1. Home
  2. tokenized assets

tokenized assets

Approach with caution: US banking regulator’s crypto warning

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) said the digital asset industry was maturing but was “not yet robust” in its risk management.

A United States banking industry regulator warned banks of the “emerging risks” of cryptocurrencies saying the sector should take a “cautious approach” and seek permission in some cases when engaging with crypto or crypto firms.

Citing “dislocations” in the crypto market over 2022 the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) highlighted what it said were “several key risks” of crypto in its Dec. 8 Semiannual Risk Perspective for Fall 2022 report.

Its three main concerns are that “stablecoins may be unstable,” the crypto industry lacks mature risk management practices and has a high risk of contagion due to the “high degree of interconnectedness.”

The space’s lack of “consistent or comprehensive regulation” and the volatility of crypto along with the increased range of firms offering “bank-like products and services” using crypto and tokenized assets were also cited as concerns, which the OCC believes raises questions regarding financial stability.

The depeg and collapse of the TerraClassicUSD (USTC) algorithmic stablecoin in May was given as an example of stablecoins’ “run risk,” and how asset-backed stablecoins also saw minor depeg events as a result.

It highlighted stablecoin backings have “incrementally evolved” since, but believes most “remain susceptible to run risk.”

Discussing risk management the OCC said practices at crypto firms were maturing but are “not yet robust” with firms appearing “unprepared for the stresses and surprises” over the past year that saw losses for millions of investors, it added:

“Hacks and outages are frequent, and fraud and scams remain high throughout the industry. In some cases, ownership rights, custody arrangements, and financial representations have created a high degree of confusion.”

The crypto market over 2022 also revealed the industry’s “interconnectedness [...] through a variety of opaque lending and investing arrangements” according to the OCC.

Related: US lawmakers question federal regulators on banks' ties to crypto firms

It remarked crypto participants “may be engaging in highly leveraged trading” which resulted in the noted contagion risk.

In its advice to banks, the OCC said institutions considering engaging with crypto or crypto companies “should take a careful and incremental approach.”

The OCC advised national banks that crypto-related plans should be discussed “with their supervisory office” before they engage in any activities as some potentially require permission.

Crypto companies have moved to improve transparency in the wake of the bankruptcy of FTX with many exchanges introducing proof-of-reserves so users can verify crypto backings along with some conducting public third-party audits.

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors

Almost everything could be tokenized in 5-10 years — Matrixport co-founder

Cost efficiencies, improved liquidity, 24/7 market access, and the removal of intermediaries were the main advantages' cited which blockchain infrastructure has over current legacy systems.

In five to ten years, almost every “real world” asset class could be tokenized in the form of a nonfungible token (NFT) according to Cynthia Wu, co-founder of digital asset service platform Matrixport.

Speaking to Cointelegraph, Wu said the best case for NFTs would see the widespread representation of real-world assets to be stored and traded on-chain:

“Eventually all the major financial asset classes are going to be represented on this new financial infrastructure [and] NFTs could be our instrument to represent off-chain assets like real estate deeds, equities or bonds.”

The move on-chain would make these real world assets “more liquid and more tradable” which would improve price discovery and transaction activity, Wu added.

But Wu said that while it’s great that we’ve created over two trillion worth of digital native assets on-chain from Bitcoin (BTC), Ethereum (ETH) and other tokens, the only niche to have generated NFT transaction activity has come from digital collectibles — which hasn’t really helped institutional adoption:

“We haven't really been seeing off-chain assets being represented on-chain [...] we're now really only at the first 3-5% of it.”

But nonetheless, Wu is confident that the tide will turn.

Earlier this month, a report from Boston Consulting Group (BCG) estimated the total size of tokenized illiquid assets to reach $16.1 trillion by 2030.

BCG predicted much of this tokenization to come from pre-initial public offering (IPO) stocks, real estate, private debt, and revenue generated from small to medium-sized businesses.

However, while the tokenization of real-world assets has piqued the interest of financial institutions, Wu said some have been a bit reluctant to move on from the legacy systems that have served them well over the years.

Related: Asset tokenization: A beginner’s guide to converting real assets into digital assets

Wu pointed out the traditional financial system hasn’t accounted for the trading of nonfungible assets because they can’t easily be exchanged the same way a fungible or divisible asset can, but tokenization on the blockchain provides a solution for that.

She also argued that blockchain infrastructure is the superior option to legacy systems, citing cost efficiencies, improved liquidity, 24/7 market access, and the removal of intermediaries as the main factors that would lead to a more streamlined financial system.

Matrixport co-founder Cynthia Wu.

Matrixport was established in Feb. 2019, and currently manages between $3-4 billion in digital assets from a broad mix of retail and institutional clients.

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors

Australian Securities Exchange takes step towards tokenized asset trading

“There's a strong value proposition here that we can essentially tokenize any asset and bridge that into the ASX ecosystem,” said Zerocap CEO Ryan McCall.

