elements in the future. “Indonesia is just one example of many developing countries that have begun to explore the potential of these technologies,” he said.

Challenges remain

While tokenized digital assets could be a solution for preserving important information, regulatory and technical challenges may hamper adoption. For instance, while Himam is bullish on blockchain technology, he noted that regulatory uncertainty within the region might create friction.

Himam said that Indonesia’s Commodity Futures Trading Regulatory Agency controls how blockchain technology is applied domestically. “Crypto assets are categorized as a commodity that can be used as the subject of futures contracts traded on an exchange,” he said. However, he added that as Indonesia begins to implement more blockchain use cases, the government will start to establish clear regulations and policies on how decentralized technologies could be applied.

It’s also notable that Indonesia’s national crypto exchange is scheduled to be completed in June 2023. According to Himam, Indonesia is showing clear interest in cryptocurrency adoption. “The country has created regulations around cryptocurrencies and is encouraging their use,” he said.

Recent: Adoption and nerves — Crypto pumps amid banking crisis

However, Indonesia’s technical infrastructure could create challenges for projects using decentralized networks. Himam pointed out that blockchain-based technologies require specialized infrastructure, such as digital wallets, which may not be widely available in certain areas in Indonesia. This, coupled with the fact that most Web3 projects require skilled professionals, could result in slow regional innovation.

Despite the challenges, Quantum Temple’s Adami believes that Asian institutions may be the furthest along in understanding blockchain-based use cases. “The Indonesian Ministry of Tourism and Creative Economy leadership understands how NFTs could offer a new funding model for the cultural and creative sector while also protecting the intellectual property rights of artists,” she remarked.

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

Crypto gateway Alchemy Pay scores license in Indonesia

Alchemy Pay has partnered with a local fintech in Indonesia to offer low-cost remittances for crypto users.

Alchemy Pay has obtained a license from the central bank of Indonesia to operate remittances and fund transfers in cooperation with local fintech firm Berkah Digital Pembayaran.

Announcing the news on Feb. 27, Alchemy Pay noted that Bank Indonesia issued the licenses jointly to Alchemy Pay and Berkah Digital’s platform BDPay, enabling the firms to offer better payout methods and reduce associated operating costs.

Fiat-to-crypto payment provider Alchemy Pay is expanding services in Asia by scoring new regulatory approval in Indonesia.

According to data from the official website of Bank Indonesia, Berkah Digital has been listed as a payment service provider under license category three. The firm is mainly known for its BDPay platform, which offers retail and corporate clients local and cross-border remittance services. The platform also provides client payroll services and transfers via bank application programming interfaces, allowing users to transfer to 136 banks in Indonesia.

Alchemy Pay’s cryptocurrency on-ramp supports payments via Mastercard, Visa, Google Pay, Apple Pay and a number of other regional mobile wallets like BDPay. The platform so far operates in 173 countries.

Related: Mastercard to allow crypto payments in Web3 via USDC settlements

Established in 2018 in Singapore, Alchemy Pay is a major global crypto-to-fiat payment platform known for partnerships with crypto giants like Binance exchange. The firm also operates its own utility token, Alchemy Pay (ACH), issued on the Ethereum blockchain. ACH is a major part of the Alchemy Pay network, providing transaction fees, network rewards and other processes.

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

3AC Co-Founder Kyle Davies Fails to Respond to Liquidators’ Subpoena Despite Twitter Delivery

3AC Co-Founder Kyle Davies Fails to Respond to Liquidators’ Subpoena Despite Twitter DeliveryAccording to recent court filings, Kyle Davies, co-founder of the defunct cryptocurrency hedge fund Three Arrows Capital (3AC), has allegedly failed to respond to a subpoena from the firm’s current liquidators, despite it being sent via Twitter. Representatives from advisory company Teneo state that Davies continues to ignore his obligations to Three Arrows. 3AC Liquidators […]

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process

Indonesia to launch national crypto exchange in 2023: Report

The platform comes as a part of the plan to shift the regulatory oversight from the commodities agency to the securities authority.

As a part of its reform of crypto regulation, Indonesia will create a crypto exchange in 2023, according to reports. The platform is planned to be launched prior to a shift of regulatory power from commodities to securities authority. 

On Jan. 4, the head of the Commodity Futures Trading Regulatory Agency of Indonesia (Bappebti), Didid Noordiatmoko, stated that a crypto exchange should be set up this year. The move comes as a part of broader financial reform launched in December 2022.

In accordance with the reform, in the next two years, the crypto oversight will be taken from Bappebti, a commodities-focused agency, by the Financial Services Authority (FSA).

The Financial Sector Development and Reinforcement bill (P2SK) was ratified by the House of Representatives of Indonesia on Dec. 15 to become the primary legal reference in the financial service sector. Explaining the shift of authority from Bappebti to the FSA, cemented by the bill, Suminto Sastrosuwito, a head of Financing and Risk Management of the national finance ministry, claimed that:

“In fact, crypto assets have become investment and financial instruments, so they need to be regulated on an equal basis with other financial and investment instruments.”

Indonesia imposed a blanket ban on crypto payments starting in 2017, while trading in digital assets has largely remained legal in the country. In the first days of January, Noordiatmoko revealed that the value of crypto transactions in the country fell by half in 2022 — from 859.4 trillion Indonesian rupiahs ($55 million) to 296.66 trillion ($19 million). 

Related: Majority of crypto exchange leadership should be comprised of citizens, say Indonesian regulators

In December, Bank of Indonesia Governor Perry Warjiyo announced the release of the conceptual design of a digital rupiah — a currency the equivalent of the country’s fiat — which will be made available for public discussion.

Brian Armstrong says Coinbase needs to ‘rethink’ its token listing process