1. Home
  2. ParaSpace NFT

ParaSpace NFT

Blue chip collaterals help stabilize NFT lending: Paraspace

"We only support blue chip NFTs to reduce the risks," said Paraspace developers.

According to a recent report published by nonfungible token (NFT) money market protocol Paraspace and multichain wallet BitKeep, the current amount of NFT borrowing and lending, or NFTFi loans, has surpassed $430 million across 43,521 borrowers. The highest proportion of collateral comprised the most popular NFT collections, such as Wrapped CryptoPunks, Bored Ape Yacht Club and Mutant Ape Yacht Club.

Researchers at Paraspace and BitKeep said that NFTFi added $25 million in outstanding loans from January to March. Also contributing was the introduction of a digital collectible lending protocol by NFT marketplace Blur, which surpassed $16 million in loans one day after its launch, led by Taiwanese celebrity Machi Big Brother. Yet, the real impetus was the invention of Bitcoin Ordinals, which boosted total NFT market transaction volume to $1.5 billion in March but shrunk to $330 million in May. Despite the growth, however, Paraspace and BitKeep researchers warned that liquidity concerns remain a constant theme in the sector:

“The lack of liquidity in NFT trading is mainly caused by limited user numbers, difficulties in pricing, and high NFT prices. We thus observe two extreme scenarios where the TOP 10 NFTs maintain a certain level of liquidity with little fluctuation between projects, while other NFTs are sold at discounts."

In a statement to Cointelegraph, Paraspace NFT developers explained that despite accumulating NFT loans of over $280 million, the protocol had just 16 NFT liquidations with no bad debt since it began operations last year. Developers say the protocol owes its success to rules allowing only the most-established and highly liquid, or blue chip NFTs, to be pledged as collateral. The entry threshold for blue chip NFTs is often very high, with an average price range between $11,000 to $120,000.

“Typically, users can only borrow ETH against a single NFT. For us, users can use a basket of NFTs + ERC20 (3 BAYC + 1 AZUKI + 2 BTC) to borrow collection assets (say 10 ETH + 10 USDT + 100 APE). This gives our platform an opportunity to aggregate liquidity into one place and thus increase the capital efficiency for liquidity."

Nevertheless, developers at both Paraspace and BitKeep cautioned that the NFTs are a new market “lacking historical data and universally recognized valuation analysis methods, resulting in pricing difficulties." As a result, different perceptions of rarity based on subjective views have led to large price variances even within the same NFT series. On the market’s future outlook, developers commented:

“High-quality NFTs often have strong community consensus, team background, and distinctive artistic styles. However, the barriers for ordinary users to participate in blue-chip or popular NFTs are increasing. Nowadays, some solutions have emerged, such as NFT fractionalization, NFT staking, and the rise of NFT liquidity platforms."

Magazine: Web3 Gamer: GTA 6 crypto rumors, Dr Who/Sandbox, Thai tourist NFTs review

Bitcoin ETFs could overtake gold ETFs in size within one month

ParaSpace team clashes with CEO over alleged whereabouts of protocol funds

Protocol developers demand that CEO and CTO Yubo Ruan step down, while Ruan has accused the development team of an "illegal takeover."

On May 10, nonfungible tokens (NFT) financialization protocol ParaSpace published several alleged irregularities tying its CEO, founder, and CTO Yubo Ruan to the mismanagement of funds equaling 2,909 Ether (ETH) recovered through a white-hat interception that occurred on March 18. Ruan denied any wrongdoing, writing: "manufacturing claims with the intent to take over and force me to step down as CEO. This is highly problematic and the legal team has taken action." 

On or around March 18, ParaSpace suffered a price-slippage exploit that was quickly resolved. Around the same time, blockchain security firm BlockSec intercepted the hack. It moved 2,909 ETH from the protocol before malicious actors could obtain the funds and subsequently returned the assets to ParaSpace staff.

According to Paraspace, Ruan had "exclusive control and management" of a portion of protocol funds returned by BlockSec. Developers subsequently allege that a portion of the 2,909 ETH believed to be in control by Ruan had "not been fully returned to protocol, with initially over 50% unreturned, leaving a hole in the protocol treasury." The development team also alleges that these assets had "outflown to various unknown wallets as well as out to CEXs and Circle redemptions," totaling $1 million.

"As a result, the team has come together, secured the protocol's multi-sig, and removed Yubo as well as any addresses not directly controlled by the team."

ParaSpace, through its official Twitter account, calls for Ruan to "step down from his roles as CEO and CTO." 

On the other hand, Ruan alleges that two former ParaSpace consultants, Thomas Schmidt and Jay Yao, who are currently stated as the protocol's COO and CBO, respectively, "have illegally obtained control of one of the protocol's multisig and social media accounts" through misrepresentation. Ruan said that upon receipt of rescued funds from BlockSec, a structured redeposit procedure was agreed to and scheduled in phases "by myself, Thomas, Jay, and other key engineering stakeholders." The CEO wrote:

"To date, following the schedule, all of the hacker's debt has been deposited back into the hacker account. The residual amount has already been paid back in full according to schedule. The mischaracterization by them is absurd, and I have nothing to hide."

Cointelegraph has not independently verified the allegations brought forth by either of the two parties. ParaSpace stated that "our top priority is to address this situation swiftly and effectively." Meanwhile, Ruan wrote, "please be aware of the legal ramifications behind these illegal takeovers action."

Magazine: Should crypto projects ever negotiate with hackers? Probably

Bitcoin ETFs could overtake gold ETFs in size within one month