Companies on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) could be able to trade tokenized bonds, equities, funds, or carbon credits after a successful proof-of-concept trial led by the digital asset investment platform Zerocap.

On Monday, Melbourne-based digital asset investment platform Zerocap told Cointelegraph it had successfully used Synfini to bridge over its custody infrastructure onto the platform as part of a trial program, allowing for the trading and clearing of Ethereum-based tokenized assets.

The trial is part of ASX’s distributed ledger technology (DLT)-based settlement project Synfini which was launched in November. The platform offers clients access to ASX’s DLT infrastructure, data hosting and ledger services, enabling them to build blockchain applications off of it.

Zerocap co-founder and CEO Ryan McCall stated that it occurred last year and that “it got a lot of interest” in the institutional sphere, particularly from companies that are exploring ways to tokenize and trade bonds, funds or carbon credits.

“Thinking beyond Bitcoin, Ethereum and other crypto assets, the tokenization of bonds, equities, property, carbon credits, private equity, and anything that's essentially illiquid, there's a strong value proposition here that we can essentially tokenize any asset and bridge that into the ASX ecosystem.”

McCall outlined that the companies dealing with especially “opaque and difficult to access markets” such as bonds and carbon credits are seeking out ways to efficiently cut costs, save time on issuance and open up broader investment access via tokenized offerings.

Questioned on whether the ASX would be able to offer crypto trading via Synfini, McCall stated “yes” but that he hasn’t seen any indicators of interest in this field, as the ASX and others are primarily focused on tokenizing traditional/real-world assets.

It is worth noting however that Synfini is a separate initiative from ASX's blockchain-based CHESS system replacement that is yet to be implemented after facing years of technical issues.

McCall went on to suggest that Zerocap could be looking to officially launch asset tokenization and trading services via Synfini to institutions in the near future, as it has just cleared the necessary steps for legal approval.

“Since then we've been going through the certification process to get into the production environment, which as you can probably imagine, for any sort of enterprise software, but certainly for an exchange, it's a fairly stringent process. So we've just cleared the production certification. So getting ready to deploy this now,” he said.

McCall also highlighted that with the ASX being a reputable source to host digital asset trading, doing so would likely dampen institutional concern over counterparty risk relating to the crypto sector.

Such risks have been thoroughly prevalent this year due to several major crypto firms either facing liquidity issues, or going completely bankrupt in the case of Celsius, Voyager Digital, and Three Arrows Capital.

“So counterparty risk, you know, credit risk specifically I guess is the biggest talking point in crypto at the moment with the 3AC disaster. And I think that just demonstrates the use case for what the ASX is trying to do here.”

“You know, thinking about the ecosystem and investor protections and all the things that it offers, there's definitely a need for something like that in digital assets,” he added.

The Zerocap CEO also suggested that Synfini will likely be utilized by a wide range of firms, as the platform is user-friendly and removes a lot of variables for companies.

“If a custodian or a fund manager or any application developer wants to come and build a blockchain application, they can do that on this Synfini platform without having to really worry about managing any of the infrastructure, which is pretty cool,” he said.

Related: ASIC chair troubled by sheer amount of ‘risk-taking’ crypto investors

Zerocap recently had a hand in a tokenized carbon credit transaction in late June, with the firm providing market-making services and liquidity for an exchange between major Australian family office Victor Smorgon Group and BetaCarbon, a blockchain-based carbon trading platform.

The deal was also facilitated via A$DC, a fully AUD collateralized stablecoin developed by “big four bank” Australian bank ANZ.

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors

Iran to Pilot ‘National Cryptocurrency,’ Considers Blockchain Tech for Stock Market

Iran to Pilot ‘National Cryptocurrency,’ Considers Blockchain Tech for Stock MarketThe Central Bank of Iran soon plans to launch the pilot phase of its digital currency project, an official unveiled. The Islamic Republic hopes to a join a growing club of nations that want to take advantage of having a sovereign coin, while it also seeks to implement blockchain technology in other areas. Iran to […]

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors

Ripple Launching Liquidity Hub Despite SEC Lawsuit Over XRP

Ripple Launching Liquidity Hub Despite SEC Lawsuit Over XRPAmid an ongoing lawsuit with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over XRP, Ripple is launching a new product, Liquidity Hub, which aims to be “a one-stop shop for enterprises to source any tokenized asset.” The product “will allow customers to seamlessly access crypto assets from a variety of global venues, including market makers, […]

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors

Arca Labs partners with Securitize on regulated, tokenized financial products

As part of its partnership with Arca Labs, Securitize will help launch tokenized financial products for the firm, starting with Arca’s registered tokenized treasury fund.

Arca Labs, the innovation arm of digital asset investment firm Arca has partnered with blockchain tech firm Securitize to launch regulated, tokenized financial products.

