1. Home
  2. rulemaking petition

rulemaking petition

Coinbase continues push to compel SEC to act on crypto rulemaking petition

Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal has once again called for a mandamus to compel the SEC to respond to the firm’s crypto rulemaking petition.

Coinbase has doubled down on its push for a court order compelling the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to act on the firm’s crypto rulemaking petition.

Coinbase wants a mandamus issued within 30 days to compel the SEC to give an official answer on whether it will accept or deny the petition.

The SEC submitted a long-awaited status update on Oct. 12, vaguely stating that “commission staff provided a recommendation” to the SEC over Coinbase’s petition, but did not divulge any further details.

In an Oct. 13 X post, Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal slammed the SEC for dragging its heels, as he called for a mandamus to force the SEC into adequately outlining its intentions.

Grewal also shared Coinbase’s response to the SEC update that it filed with the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit.

“The SEC’s unilluminating report is mere bureaucratic pantomime and confirms that nothing short of mandamus will prompt the agency to take its obligations seriously. It took more than a year and an order from this Court to elicit even a staff-level recommendation,” the response reads, adding that:

“The Commission has resolved not to conduct the rulemaking Coinbase requested, and it will exploit every bureaucratic artifice in its arsenal to forestall judicial review so long as the Court allows it.”
Coinbase's response to the SEC update. Source: Paul Grewal on X.

Coinbase initially filed the rulemaking petition in July 2022, requesting the SEC to “propose and adopt rules” to govern the crypto market, including potential rules to clearly outline which digital assets fall under the definition of securities.

After the SEC failed to respond, Coinbase filed a petition for mandamus nine months later, seeking the court to compel the SEC to give a “yes or no” answer.

Related: Coinbase spot trading volume falls by 52% compared to 2022: Report

However, the SEC has fired back on multiple occasions, refuting the need to meet Coinbase’s requirements while also asking the court to deny Coinbase’s petition for mandamus.

In mid June, the SEC then asked the court for an additional 120 days to respond to the rulemaking petition. Such a timeline suggests that the agency may have an answer by the end of October or early November.

Magazine: How to protect your crypto in a volatile market — Bitcoin OGs and experts weigh in

Bitcoin Bull Market May Drive Russian Miners Underground

SEC asks for more time to respond to Coinbase call for crypto clarity

The securities regulator said it would make a recommendation within 120 days on Coinbase’s rulemaking request, but says the action has “no merit.”

The United States securities regulator has asked for four more months to provide a response to Coinbase’s request for crypto regulatory clarity.

In a June 13 letter submitted to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) said it needs an additional 120 days to reply to Coinbase’s request that it adopt new rules and provide further clarity on the laws governing crypto.

The letter was in response to the court’s June 6 order to the SEC which asked the regulator to address if it’s denying the rulemaking or if it needs more time to respond.

The SEC said it “has not decided what action to take on that petition in whole or in part” and claimed Coinbase’s request for a writ of mandamus has “no merit.”

The regulator claimed that the mandamus petition “should be denied” but anticipated it would be able to make a recommendation on Coinbase’s petition for rulemaking “within the next 120 days.”

In response to the letter, Coinbase chief legal officer Paul Grewal informed his 40,000 Twitter followers that the SEC had repeated the “fallacy” that it was yet to decide on any new regulation.

Related: Hinman documents suggest SEC is the wrong agency to govern digital assets, crypto lawyer says

He added the letter ignored clear statements from SEC chair Gary Gensler that the SEC has “no intent to issue new rules.”

“[The SEC] instead conflate the evidence of a decision those statements provide with an argument that the statements are themselves a decision,” Grewal said.

“They refuse to commit to any deadline despite the Court's explicit order,” Grewal added.

The court’s order to the SEC came the same day the regulator sued Coinbase for offering unregistered securities and operating an unregistered securities exchange.

Magazine: Joe Lubin — The truth about ETH founders split and ‘Crypto Google’

Bitcoin Bull Market May Drive Russian Miners Underground