According to a Sept. 23 announcement, Securitize has signed on to provide a smart contract and issuance platform for the firm, starting firstly with Arca’s tokenized fund dubbed “Arca U.S. Treasury Fund” that was launched in July 2020.

Arca touts it as the first treasury fund registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940 to issue shares as digital assets via the blockchain. The fund meets the same regulatory requirements as a mutual fund, but differs by offering exposure via Ethereum-based digital asset security tokens called “ArCoin.”

Arca states that the fund will typically “invest a minimum of 80% of assets in U.S. Treasury securities.”

Securitize has taken over the fund’s transfer agent role from TokenSoft, and will be tasked with managing regulatory compliance mandates such as investor verification, know your customer and anti-money laundering policies, along with onboarding clients and issuing the fund’s shares via ArCoin. Securitize is a registered transfer agent with over 200 clients and nearly a half-billion dollars in regulated securities issued in the past three years

The transition has seen the fund’s existing outstanding balances burned and automatically reissued under Securitize’s new smart contract to each shareholder.

Additionally, there will be jointly-offered tokenized financial products that will be announced at a later date.

Related: Bitcoin-based security token offering approved in Germany

“Institutions have struggled to meet investor demand because few tokenization companies have met the rigorous regulatory and operational thresholds required by investors,” the announcement stated, adding that the firms are “seeking to channel the growth of fast-developing blockchain technologies within the existing financial services regulatory framework, which we believe to be key for increased investor trust and adoption.”

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors

Tokenized real estate inches forward despite legal, technical hurdles

A rowdy virtual panel showcased the hurdles and promise of real estate on chain

An unusually rowdy (and informative) virtual panel at the Security Token Summit yesterday reveals the fractious difficulties of bringing regulated assets on-chain — as well as the promise and progress of the tokenized real estate use case despite those hurdles. 

Michael Flight of the Liberty Fund, Jude Regev of Jointer.io, and Mohsin Masud of AKRU spoke for 30 minutes on the state of securitized real estate in a free-flowing and often-contentious discussion that highlighted the complexities that arise when decentralized finance and stringent governmental oversight meet. Host Kiran Arif of AKRU seldom spoke.

When asked why tokenized real estate is so exciting, Flight pointed to the size of the market and to how few investors can gain exposure to it.

“You’ve got 280 trillion dollars of real estate assets, and tokenized real estate is gonna let all investors into that asset class,” he said.

Mohsin concurred, noting that high prices and regulations have traditionally kept average investors out of the real estate market, aside from purchases like homes.

“We want to offer these securities, these asset-backed securities, to people who traditionally haven’t had access.”

Regulatory shackles 

While the promise of the use case is significant and has been pondered over for close to a decade, aside from a handful of experiments there has been little significant traction. 

Part of the reason, according to Regev, is the friction from bringing a regulated asset to a decentralized system.

“It can’t work,” he said.

He compared current digital real estate to “digital paper,” saying that all of the legal requirements and barriers surrounding real estate remain functionally identical regardless of whether its a digital or physical format, and as a result unaccredited investors still can’t have access.

Likewise, he expressed doubt that such tokens would ever be listed on exchanges or achieve any significant liquidity, rendering the use case useless.

“You remember the days of timesharing, it sounds so good? And when you’re into it, you can’t get out? That’s pretty much what it is,” he said, comparing tokenization to a “magic word” with little substance.

Something is better than nothing

Mohsin rejected many of these points, pointing out that REITs and other real estate-backed products have managed to achieve significant liquidity. Moreover, he noted that there are 12.5 million accredited investor households in the US who could benefit (more recent data suggests there are 13.6 million), even if tokenized real estate doesn’t fully “democratize” the market. 

Flight also pointed out the significant advanced in utility that can be made with tokenized real estate. He said that Liberty is working with centralized crypto lender Blockfi to allow real estate-backed security tokens to be used as collateral, and even to earn interest as a yield-bearing asset.

While he remained suspicious regardless of these points, Regev also made a stirring call for platforms and issuers taking responsibility for users if the use case is ever to gain significant traction.

“We need to protect the simple person who is busy, busy to survive, and wants their money to work for them.” 

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors

Domestic and Foreign Buyers Acquired a ‘Tokenized’ Apartment in a Spanish City by Paying With Ethereum

Domestic and Foreign Buyers Acquired a ‘Tokenized’ Apartment in a Spanish City by Paying With EthereumNational and foreign buyers acquired a “tokenized” apartment in Spain with ethereum, which involved a domestic crypto exchange and a real estate investment firm. The city of Sevilla was the scenario for the crypto deal between the parties. Transaction Was Worth Over $64,000 According to El Correo Web, the Spanish crypto exchange Criptan and the […]

SEC Slaps Digital Currency Group With $38,000,000 Fine, Claims Crypto Venture Firm Misled Investors